state Case Commentaries

Direct-Appeal Ineffective Assistance Claims Must Be Record-Based; Pro Se Appellants Must Cite the Record and Authority (State v. B. Ackerman)

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Direct-Appeal Ineffective Assistance Claims Must Be Record-Based; Pro Se Appellants Must Cite the Record and Authority (State v. B. Ackerman) 1. Introduction In State v. B. Ackerman, 2026 MT 196N,...

Stipulation and Failure to Object Waive Appellate Claims for Elapsed (Street) Time Credit in Revocation Sentencing

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Stipulation and Failure to Object Waive Appellate Claims for Elapsed (Street) Time Credit in Revocation Sentencing 1. Introduction State v. R. Jore (Mont. Sup. Ct. Aug. 18, 2026) addresses a...

Specific Jurisdiction Requires Forum-Directed Affirmative Acts; Alleged Policy Omissions by a National Organization Do Not Suffice

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Specific Jurisdiction Requires Forum-Directed Affirmative Acts; Alleged Policy Omissions by a National Organization Do Not Suffice 1. Introduction E.T. v. the Boys and Girls Club of Hudson County...

State v. Engel: Warndahl Attenuation Governs Suppression of New Crimes Committed in Response to Unconstitutional Seizures

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Warndahl Attenuation Governs Suppression of “New Crime” Evidence Following an Unconstitutional Seizure (and Vehicular Flight May Be Admissible) Case: State of Minnesota v. Nicholas Norton Engel...

Mailing to a Property Owner’s Last Known Address “Provides” the § 12-63c Income-and-Expense Form; Actual Receipt Not Required

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Mailing to a Property Owner’s Last Known Address “Provides” the § 12-63c Income-and-Expense Form; Actual Receipt Not Required 1. Introduction Case: Greenwich Retail, LLC v. Town of Greenwich (Supreme...

Conditional Global Pleas: Prevailing on a Reserved Suppression Issue Can Permit Withdrawal of the Entire “Plea” When the Suppressed Evidence Was Also Material to the Companion Indictment

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Conditional Global Pleas: Prevailing on a Reserved Suppression Issue Can Permit Withdrawal of the Entire “Plea” When the Suppressed Evidence Was Also Material to the Companion Indictment Case: State...

Limited “Sharing” Protective Orders Are Permissible Under Alabama Rule 26—But Must Be Case-Specific, Jurisdiction-Binding, and Return/Destroy-Coordinated

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Limited “Sharing” Protective Orders Are Permissible Under Alabama Rule 26—But Must Be Case-Specific, Jurisdiction-Binding, and Return/Destroy-Coordinated Case: Ex parte State Farm Fire and Casualty...

Substantive Due Process Bars Predatory-Offender Registration Triggered by a Predatory Charge Ending in a Trial Judgment of Acquittal

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Substantive Due Process Bars Predatory-Offender Registration Triggered by a Predatory Charge Ending in a Trial Judgment of Acquittal 1. Introduction In Chad Loran Siegel v. Drew Evans (Minn. Aug. 19,...

Trustee Appointment Is a Condition Precedent to Commencing a Minnesota Wrongful Death Action

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Trustee Appointment Is a Condition Precedent to Commencing a Minnesota Wrongful Death Action Case: Keith D Hagfors, as Trustee for the Next of Kin of Sara E Hagfors v. Fairview Health Services, et...

Zielinski “Reasonable-Probability” Standard Governs Denials of Vacatur Petitions Under the 2023 Felony-Murder Relief Act

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Zielinski “Reasonable-Probability” Standard Governs Denials of Vacatur Petitions Under the 2023 Felony-Murder Relief Act Case: Ryan Grant v. State of Minnesota Court: Supreme Court of Minnesota Date:...

Fundamental Fairness Limits § 12-63c Penalties When the Assessor’s Notice Is Not Reasonably Calculated to Reach the Owner

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Fundamental Fairness Limits § 12-63c Penalties When the Assessor’s Notice Is Not Reasonably Calculated to Reach the Owner 1. Introduction In Greenwich Retail, LLC v. Greenwich (Concurrence &...

