Non-Relative Kidney Donation: Collateral Documentary Gaps Cannot Alone Justify Refusal of a Genuine, Non-Commercial Donation

Case: RANJEET KUMAR GHOSH v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.

Court: Calcutta High Court, Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction, Appellate Side
Judge: Justice Krishna Rao
Case number: W.P.A. No. 20086 of 2026
Judgment delivered: 5 October 2026

1. Introduction

This judgment examines the limits of administrative scrutiny when a person offers to donate a kidney to someone who is not a near relative. The central question was whether transplant authorities could reject the proposed donation principally because of discrepancies concerning the donor’s husband’s driving licence and the absence of documentary proof of his earlier driving assignments, despite evidence of an affectionate relationship and reports disclosing no commercial transaction or intermediary.

Ranjeet Kumar Ghosh, suffering from chronic kidney disease, sought permission for a kidney donation from the wife of a driver who had become acquainted with his family. The State authorities questioned whether the asserted relationship had been adequately established. The High Court concluded that their reasons for refusal did not accord with the governing statutory framework.

The decision’s significance lies in its insistence that safeguards against organ trafficking must remain directed toward their statutory purpose. Verification cannot become an exercise in demanding collateral documentation without adequately assessing the evidence of genuine affection and the absence of commercial dealing.

2. Background and Principal Issues

Medical need and proposed donor

After treatment and investigations at several hospitals, the petitioner was diagnosed with chronic kidney disease and advised to undergo renal transplantation. His counsel submitted that no family member had been found to be a suitable match. The proposed donor, Respondent No. 9, had a compatible blood group and offered to donate voluntarily.

The donor’s husband drove vehicles through a car-booking centre and had provided driving services to the petitioner’s family. According to the interviews, the families became acquainted when the petitioner and his wife visited Boro Maa’s temple and needed another vehicle after their car broke down. Subsequent journeys, including hospital visits, developed into a family-like association over approximately three to four years.

The donor described the petitioner as “Kaku,” or uncle, and explained that witnessing his deteriorating health had prompted her offer.

Application and verification

  • A joint application and medical fitness certificate were submitted on 19 January 2026.
  • The judgment also records a medical certificate dated 28 January 2026 following tests and investigations.
  • On 2 February 2026, the hospital forwarded the relevant documents and requested approval as a life-saving measure.
  • A police verification report dated 23 February 2026 disclosed no unofficial dealing in cash or kind and no middleman.
  • The authorities interviewed the donor, her husband, and the petitioner’s wife, recording their statements on video.

Reasons for refusal

Although the initial verification also raised questions about the documents associated with the driving centre, the Court identified two principal grounds underlying the rejection:

  1. The donor’s husband’s driving licence had been issued on 27 February 2024, whereas the parties said that he had been driving since 2021 or 2021–22.
  2. No documentary evidence established that he had worked through the driving centre since 2021.

The authorities considered these matters insufficiently explained and concluded that the asserted relationship had not been satisfactorily proved.

Questions before the Court

  1. What must applicants establish when a living donor is not a near relative of the recipient?
  2. How should documentary gaps be assessed alongside interviews and police verification?
  3. Were the particular reasons for refusal relevant and sufficient under the transplantation legislation?
  4. Should the Court itself permit transplantation or require reconsideration by the statutory committee?

3. Summary of the Judgment

The High Court allowed the writ petition, quashed the adverse decision, and directed the State Level Authorization Committee to reconsider the petitioner’s request and take an appropriate decision within two weeks from receipt of the order.

The Court’s principal findings were:

  • The legislation permits donation to a person who is not a near relative, subject to the statutory requirements and prior committee approval.
  • The governing inquiry concerns genuine affection, attachment, or another special reason, together with the prevention of commercial dealing.
  • The police report disclosed neither a commercial transaction nor the involvement of a middleman or tout.
  • The interviews supported an acquaintance extending over several years and the donor’s stated affection for the petitioner.
  • The driving-licence chronology and missing driving-centre records did not adequately justify rejection on the facts presented.

The Court did not grant unconditional permission for transplantation. It restored the matter to the statutory decision-maker for a fresh decision consistent with its reasoning.

4. Statutory Framework

Section 9(3): Donation beyond near relatives

Section 9(3) of the Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act, 1994 permits a living donor to authorise donation to a recipient who is not a near relative where the donation is motivated by affection, attachment, or another special reason. Such transplantation requires prior approval of the Authorisation Committee.

The provision therefore does not equate absence of kinship with ineligibility. It recognises that meaningful human relationships may arise outside a legally defined family, while requiring additional scrutiny to prevent exploitation.

