Calcutta High Court Case Commentaries

Writ Enforcement of a Subsisting Civil-Court Police-Assistance Order Without Adjudicating Alleged Breach

Date: Nov 3, 2026

Writ Enforcement of a Subsisting Civil-Court Police-Assistance Order Without Adjudicating Alleged Breach Case: RUMA CHATTERJEE AND ORS v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS. Citation: 2026 CHC-AS 1907...

A Recruitment Correction Window Does Not Reopen Applications: Public Notice Binds Late Candidates

Date: Nov 3, 2026

A Recruitment Correction Window Does Not Reopen Applications: Public Notice Binds Late Candidates Case: SAMBHU CHARAN BERA v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS. Citation: 2026 CHC-AS 1905 Court: Calcutta...

Wrong-Forum Appeal Dismissed, but Deportation Deferred Pending Decision on CAA Citizenship Application

Date: Oct 16, 2026

Wrong-Forum Appeal Dismissed, but Deportation Deferred Pending Decision on CAA Citizenship Application Case: OISHE BISWAS v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL Court: Calcutta High Court Judge: Justice Jay...

Peaceful Protest and COVID Restrictions: FIRs Must Disclose the Ingredients of Each Offence

Date: Oct 15, 2026

Peaceful Protest and COVID Restrictions: FIRs Must Disclose the Ingredients of Each Offence Commentary on TRINA HALDER AND ORS. v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS. Calcutta High Court, Constitutional...

Allegedly False Reporting Does Not Justify Prosecution Without the Essential Ingredients of BNS Offences

Date: Oct 14, 2026

Allegedly False Reporting Does Not Justify Prosecution Without the Essential Ingredients of BNS Offences Case: SK. SAFIKUL ISLAM v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS. Court: Calcutta High Court, Constitutional...

Customary Primogeniture Cannot Override Applicable Hindu Succession Law; Partition Requires All Co-owners as Parties

Date: Oct 14, 2026

Customary Primogeniture Cannot Override Applicable Hindu Succession Law; Partition Requires All Co-owners as Parties Case: UDDHAB SINGH BABU & ANR v. HEMANTA KR. SINGH MANKI Court: Calcutta High...

Foreigners Act: Guilty-Plea Conviction Affirmed but Imprisonment Reduced to Time Served to Facilitate Repatriation

Date: Oct 14, 2026

Foreigners Act: Guilty-Plea Conviction Affirmed but Imprisonment Reduced to Time Served to Facilitate Repatriation Case: TANUSHREE SARKAR @ PUTUL v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL Court: Calcutta High Court |...

Railway Accident Compensation: Bona Fide Travel Can Be Established Without Recovery of a Ticket

Date: Oct 14, 2026

Railway Accident Compensation: Bona Fide Travel Can Be Established Without Recovery of a Ticket Case: SUDAMA MAHATO ALIAS SUDHAMA MAHATO AND ANR v. UNION OF INDIA Citation: 2026 CHC-AS 1863 Court:...

Partition Requires Proven Co-ownership of the Identified Suit Property and Joinder of Interested Co-sharers

Date: Oct 8, 2026

Partition Requires Proven Co-ownership of the Identified Suit Property and Joinder of Interested Co-sharers Case: SAFIKUL ISLAM KHAN v. DHULO SK. & ORS Court: Calcutta High Court, Civil Appellate...

Prior Approval and Salary Payments Do Not Bar Verification of Madrasah Appointments

Date: Oct 8, 2026

Prior Approval and Salary Payments Do Not Bar Verification of Madrasah Appointments Case: TARIKUL MOLLA AND ORS v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS. Court: Calcutta High Court, Constitutional Writ...

Private Book-Fair Organisation Does Not, Without an Enforceable Public Duty, Attract Article 226 Review

Date: Oct 7, 2026

Private Book-Fair Organisation Does Not, Without an Enforceable Public Duty, Attract Article 226 Review Case: ASSOCIATION FOR PROTECTION OF DEMOCRATIC RIGHTS AND ANR v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS....

