Supreme Court Case Commentaries

Prolonged Post-Acquittal Detention Requires Meaningful, Rehabilitation-Oriented Compensation

Date: Nov 18, 2026

Prolonged Post-Acquittal Detention Requires Meaningful, Rehabilitation-Oriented Compensation Case: DEVILAL GOND v. STATE OF CHHATTISGARH Citation: 2026 INSC 1226 Court: Supreme Court of India Date:...

Probationary Discharge: A Substance-Based Framework for Distinguishing Unsuitability from Punitive Stigma

Date: Nov 18, 2026

Probationary Discharge: A Substance-Based Framework for Distinguishing Unsuitability from Punitive Stigma Case: DR. G. SRINIVASAN v. UNION OF INDIA Citation: 2026 INSC 1218 Court: Supreme Court of...

Unauthorised Absence Is Not Necessarily Wilful: Disciplinary Findings Require Evidence and Punishment Must Be Proportionate

Date: Nov 18, 2026

Unauthorised Absence Is Not Necessarily Wilful: Disciplinary Findings Require Evidence and Punishment Must Be Proportionate Case: MITHILESH KUMAR PATHAK v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. Citation: 2026 INSC...

Indoor Management: An Outside Purchaser Need Not Prove a Company’s Internal Board Proceedings

Date: Nov 18, 2026

Indoor Management: An Outside Purchaser Need Not Prove a Company’s Internal Board Proceedings Case: ELAINE INFO SOLUTIONS PVT. LTD. v. M/S. J AND A AVENUES INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED Citation: 2026 INSC...

SICA Rehabilitation Schemes: Contingent Claimants Cannot Escape Binding Debt Reductions

Date: Nov 18, 2026

SICA Rehabilitation Schemes: Contingent Claimants Cannot Escape Binding Debt Reductions Case: M/S. GANESH BENZOPLAST LTD. v. THE STATE TRADING CORPORATION OF INDIA Citation: 2026 INSC 1223 | Court:...

Police Statements Cannot Become Substantive Evidence When Witnesses Turn Hostile: Proof, Recovery and Parity in Criminal Trials

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Police Statements Cannot Become Substantive Evidence When Witnesses Turn Hostile: Proof, Recovery and Parity in Criminal Trials Case: NARESH v. STATE OF HARYANA Citation: 2026 INSC 1220 Court:...

Civil Findings Cannot Be Reversed on Suspicion: Evidence-Based Appellate Review in Electrocution Claims

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Civil Findings Cannot Be Reversed on Suspicion: Evidence-Based Appellate Review in Electrocution Claims Case: REKHA v. JAIPUR VIDYUT VITRAN NIGAM LIMITED Citation: 2026 INSC 1216 Court: Supreme Court...

Introducing a Written Test During Recruitment: Permissible Procedural Refinement Where Rules Allow Competitive Selection and Fairness Is Preserved

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Introducing a Written Test During Recruitment: Permissible Procedural Refinement Where Rules Allow Competitive Selection and Fairness Is Preserved Case: T. AKON PHOM v. STATE OF NAGALAND Citation:...

Automatic Forest Vesting Requires Statutory Qualification: Probabilistic Proof and Limits on Belated Evidence

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Automatic Forest Vesting Requires Statutory Qualification: Probabilistic Proof and Limits on Belated Evidence Case: STATE OF KERALA & ANR. v. P. KRISHNA PILLAI & ORS. Citation: 2026 INSC 1212 Court:...

Defective Insolvency Plans: Legality-Based Remand, Not Judicial Rewriting, and the Exclusion of Subsidiary Assets

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Defective Insolvency Plans: Legality-Based Remand, Not Judicial Rewriting, and the Exclusion of Subsidiary Assets Case: TWINSTAR TECHNOLOGIES LIMITED v. BANK OF MAHARASHTRA Citation: 2026 INSC 1214 |...

No Coparcenary Right by Birth in a Father’s Share Inherited Under Section 8 and Allotted on Partition

Date: Nov 9, 2026

No Coparcenary Right by Birth in a Father’s Share Inherited Under Section 8 and Allotted on Partition Case: J. Rajesh (Minor), through his mother and natural guardian J. Gomathi v. M. Kumaran (Dead),...

Public-Interest Compulsory Retirement: Uncommunicated Adverse Entries Remain Relevant, and Regularisation Does Not Erase Performance Deficiencies

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Public-Interest Compulsory Retirement: Uncommunicated Adverse Entries Remain Relevant, and Regularisation Does Not Erase Performance Deficiencies Case: CHATUR SINGH DHRUW v. THE STATE OF...

National Book Trust Is “State” under Article 12: Pervasive Government Control Prevails over Society Status and Independent Revenue

Date: Nov 6, 2026

National Book Trust Is “State” under Article 12: Pervasive Government Control Prevails over Society Status and Independent Revenue Case: THE CHAIRMAN NATIONAL BOOK TRUST INDIA . v. AR ABDUL GAFFAR ....

Megamalai Forest Rights: Primary Residence, Statutory Scrutiny and Time-Bound Judicial Supervision

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Megamalai Forest Rights: Primary Residence, Statutory Scrutiny and Time-Bound Judicial Supervision Case: A JOHN KENNEDY v. STATE OF TAMIL NADU Citation: 2026 INSC 1204 Court: Supreme Court of India...

OBC Creamy-Layer Ruling Governs Pending Allocations Without Automatically Reopening Concluded Selections

Date: Nov 6, 2026

OBC Creamy-Layer Ruling Governs Pending Allocations Without Automatically Reopening Concluded Selections Case: UNION OF INDIA v. ROHITH NATHAN AND ANR ETC. Citation: 2026 INSC 1201 Court: Supreme...

Finality of Inter-State Power Decrees: Energy-Arrears Settlement Through Capital-Cost Set-Off

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Finality of Inter-State Power Decrees: Energy-Arrears Settlement Through Capital-Cost Set-Off Case: STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH v. UNION OF INDIA Citation: 2026 INSC 1200 Court: Supreme Court of India...

Fatal School Construction Accidents: Mere Supervisory Negligence Does Not Establish Criminal Liability for Death

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Fatal School Construction Accidents: Mere Supervisory Negligence Does Not Establish Criminal Liability for Death Case: MATIN SHANKARRAO BHOSALE v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA Citation: 2026 INSC 1198 Court:...

Reversing an Acquittal: Charge-Based Fairness, Conflicting Dying Declarations and the Limits of Section 106

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Reversing an Acquittal: Charge-Based Fairness, Conflicting Dying Declarations and the Limits of Section 106 Case: SAU. KAMALBAI WAMAN PATIL v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA Citation: 2026 INSC 1196 |...

Article 22(2): The 24-Hour Clock Begins with Actual Restraint, Not Formal Arrest

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Article 22(2): The 24-Hour Clock Begins with Actual Restraint, Not Formal Arrest Case: SUJIT DAS v. UNION OF INDIA Citation: 2026 INSC 1195 Court: Supreme Court of India Date: 5 November 2026 Bench:...

Pre-Registration Rejection of Plaints: Limited Judicial Scrutiny and Mandatory Recordkeeping

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Pre-Registration Rejection of Plaints: Limited Judicial Scrutiny and Mandatory Recordkeeping Case: G. PAZHANIVEL v. S. THILAGAVATHY Citation: 2026 INSC 1197 Court: Supreme Court of India Date: 5...