Texas Case Commentaries

“Allocable Share” Proportionate Indemnity Does Not Authorize Post‑Settlement Cost-Shifting Absent Express Language

Date: Mar 14, 2026

“Allocable Share” Proportionate Indemnity Does Not Authorize Post‑Settlement Cost-Shifting Absent Express Language I. Introduction This commentary addresses Justice Bland’s dissent (joined by...

Contractual Proportional Indemnity Survives Voluntary Settlement and Accrues at Settlement

Date: Mar 14, 2026

Contractual Proportional Indemnity Survives Voluntary Settlement and Accrues at Settlement Case: S&B Engineers & Constructors, Ltd. and Zurich American Insurance Company v. Scallon Controls, Inc....

Express 1/128 “Product Fraction” and Explanatory Parenthetical Rebut Van Dyke’s Double-Fraction Presumption; Future-Lease Royalty Construed as Fixed When Measured from the Whole Tract

Date: Mar 14, 2026

Express 1/128 “Product Fraction” and Explanatory Parenthetical Rebut Van Dyke’s Double-Fraction Presumption; Future-Lease Royalty Construed as Fixed When Measured from the Whole Tract Introduction...

Probate Finality in Texas: An Order Admitting a Will Is Not Appealable When It Expressly Leaves Pending Objections Unruled

Date: Feb 16, 2026

Probate Finality in Texas: An Order Admitting a Will Is Not Appealable When It Expressly Leaves Pending Objections Unruled Introduction In the Estate of J. Hugh Wheatfall, Deceased is a Texas...

Undefined “Windstorm” Unambiguously Includes Tornadoes in Texas Homeowners Policies

Date: Feb 16, 2026

Undefined “Windstorm” Unambiguously Includes Tornadoes in Texas Homeowners Policies Case: Privilege Underwriters Reciprocal Exchange v. Jeff Mankoff and Staci Mankoff Court: Supreme Court of Texas...

Enforcement Jurisdiction Persists Despite Overbroad Relief, but Home-Sale Proceeds May Be Set Off Only to Proven Chapter 9 Damages

Date: Feb 4, 2026

Enforcement Jurisdiction Persists Despite Overbroad Relief, but Home-Sale Proceeds May Be Set Off Only to Proven Chapter 9 Damages Introduction In Debbie Jo Morrison v. Rodney Wayne Morrison (Tex....

Whitney Certificates Prove Forwarding as Addressed, Not Statutory-Address Compliance, in Restricted-Appeal Review of Secretary-of-State Service

Date: Jan 17, 2026

Whitney Certificates Prove Forwarding as Addressed, Not Statutory-Address Compliance, in Restricted-Appeal Review of Secretary-of-State Service I. Introduction In SHAMROCK ENTERPRISES, LLC D/B/A...

Appellate Courts Must Determine the Validity of a Disputed Settlement-Appellate Waiver Before Dismissing an Appeal

Date: Jan 10, 2026

Appellate Courts Must Determine the Validity of a Disputed Settlement-Appellate Waiver Before Dismissing an Appeal Case: 1 Coventry Court, LLC v. The Downs of Hillcrest Residential Association, Inc....

Chapter 252 Procurement Suits: Jurisdictional Discovery Required When Contract Terms Could Require >$50,000 City Expenditures; Revenue Labels and “No Expenditure” Disclaimers Do Not Defeat the Statute

Date: Jan 10, 2026

Chapter 252 Procurement Suits: Jurisdictional Discovery Required When Contract Terms Could Require >$50,000 City Expenditures; Revenue Labels and “No Expenditure” Disclaimers Do Not Defeat the...

Rule 29.3 Stays Against the State: Appellate Courts Must Weigh Merits, Balance Harms, and Act Within a Reasonable Time

Date: Dec 29, 2025

Rule 29.3 Stays Against the State: Appellate Courts Must Weigh Merits, Balance Harms, and Act Within a Reasonable Time 1. Introduction In re Ken Paxton and the Office of the Attorney General is an...

