federal Case Commentaries

Mixed-Motive Title VII Claims Require Evidence of a Motivating Factor; Independent Investigations Break “Cat’s Paw” Causation

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Mixed-Motive Title VII Claims Require Evidence of a Motivating Factor; Independent Investigations Break “Cat’s Paw” Causation 1. Introduction In Amanda Fennel v. Elmore County Board of Education...

Non-Signatories May Be Enjoined for Aiding a Non-Compete Breach; Record-Based Territory and Customer/Workforce Loss Support Irreparable Harm

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Non-Signatories May Be Enjoined for Aiding a Non-Compete Breach; Record-Based Territory and Customer/Workforce Loss Support Irreparable Harm I. Introduction Puris, LLC. v. CMG Pipelines, Inc. (11th...

Federal Rule 8 Governs Pleading of Underlying Tort for Georgia Negligent-Retention Claims in Federal Court

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Federal Rule 8 Governs Pleading of Underlying Tort for Georgia Negligent-Retention Claims in Federal Court 1. Introduction In Syurii-Kiaira Smith v. Birge & Held Property Management, LLC, the...

Law-of-the-Case Bars Renewed Rule 404(b) Admissibility Challenges on Retrial; “Same Sentence Anyway” Renders Guidelines Disputes Non-Dispositive if Substantively Reasonable

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Law-of-the-Case Bars Renewed Rule 404(b) Admissibility Challenges on Retrial; “Same Sentence Anyway” Renders Guidelines Disputes Non-Dispositive if Substantively Reasonable Case: United States v....

Promptly Corrected “Verdict Must Be Guilty” Misstatement Is Not Structural Error; Gang-Affiliation Spillover and Joint-Trial Severance Require Specific Objections and Compelling Prejudice

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Promptly Corrected “Verdict Must Be Guilty” Misstatement Is Not Structural Error; Gang-Affiliation Spillover and Joint-Trial Severance Require Specific Objections and Compelling Prejudice Case:...

Eleventh Circuit Reaffirms § 922(g)(1)’s Constitutionality Post-Bruen/Rahimi and Upholds an Above-Guidelines Sentence Based on Deterrence and Public Protection

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Eleventh Circuit Reaffirms § 922(g)(1)’s Constitutionality Post-Bruen/Rahimi and Upholds an Above-Guidelines Sentence Based on Deterrence and Public Protection I. Introduction In United States v....

District Courts May Deny Amendment 821 § 3582(c)(2) Reductions Based on § 3553(a) Assessment of Evasive/Jettison Conduct Even Without a § 3C1.1 Obstruction Enhancement

Date: Sep 12, 2026

District Courts May Deny Amendment 821 § 3582(c)(2) Reductions Based on § 3553(a) Assessment of Evasive/Jettison Conduct Even Without a § 3C1.1 Obstruction Enhancement 1. Introduction In United...

Georgia Choice-of-Law + AAA Rules Does Not Displace FAA Review Absent an Explicit Opt-Out (and Silence at Arbitration Can Waive the Objection)

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Georgia Choice-of-Law + AAA Rules Does Not Displace FAA Review Absent an Explicit Opt-Out (and Silence at Arbitration Can Waive the Objection) 1. Introduction Univabs Solutions Private Limited (an...

Tenth Circuit Tightens Pleading and Causation Requirements for § 1983 Malicious Prosecution Based on Affidavit Defects and Requires Post-Disposition Reassessment of Supplemental Jurisdiction

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Tenth Circuit Tightens Pleading and Causation Requirements for § 1983 Malicious Prosecution Based on Affidavit Defects and Requires Post-Disposition Reassessment of Supplemental Jurisdiction 1....

Post-Removal Mootness of § 2241 Detention Challenges and Issue Preservation Limits on Third-Country Removal Claims

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Post-Removal Mootness of § 2241 Detention Challenges and Issue Preservation Limits on Third-Country Removal Claims 1. Introduction Case: Mario Javier Cedeno-Gonzalez v. Markwayne Mullin, et al....

