Texas Case Commentaries

Oral Nicotine Pouches as “Tobacco Products”: “Tobacco Substitute” Includes Plant-Matter-and-Nicotine Replacements for Pulverized Tobacco

Date: May 9, 2026

Oral Nicotine Pouches as “Tobacco Products”: “Tobacco Substitute” Includes Plant-Matter-and-Nicotine Replacements for Pulverized Tobacco Introduction In Kelly Hancock, Acting Comptroller of Public...

Accord and Satisfaction by “Full & Final Settlement” Check: Cashing the Check Discharges Claims Despite Strike-Through

Date: May 9, 2026

Accord and Satisfaction by “Full & Final Settlement” Check: Cashing the Check Discharges Claims Despite Strike-Through 1. Introduction In The Bryant Law Firm and Deborah E. Bryant v. Robert Walker...

Direct Tax-Payment Injury Confers Standing Without “Taxpayer Standing”; “Governmental Disruption” Is Not a Standing Bar

Date: May 9, 2026

Direct Tax-Payment Injury Confers Standing Without “Taxpayer Standing”; “Governmental Disruption” Is Not a Standing Bar I. Introduction In Ryan Busse, Josh Klostermann, Russel Klostermann, Layne...

Rule 91a Dismissal When Petition Establishes § 452.056(d) Immunity for DART’s Private Operator—even Against Fraud Claims

Date: May 9, 2026

Rule 91a Dismissal When Petition Establishes § 452.056(d) Immunity for DART’s Private Operator—even Against Fraud Claims I. Introduction In MV Transportation, Inc. v. GDS Transport, LLC (Tex. May 8,...

Section 18.001’s “Unless” Clause as an All-or-Nothing Bar: Any Compliant Counteraffidavit Defeats Affidavit Admissibility

Date: May 6, 2026

Section 18.001’s “Unless” Clause as an All-or-Nothing Bar: Any Compliant Counteraffidavit Defeats Affidavit Admissibility Case: Tatia Ortiz v. Ramu Nelapatla Court: Supreme Court of Texas Date: May...

Partial Section 18.001 Counteraffidavits: Unchallenged Medical-Expense Portions Remain Admissible (and Counteraffidavits May Prove the Reasonable Portion)

Date: May 5, 2026

Partial Section 18.001 Counteraffidavits: Unchallenged Medical-Expense Portions Remain Admissible (and Counteraffidavits May Prove the Reasonable Portion) I. Introduction Parties: Tatia Ortiz...

Commissioner’s § 481.034(g) Objections Are Effectively Unreviewable and Not Subject to APA Rulemaking; Courts May Not Enjoin Agencies to “Rewrite” Controlled-Substance Schedules

Date: May 5, 2026

Commissioner’s § 481.034(g) Objections Are Effectively Unreviewable and Not Subject to APA Rulemaking; Courts May Not Enjoin Agencies to “Rewrite” Controlled-Substance Schedules 1. Introduction In...

Temporary-Injunction Relief Can Confer “Prevailing Party” Status Under Texas Education Code § 11.1512; § 11.1512(c-2) Creates a No-Exhaustion Path to Court

Date: Apr 29, 2026

Temporary-Injunction Relief Can Confer “Prevailing Party” Status Under Texas Education Code § 11.1512; § 11.1512(c-2) Creates a No-Exhaustion Path to Court I. Introduction Case: WEBB CONSOLIDATED...

Permissive-Appeal Jurisdiction Encompasses Fairly Included Subsidiary Issues, Including the Presumed-Grant Doctrine in Double-Fraction Royalty Disputes

Date: Apr 29, 2026

Permissive-Appeal Jurisdiction Encompasses Fairly Included Subsidiary Issues, Including the Presumed-Grant Doctrine in Double-Fraction Royalty Disputes Case: BOREN DESCENDANTS AND ROYALTY OWNERS v....

Mootness from Closed DFPS Investigations and Children’s Majority; Speculative Provider Harms Defeat Standing for Injunctive Relief

Date: Apr 29, 2026

Mootness from Closed DFPS Investigations and Children’s Majority; Speculative Provider Harms Defeat Standing for Injunctive Relief I. Introduction These consolidated matters arise from three...

