All High Courts Case Commentaries

Promulgation-as-Commencement Rule in Sports Selection: Selection Window Runs From Public Upload of Criteria; Preliminary Minutes Not Final Selection

Date: Sep 22, 2026

Promulgation-as-Commencement Rule in Sports Selection: Selection Window Runs From Public Upload of Criteria; Preliminary Minutes Not Final Selection 1. Introduction The Delhi High Court in VAASVI...

Juvenile Bail Under Section 12 JJ Act Prevails Despite NDPS Commercial Quantity: Gravity Not a Standalone Ground to Refuse Bail

Date: Sep 22, 2026

Juvenile Bail Under Section 12 JJ Act Prevails Despite NDPS Commercial Quantity: Gravity Not a Standalone Ground to Refuse Bail 1. Introduction The Patna High Court, in XX (CICL) v. D.R.I. Patna...

Failed Sterilisation Does Not Presume Medical Negligence: Compensation Lies Only on Proof of Negligent Surgery or Specific Assurance

Date: Sep 22, 2026

Failed Sterilisation Does Not Presume Medical Negligence: Compensation Lies Only on Proof of Negligent Surgery or Specific Assurance 1. Introduction In Lady Kishwar v. State Of M.P. and Others (2026...

NDPS Vehicle Release on Supurdginama: Trial Courts Must Apply Bishwajit Dey Flexibly and Decide on Merits

Date: Sep 22, 2026

NDPS Vehicle Release on Supurdginama: Trial Courts Must Apply Bishwajit Dey Flexibly and Decide on Merits Case: Lokendra Alias Golu v. The State Of Madhya Pradesh Citation: 2026 MPHC-GWL 28101 Court:...

Persistent Dowry-Demand Cruelty in a Short Marriage Satisfies “Soon Before Death” Under Section 304-B IPC Despite Minor Improvements and No Injury Marks

Date: Sep 22, 2026

Persistent Dowry-Demand Cruelty in a Short Marriage Satisfies “Soon Before Death” Under Section 304-B IPC Despite Minor Improvements and No Injury Marks Case: NAVEEN KUMAR VERMA & ANR. v. STATE...

Role-Specific Allegations of Supporting Talaq May Justify Anticipatory Bail

Date: Sep 22, 2026

Role-Specific Allegations of Supporting or Instigating Talaq May Justify Anticipatory Bail Where Custodial Arrest Is Unwarranted Case: RAHIMABEN ABDULKARIM MANASIYA v. STATE OF GUJARAT Court: Gujarat...

Multiple Personal Disputes Cannot Justify Preventive Detention Without a Demonstrable Threat to Public Order

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Multiple Personal Disputes Cannot Justify Preventive Detention Without a Demonstrable Threat to Public Order Case: MOHD YOUSUF TH. HIS WIFE FARIDA BI v. UT OF J AND K TH. ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY...

Bihar Prison Remission Must Be Transparent, Reviewable and Non-Discriminatory

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Bihar Prison Remission Must Be Transparent, Reviewable and Non-Discriminatory Case: In view of minutes dt- 17.12.25 of Hon'ble The A.C.J. based on SLP(Crl) No. 529/21 v. The State of Bihar through...

Repeated Drug-Trafficking Conduct Despite Bail May Justify PITNDPS Preventive Detention

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Repeated Drug-Trafficking Conduct Despite Bail May Justify PITNDPS Preventive Detention Where Procedural Safeguards Are Observed Case: FIRDOUS AHMAD MIR v. UNION TERRITORY OF J AND K (HOME) AND ORS...

Pre-Trial Amendment May Add a Mesne-Profits Claim Arising from the Same Tenancy Dispute

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Pre-Trial Amendment May Add a Mesne-Profits Claim Arising from the Same Tenancy Dispute Case: ZAHOOR AHMAD DAR v. MYMOONA AND OTHERS Court: High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh at Srinagar Coram:...

Baseless Allegations of “Match Fixing” and Forgery Against Courts Constitute Criminal Contempt

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Baseless Allegations of “Match Fixing” and Forgery Against Courts Constitute Criminal Contempt Case: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA v. SRI H P SABJAN Court: High Court of Karnataka, Bengaluru Coram: D K...

Selection Against a Sanctioned Cadre Post Cannot Be Converted into Perpetual Contractual Employment

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Selection Against a Sanctioned Cadre Post Cannot Be Converted into Perpetual Contractual Employment Case: Pradeep Kumar v. State Of U.P. Through Special Secy. Govt. Of U.P. Civil Sece Neutral...

Section 20 UAPA Cannot Rest on Mere Association: Involvement in a Terrorist Act Is Essential

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Section 20 UAPA Cannot Rest on Mere Association: Involvement in a Terrorist Act Is Essential Case: DAWOOD v. UT OF J AND K TH NATIONAL INVESTIGATION AGENCY, JAMMU Court: High Court of Jammu & Kashmir...

A Disowned and Unverified Complaint Cannot Sustain Vigilance Proceedings

Date: Sep 18, 2026

A Disowned and Unverified Complaint Cannot Sustain Vigilance Proceedings: Consequential Action Falls with an Invalid Foundation Case: Abhishek Prakash v. State Of U.P. Thru. Deptt. Of Appointment And...

A Corrigendum Cannot Expand a Completed Land Acquisition: Fresh Proceedings Required for Additional Land

Date: Sep 18, 2026

A Corrigendum Cannot Expand a Completed Land Acquisition: Fresh Proceedings Required for Additional Land Case: Smt. Gitanjali Saha v. The State of Tripura and 3 Others Court: Tripura High Court,...

Women’s Doubles Teams Require a Proper Event-Specific Selection Process

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Women’s Doubles Teams Require a Proper Event-Specific Selection Process and Cannot Be Formed Merely from Singles Selections Case: DR RAJALAKSHMI SHANKAR JANARDHANA MURTHY v. THE SECRETARY REPBY UNION...

Statutory Transfer Does Not Restart Limitation: A Transferred First Appeal Retains Its Original Procedural Status

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Statutory Transfer Does Not Restart Limitation: A Transferred First Appeal Retains Its Original Procedural Status Case: STATE OF GUJARAT v. SAMANTSINH GOPALSINH RATHOD Court: Gujarat High Court Date:...

Mere Police Intimation Without Formal Charges Cannot Withhold an Otherwise Due Promotion

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Mere Police Intimation Without Formal Charges Cannot Withhold an Otherwise Due Promotion Case: SHRI M N KHAJA HUSSAIN v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA Court: Karnataka High Court, Dharwad Bench Date: 15...

Registrar Cannot Invoke Section 125 to Curtail a Cooperative Credit Society’s Staffing Autonomy

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Registrar Cannot Invoke Section 125 to Curtail a Cooperative Credit Society’s Staffing Autonomy Case: POORAN SINGH MEENA v. STATE OF RAJ AND ORS. Citation: 2026 RJ-JP 37114 Court: Rajasthan High...

Mere Assertion of Abscondence Cannot Justify Delayed Execution of a Preventive Detention Order

Date: Sep 15, 2026

Mere Assertion of Abscondence Cannot Justify Delayed Execution of a Preventive Detention Order Case: FIRDOUS AHMAD DAR v. UNION TERRITORY OF J AND K AND ORS. (HOME DEPARTMENT) Court: High Court of...