Nonreceipt of Alternative-Service Citation Satisfies Craddock’s “No Conscious Indifference” Element Despite Knowledge of the Lawsuit

Date: Dec 23, 2025

Nonreceipt of Alternative-Service Citation Satisfies Craddock’s “No Conscious Indifference” Element Despite Knowledge of the Lawsuit I. Introduction JENNA TABAKMAN v. GARY TABAKMAN is a...

Rule 29.3 Stays Against the State: Appellate Courts Must Consider Likely Merits, Balance Harms, and Have Reasonable Time to Decide

Date: Dec 23, 2025

Rule 29.3 Stays Against the State: Appellate Courts Must Consider Likely Merits, Balance Harms, and Have Reasonable Time to Decide I. Introduction Case: In re Ken Paxton and the Office of the...

Craddock Relief When a Defendant Lacks Actual Notice After Alternative Service and Appears Before the Decree Is Signed

Date: Dec 23, 2025

Craddock Relief When a Defendant Lacks Actual Notice After Alternative Service and Appears Before the Decree Is Signed Supreme Court of Texas (Per Curiam) — Default divorce; alternative service;...

Actual Receipt of Citation, Not Mere Knowledge of Suit: The Texas Supreme Court Recalibrates the Craddock Doctrine in Default Divorce Judgments

Date: Dec 20, 2025

Actual Receipt of Citation, Not Mere Knowledge of Suit: The Texas Supreme Court Recalibrates the Craddock Doctrine in Default Divorce Judgments I. Introduction The Supreme Court of Texas’s per curiam...

Evident Partiality in Contractual Appraisals: Duty to Disclose Pre‑Appointment Case Communications by Prospective Neutral Appraisers

Date: Dec 20, 2025

Evident Partiality in Contractual Appraisals: Duty to Disclose Pre‑Appointment Case Communications by Prospective Neutral Appraisers I. Introduction In Kevin Burke, et al. v. Houston PT BAC Office...

Huynh v. Blanchard and the Limits of Shutdown Injunctions in Texas Nuisance Law

Date: Dec 17, 2025

Huynh v. Blanchard and the Limits of Shutdown Injunctions in Texas Nuisance Law I. Introduction This commentary analyzes Justice Rebeca Huddle’s concurring opinion in the Supreme Court of Texas’s...

No-Privity Requirement and Broad “Highway” Scope Under Texas Civil Practice & Remedies Code § 97.002

Date: Dec 13, 2025

No-Privity Requirement and Broad “Highway” Scope Under Texas Civil Practice & Remedies Code § 97.002 I. Case Overview and Context A. Parties and Procedural Posture The case Third Coast Services, LLC...

Actual Notice of Citation, Not Mere Knowledge of Suit, Governs Conscious Indifference Under Craddock After Alternative Service: Commentary on Jenna Tabakman v. Gary Tabakman

Date: Dec 10, 2025

Actual Notice of Citation, Not Mere Knowledge of the Lawsuit, Governs Conscious Indifference Under Craddock After Alternative Service: A Commentary on Jenna Tabakman v. Gary Tabakman I. Introduction...

Distinguishing Knowledge of a Lawsuit from Notice of Citation: The Texas Supreme Court Recalibrates Craddock in Default Divorce Cases

Date: Dec 6, 2025

Distinguishing Knowledge of a Lawsuit from Notice of Citation: The Texas Supreme Court Recalibrates Craddock in Default Divorce Cases I. Introduction The Supreme Court of Texas’s per curiam opinion...

Shutdown as Last Resort: Narrowly Tailored Nuisance Injunctions and Deference to Texas Poultry‑Odor Regulation

Date: Nov 20, 2025

Shutdown as Last Resort: Narrowly Tailored Nuisance Injunctions and Deference to Texas Poultry‑Odor Regulation I. Introduction The Supreme Court of Texas’s decision in Steve Huynh, et al. v. Frank...