Permanent Closure and Aging Out Moot Injunction Challenges to DFPS Investigations; Speculative Provider Harms Do Not Confer Standing

Date: Apr 29, 2026

Permanent Closure and Aging Out Moot Injunction Challenges to DFPS Investigations; Speculative Provider Harms Do Not Confer Standing I. Introduction In these consolidated interlocutory appeals, the...

Permissive-Appeal Scope Includes Fairly Included Issues Like the Presumed-Grant Doctrine in Double-Fraction Royalty Disputes

Date: Apr 29, 2026

Permissive-Appeal Scope Includes Fairly Included Issues Like the Presumed-Grant Doctrine in Double-Fraction Royalty Disputes I. Introduction This Supreme Court of Texas per curiam opinion arises out...

Temporary Injunction as Merits-Dispositive Relief Under Texas Education Code § 11.1512: Fees Survive Mootness and No Administrative Exhaustion Required

Date: Apr 29, 2026

Temporary Injunction as Merits-Dispositive Relief Under Texas Education Code § 11.1512: Fees Survive Mootness and No Administrative Exhaustion Required I. Introduction In WEBB CONSOLIDATED...

Texas Public Information Act: Post-Request “Confidentiality” Inquiry and Resetting the 10-Business-Day Attorney General Deadline

Date: Apr 18, 2026

Texas Public Information Act: Post-Request “Confidentiality” Inquiry and Resetting the 10-Business-Day Attorney General Deadline 1. Introduction Case: Texas Commission on Environmental Quality v. Ken...

Public Information Act Deadlines Reset by Good-Faith Narrowing Requests; Omission of Withdrawal Warning Does Not Forfeit Reset; Mailbox Rule Timeliness May Be Proven in Court

Date: Apr 18, 2026

Public Information Act Deadlines Reset by Good-Faith Narrowing Requests; Omission of Withdrawal Warning Does Not Forfeit Reset; Mailbox Rule Timeliness May Be Proven in Court Introduction In Texas...

Texas Appellate “Order of Operations”: Rendition Issues Must Be Decided Before Remand; Harm Analysis Must Review the Whole Record

Date: Apr 18, 2026

Texas Appellate “Order of Operations”: Rendition Issues Must Be Decided Before Remand; Harm Analysis Must Review the Whole Record Case: Ron Valk d/b/a Platinum Construction v. Copper Creek...

“Free of Cost Forever” Does Not Shift Royalty Valuation Downstream Absent Clear Valuation-Point or Gross-Proceeds Language (Tex. 2026)

Date: Apr 16, 2026

“Free of Cost Forever” Does Not Shift Royalty Valuation Downstream Absent Clear Valuation-Point or Gross-Proceeds Language (Tex. 2026) I. Introduction In Fasken Oil and Ranch, Ltd., Fasken Land and...

Constructive Notice in Texas Slip-and-Fall Cases Requires Evidence of Hazard Duration at the Time and Place of Injury

Date: Apr 11, 2026

Constructive Notice in Texas Slip-and-Fall Cases Requires Evidence of Hazard Duration at the Time and Place of Injury I. Introduction H-E-B, L.P. v. Marissa Peterson is a premises-liability...

Section 21.105 as a Threshold Bar: No Chapter 21 Disability-Liability When the Condition Objectively Impairs Reasonable Job Performance

Date: Apr 11, 2026

Section 21.105 as a Threshold Bar: No Chapter 21 Disability-Liability When the Condition Objectively Impairs Reasonable Job Performance Case: Texas Department of Public Safety v. Robert Christopher...

“All Laws” Clauses Incorporate Later-Enacted PURA Pole-Attachment Limits and Make Them Contract-Enforceable

Date: Apr 11, 2026

“All Laws” Clauses Incorporate Later-Enacted PURA Pole-Attachment Limits and Make Them Contract-Enforceable I. Introduction In Spectrum Gulf Coast, LLC v. City of San Antonio, acting by and through...