federal Case Commentaries

Tenth Circuit: Hardship Review Is Deferential, and Cancellation Appeals Cannot Recast Fact Disputes as Legal Error

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Tenth Circuit: Hardship Review Is Deferential, and Cancellation Appeals Cannot Recast Fact Disputes as Legal Error 1. Introduction In Hernandez Hernandez v. Blanche (10th Cir. Sept. 4, 2026)...

Post-Hunter I: Appeal Waivers Yield Only to Obvious, Egregious Error—Debatable § 922(g)(3) Constitutional Claims Remain Waived

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Post-Hunter I: Appeal Waivers Yield Only to Obvious, Egregious Error—Debatable § 922(g)(3) Constitutional Claims Remain Waived I. Introduction United States v. Nyandoro (5th Cir. Sept. 4, 2026)...

Starbucks v. NLRB (5th Cir. Sept. 4, 2026): Limits on NLRB Coercion Findings and Remedies—No Consequential Damages; No “Impossible” Reopening; Gissel Bargaining Order and Notice-Reading Sustained

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Limits on NLRB Coercion Findings and Remedies—No Consequential Damages; No “Impossible” Reopening; Gissel Bargaining Order and Notice-Reading Sustained Introduction In Starbucks Corporation v....

Procedural Forfeiture and Docket-Management Deference in Consolidated Federal Actions Challenging State Criminal Proceedings

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Procedural Forfeiture and Docket-Management Deference in Consolidated Federal Actions Challenging State Criminal Proceedings 1. Introduction In Urve Maggitti v. John Capuzzi, Sr. (3d Cir. Sept. 4,...

Fourth Circuit: Objective Recklessness Establishes Willful FBAR Liability, and Aggregate Willful FBAR Penalties Are Not “Grossly Disproportional” When Far Below the Statutory Maximum

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Fourth Circuit: Objective Recklessness Establishes Willful FBAR Liability, and Aggregate Willful FBAR Penalties Are Not “Grossly Disproportional” When Far Below the Statutory Maximum 1. Introduction...

Harmless Error in CAT Review When Likelihood-of-Torture Fails at Myrie Step One

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Harmless Error in CAT Review When Likelihood-of-Torture Fails at Myrie Step One 1. Introduction In Rafael Aguilar-Ayala v. Attorney General United States of America (3d Cir. Sept. 4, 2026) (not...

Summary Judgment Reversible Error: District Courts Must Analyze Self-Interested Testimony on Insurable Interest and Explain Their Reasons

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Summary Judgment Reversible Error: District Courts Must Analyze Self-Interested Testimony on Insurable Interest and Explain Their Reasons 1. Introduction Case: Marbury v. United National Insurance...

Independent Traffic Violation and Attenuation Cure an Earlier Unlawful Prolongation; Redundant Records Checks During Ongoing Citation Work Do Not “Prolong” a Stop

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Independent Traffic Violation and Attenuation Cure an Earlier Unlawful Prolongation; Redundant Records Checks During Ongoing Citation Work Do Not “Prolong” a Stop Case: United States v. Robert...

Mississippi Nonjudicial Foreclosure: Clerk-Signed Courthouse Posting Evidence and No Statutory Duty to Accept Partial Reinstatement Payments Under § 89-1-59

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Mississippi Nonjudicial Foreclosure: Clerk-Signed Courthouse Posting Evidence and No Statutory Duty to Accept Partial Reinstatement Payments Under § 89-1-59 I. Introduction In Snell v. 21st Mortgage...

Sterling v. City of Jackson: No Substantive Due Process Right to Contaminant-Free Municipal Water or Truthful Official Assurances About Water Safety

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Sterling v. City of Jackson: No Substantive Due Process Right to Contaminant-Free Municipal Water or Truthful Official Assurances About Water Safety Introduction In Sterling v. City of Jackson (5th...

Home Invasion as a “Dangerousness” Predicate Upholding 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1) After Hembree

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Home Invasion as a “Dangerousness” Predicate Upholding 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1) After Hembree 1. Introduction In United States v. Lewis (5th Cir. Sept. 4, 2026) (per curiam) (unpublished), the Fifth...

Qualified Immunity Applies Absent Clearly Established Eighth Amendment Protection from a Non-Prison Co-Worker’s Recklessness

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Qualified Immunity Applies Absent Clearly Established Eighth Amendment Protection from a Non-Prison Co-Worker’s Recklessness I. Introduction Case: Joshua M. Hubbert v. Kenny Brinley (11th Cir. Sept....

Tenth Circuit COA Gatekeeping: New Habeas Theories Disregarded, Oklahoma Rule 5.2(A) Defaults Enforced, and Posttrial Recantations Rarely Open the Schlup Gateway

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Tenth Circuit COA Gatekeeping: New Habeas Theories Disregarded, Oklahoma Rule 5.2(A) Defaults Enforced, and Posttrial Recantations Rarely Open the Schlup Gateway 1. Introduction In Collins v....

Striking a Defendant’s Entire Closing Argument Is a Prejudicial Abuse of Discretion

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Striking a Defendant’s Entire Closing Argument Is a Prejudicial Abuse of Discretion (Even If Parts Were Improper) I. Introduction In United States v. Cristian Arevalo Arias (consolidated appeals...

Objective-Reasonableness Standard Governs Civil Detainee Diet Claims; Qualified Immunity Applies Where Kosher Request Appears Insincere and Officials Lack Personal Involvement

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Objective-Reasonableness Standard Governs Civil Detainee Diet Claims; Qualified Immunity Applies Where Kosher Request Appears Insincere and Officials Lack Personal Involvement Introduction In Logan...

Striking the Entire Defense Closing Argument Is a Prejudicial Abuse of Discretion Even When Parts Are Improper

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Striking the Entire Defense Closing Argument Is a Prejudicial Abuse of Discretion Even When Parts Are Improper I. Introduction In United States v. Cristian Ariel Arevalo Arias, United States v....

Constructive “Application for Admission” After Unlawful Entry Validates Expedited Removal as a § 1326 Predicate (Fifth Circuit)

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Constructive “Application for Admission” After Unlawful Entry Validates Expedited Removal as a § 1326 Predicate (Fifth Circuit) 1. Introduction In United States v. Escobedo-Gomez (5th Cir. Sept. 3,...

FLSA Salary-Basis Rule: Comp-Time and Hypothetical Docking Do Not Defeat Exempt Status Absent an Actual Pay-Reduction Practice

Date: Sep 4, 2026

FLSA Salary-Basis Rule: Comp-Time and Hypothetical Docking Do Not Defeat Exempt Status Absent an Actual Pay-Reduction Practice Moreau v. Harris County (5th Cir. Sept. 3, 2026) — No. 25-20045 1....

Separate-Contract Endorsements Bar Convention Arbitration Against Domestic Insurers, but Related Domestic Litigation May Be Stayed Pending Foreign-Insurer Arbitration

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Separate-Contract Endorsements Bar Convention Arbitration Against Domestic Insurers, but Related Domestic Litigation May Be Stayed Pending Foreign-Insurer Arbitration Case: Transportation...

Interboro Protection Extends to Honest, Reasonable CBA-Based Complaints About “Side Deals,” and Remedy-Scaling Must Wait for NLRB Compliance Proceedings

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Interboro Protection Extends to Honest, Reasonable CBA-Based Complaints About “Side Deals,” and Remedy-Scaling Must Wait for NLRB Compliance Proceedings Case: NLRB v. VNS Fed. Servs., LLC (6th Cir....