Continued Detention After Compliance with Bail Requires Independent Legal Authority: State Compensation for Unlawful Custody

Date: Oct 6, 2026

Continued Detention After Compliance with Bail Requires Independent Legal Authority: State Compensation for Unlawful Custody Case JOY KRISHNA NAG @ JOY KUMAR NAG @ ROHIT v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL &ORS...

Non-Relative Kidney Donation: Collateral Documentary Gaps Cannot Alone Justify Refusal of a Genuine, Non-Commercial Donation

Date: Oct 6, 2026

Non-Relative Kidney Donation: Collateral Documentary Gaps Cannot Alone Justify Refusal of a Genuine, Non-Commercial Donation Case: RANJEET KUMAR GHOSH v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS. Court: Calcutta...

Goodwill of a Partnership is Not a “Family Mark”: Heirs Cannot Appropriate a Law-Firm Name; Summary Judgment in Passing Off under Order XIII-A

Date: Aug 25, 2026

Goodwill of a Partnership is Not a “Family Mark”: Heirs Cannot Appropriate a Law-Firm Name; Summary Judgment in Passing Off under Order XIII-A 1) Introduction The decision in FOX AND MANDAL AND ANR....

Presumption of Bona Fide Travel in Railway “Untoward Incident” Claims Despite Missing/Disputed Ticket

Date: Aug 20, 2026

Presumption of Bona Fide Travel in Railway “Untoward Incident” Claims Despite Missing/Disputed Ticket 1) Introduction This decision of the Calcutta High Court (Biswaroop Chowdhury, J.) in ANAMIKA...

Section 22 of the Senior Citizens Act Cannot Be Used to Evict Tenants: Tenancy Law Remedy and Jurisdictional Limits of the SDM

Date: Jul 31, 2026

Section 22 of the Senior Citizens Act Cannot Be Used to Evict Tenants: Tenancy Law Remedy and Jurisdictional Limits of the SDM 1. Introduction In ANNA SING @ ANAN SINGHA v. SASWATI MALLICK (Calcutta...

Company Must Be Arraigned for Section 66 FSS Act Vicarious Liability; Statutory Timelines and Authorization Under Sections 46/37/42 as Jurisdictional Preconditions

Date: Jul 30, 2026

Company Must Be Arraigned for Section 66 FSS Act Vicarious Liability; Statutory Timelines and Authorization Under Sections 46/37/42 as Jurisdictional Preconditions 1. Introduction In PARTHA SARATHI...

Reserved-Category Migration to Unreserved Posts Permitted Where Final Merit Is Aggregate and No Rule Bars Relaxation-Based Selection

Date: Jul 28, 2026

Reserved-Category Migration to Unreserved Posts Permitted Where Final Merit Is Aggregate and No Rule Bars Relaxation-Based Selection 1. Introduction Case: KOUSHIK CHATTERJEE AND ORS. v. STATE OF WEST...

Consent as a Sine Qua Non for Mediation Under Section 89 CPC: Mutual-Consent Divorce Cannot Be Dismissed for Non-Appearance in Mediation

Date: Jul 21, 2026

Consent as a Sine Qua Non for Mediation Under Section 89 CPC: Mutual-Consent Divorce Cannot Be Dismissed for Non-Appearance in Mediation 1. Introduction In DANISH KARIM v. RANJANA CHOWDHURY (Calcutta...

Holding Over After Withdrawal and Rent Acceptance Creates a Fresh Month-to-Month Tenancy: Subsequent Eviction Suit Not Barred by Order XXIII and Late Commercial-Court Objections

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Holding Over After Withdrawal and Rent Acceptance Creates a Fresh Month-to-Month Tenancy: Subsequent Eviction Suit Not Barred by Order XXIII and Late Commercial-Court Objections Case: BUDGE BUDGE...