Early Voting Requires Election Judges: Minnesota Election-Day Judge Duties Apply Throughout the 18-Day Early Voting Period

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Early Voting Requires Election Judges: Minnesota Election-Day Judge Duties Apply Throughout the 18-Day Early Voting Period 1. Introduction In Minnesota Voters Alliance v. City of Minneapolis (Minn....

State v. Sims (Kan. 2026): Noncompliance with a Supreme Court Remand-Filing Order Can Forfeit Review and Leave an Adverse Prejudice Finding Intact

Date: Aug 21, 2026

State v. Sims (Kan. 2026): Noncompliance with a Supreme Court Remand-Filing Order Can Forfeit Review and Leave an Adverse Prejudice Finding Intact 1. Introduction State v. Sims, No. 114,959 (Kan....

State v. Brown (Kan. 2026): Disapproving “Fundamental Failure” and Re-Centering Mistrial Review on Abuse of Discretion Under K.S.A. 22-3423(1)(c)

Date: Aug 21, 2026

State v. Brown (Kan. 2026): Disapproving “Fundamental Failure” and Re-Centering Mistrial Review on Abuse of Discretion Under K.S.A. 22-3423(1)(c) Case: State v. Brown, No. 128,178 (Kan. Aug. 14,...

Severance-of-Title Creates an Appurtenant Parking Easement; Post-Conveyance “Release” by a Non-Owner Is Ineffective

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Severance-of-Title Creates an Appurtenant Parking Easement; Post-Conveyance “Release” by a Non-Owner Is Ineffective Case: James R. McCann v. Brittany Bower & a. Court: Supreme Court of New Hampshire...

Estoppel by Deed Creates an Easement from a Deed’s “Abuttal” Reference Even Where the Way Runs Perpendicularly; Bad-Faith Fee Shifting Limited to Costs of an Unnecessary Separate Quiet Title Action

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Estoppel by Deed Creates an Easement from a Deed’s “Abuttal” Reference Even Where the Way Runs Perpendicularly; Bad-Faith Fee Shifting Limited to Costs of an Unnecessary Separate Quiet Title Action...

Quiet Title Judgments Must Depict Both the Historic Easement and Its Prescriptive Extinguishment; Remand Cannot Be Used to Reroute Access

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Quiet Title Judgments Must Depict Both the Historic Easement and Its Prescriptive Extinguishment; Remand Cannot Be Used to Reroute Access Introduction In Donald Edward Bloom, Deborah Jane Bloom, and...

Intertribal Consortium Arm-of-the-Tribe Immunity Under Ito; Tribal Plaintiffs Waive Immunity to Rule 82 Fees by Filing Suit

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Intertribal Consortium Arm-of-the-Tribe Immunity Under Ito; Tribal Plaintiffs Waive Immunity to Rule 82 Fees by Filing Suit 1. Introduction In Dot Lake Village v. Dená Nená Henash, d/b/a Tanana...

State v. Nickels: Jury Must Decide Disputed “Dwelling” (and Initial Aggressor) Facts Governing Nebraska’s No-Retreat Privilege

Date: Aug 21, 2026

State v. Nickels: Jury Must Decide Disputed “Dwelling” (and Initial Aggressor) Facts Governing Nebraska’s No-Retreat Privilege I. Introduction In State v. Nickels, 322 Neb. 1 (Aug. 14, 2026), the...

Prospective Population-Class Statutes Are Still “Local or Special” When the Range Is Irrationally Narrow and Targets a Single County; Permanent Multi‑Project Tax Mandates Regulate County Business Under Nev. Const. art. 4, § 20

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Prospective Population-Class Statutes Are Still “Local or Special” When the Range Is Irrationally Narrow and Targets a Single County; Permanent Multi‑Project Tax Mandates Regulate County Business...