PLRA Exhaustion at Summary Judgment: Defendants Must Prove When the Grievance Clock Starts When Notice of Finality Is Disputed

Date: Sep 12, 2026

PLRA Exhaustion at Summary Judgment: Defendants Must Prove When the Grievance Clock Starts When Notice of Finality Is Disputed Case: Danyale Tubbs v. Sherry Payton (6th Cir. Sept. 10, 2026)...

Police-Pursuit Substantive Due Process Requires “Intent to Harm”; TTCA Claim Must Be Reassessed When Federal Claims Drop Out

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Police-Pursuit Substantive Due Process Requires “Intent to Harm”; TTCA Claim Must Be Reassessed When Federal Claims Drop Out I. Introduction In Valadez v. City of Jacinto City (5th Cir. Sept. 9,...

Tenth Circuit Narrows Oklahoma H.B. 1775 to a Ban on Teaching “Divisive Concepts” as Correct Principles—and Vacates Vagueness Injunction

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Tenth Circuit Narrows Oklahoma H.B. 1775 to a Ban on Teaching “Divisive Concepts” as Correct Principles—and Vacates Vagueness Injunction Case: Black Emergency Response Team v. Braught (caption...

VICAR Enterprise Proof Through “Intrinsic” Gang Drug-Trafficking Evidence; Predicate Acquittal Does Not Undo a § 924(c) Firearm Conviction

Date: Sep 12, 2026

VICAR Enterprise Proof Through “Intrinsic” Gang Drug-Trafficking Evidence; Predicate Acquittal Does Not Undo a § 924(c) Firearm Conviction I. Introduction United States v. Markell Young (with...

Pleading a Prison-Job Retaliation Claim: Alleged Termination Must Be Credited as “Adverse Action” at the Motion-to-Dismiss Stage

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Pleading a Prison-Job Retaliation Claim: Alleged Termination Must Be Credited as “Adverse Action” at the Motion-to-Dismiss Stage 1. Introduction In Brian Thompson v. Mohamed Safa, Sergeant (3d Cir....

Third Circuit Requires § 401 Certifications to Resolve Material Monitoring/Adaptive-Management Terms or Condition Dredging on Agency Approval

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Third Circuit Requires § 401 Certifications to Resolve Material Monitoring/Adaptive-Management Terms or Condition Dredging on Agency Approval I. Introduction In Natural Resources Defense Council Inc...

Indentation-as-Meaning Rule for Insurance Endorsements: Unindented “to the extent” Qualifiers Apply Across All Subparts

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Indentation-as-Meaning Rule for Insurance Endorsements: Unindented “to the extent” Qualifiers Apply Across All Subparts Publication status. The Fifth Circuit noted this opinion is “not designated for...

Automatic Deletion Under Neutral Retention Policies Does Not Warrant a Criminal Spoliation Adverse-Inference Instruction Absent Prior Knowledge of Relevance and Willful Loss

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Automatic Deletion Under Neutral Retention Policies Does Not Warrant a Criminal Spoliation Adverse-Inference Instruction Absent Prior Knowledge of Relevance and Willful Loss I. Introduction In United...

Striking a Cooperating Witness’s Testimony as an Adequate Brady Cure; Conditional Intent and Two‑Step Digital Warrants Sustain VICAR Convictions

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Striking a Cooperating Witness’s Testimony as an Adeate Brady Cure; Conditional Intent and Two‑Step Digital Warrants Sustain VICAR Convictions 1. Introduction In United States v. Jairo Gustavo...

Curative Instruction by Striking a Witness’s Testimony Can Cure Mid‑Trial Brady Prejudice; Digital Warrants May Permit Broad Review Where Seizure Is Cabined to Enumerated Crimes

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Curative Instruction by Striking a Witness’s Testimony Can Cure Mid‑Trial Brady Prejudice; Digital Warrants May Permit Broad Review Where Seizure Is Cabined to Enumerated Crimes Case: United States...