Rule 7(3): A substantive assessment of genuineness

Rule 7(3) of the Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Rules, 2014 requires the committee to investigate matters including:

  • Whether payment or a commercial arrangement exists;
  • The connection between donor and recipient and the circumstances of the offer;
  • The donor’s reasons for donating;
  • Documents and photographs supporting the relationship;
  • The involvement of a middleman or tout;
  • The parties’ financial circumstances and any significant disparity;
  • Whether the donor is a drug addict; and
  • The awareness and views of the donor’s relevant family member.

These requirements call for a combined assessment of motivation, relationship, financial circumstances, and voluntariness. Documentary evidence matters, but it must be considered as part of that larger inquiry.

Rule 17: Clarification rather than premature rejection

The Court referred to Rule 17 as permitting explanations to be sought and verification through government officials where doubts arise. Its approach favours resolving material uncertainty through available investigative mechanisms rather than treating every missing record as fatal.

5. Precedent Cited and Its Influence

Kuldeep Singh & Anr. Vs. State of T.N. & Ors.

The judgment cites Kuldeep Singh & Anr. Vs. State of T.N. & Ors., reported in (2005) 11 SCC 122. This is the only judicial precedent discussed in the supplied judgment.

The Supreme Court’s governing principles

The quoted passage establishes that an unrelated donor must demonstrate that the proposed donation arises from affection, attachment, or another genuine special reason. A commercial motive cannot qualify as such a reason.

The Supreme Court emphasised that the committee must look beyond an asserted relationship and determine the true purpose of the proposed donation. It placed a heavy burden on the applicants, because the relationship and motivation lie particularly within their knowledge.

Relevant indicators include the duration of acquaintance, degree of association, reciprocal feelings, gratitude, and other human bonds. The quoted decision also addressed which State’s committee should conduct the inquiry, favouring the committee best placed to examine the parties’ true relationship and intentions.

Application in the present case

The High Court used the precedent principally to identify the substantive inquiry: whether the donation was genuinely motivated by affection or another permissible reason, rather than commerce. Territorial competence was not the dispute requiring resolution here.

The interviews supplied evidence corresponding to several factors recognised by the Supreme Court: a multi-year acquaintance, repeated contact, hospital-related assistance, and an expressed familial bond. The police report also supported the absence of a commercial arrangement.

Reconciling the applicants’ burden with the Court’s warning against excessive demands

An important interpretive point arises because the Supreme Court described the applicants’ burden as heavy, while the High Court cautioned that “too much” burden should not be imposed.

The sound reading is that the High Court did not dispense with proof of genuine motivation. Rather, it rejected a disproportionate application of that burden where the record already contained affirmative evidence of the relationship and no credible indication of commercial dealing.

Accordingly, the judgment should not be understood as making a donor’s declaration conclusive or requiring proof of an organ-sale offence before refusal becomes possible. The committee retains its duty to investigate credible doubts and evaluate the entire record.

6. Analysis of the Court’s Legal Reasoning

A. The inquiry must remain connected to the statutory purpose

The Court repeatedly identified prevention of commercial dealing as the legislation’s central protective purpose. At the same time, Section 9(3) expressly accommodates genuine donation outside near-relative relationships.

The committee therefore had to distinguish between evidence suggesting a fabricated relationship and imperfections in the documentation of an otherwise plausible relationship. A discrepancy is relevant only to the extent that it rationally bears on the authenticity or lawfulness of the proposed donation.

B. The licence discrepancy did not establish that the acquaintance was false

Both the donor and her husband acknowledged that he had driven before obtaining his licence. Consequently, the 2024 licence date did not necessarily disprove an acquaintance beginning in 2021.

Driving without a licence could raise a separate legal issue, but it did not itself demonstrate that the claimed relationship was invented or commercially motivated. The judgment neither approves nor excuses unlicensed driving; it rejects the use of that fact as a sufficient basis for the transplantation refusal.

C. Missing occupational records required contextual evaluation

The recipient’s wife explained that the driver would attend, drive, receive payment, and leave. That account described an arrangement which might not generate extensive records in the family’s possession.

The Court did not declare driving-centre documents irrelevant. Its conclusion was narrower: their absence could not carry the rejection when weighed against the interviews, the history described by the parties, and the police findings.

This distinction is important. A committee may request documentary corroboration, but should explain why a particular omission materially undermines the relationship rather than assuming that informality proves fabrication.

D. Oral evidence and police verification had substantive value

The Court reviewed the recorded interviews rather than relying only on the committees’ summaries. Those interviews provided an account of how the families met, how contact continued, and why the donor offered her kidney.

The police report was also significant because it addressed commercial dealing and intermediaries directly. It was not treated as a statutory substitute for committee approval, but it was evidence that the committee’s reasoning had to confront.

E. Financial vulnerability remains relevant

The judgment records the donor’s annual income as ₹1,48,000. It does not provide a full comparative analysis of the recipient’s finances or establish that income disparity is immaterial.

The broader statutory obligation to examine financial circumstances therefore survives. Equally, limited income or a service-related connection cannot automatically establish that a donation is purchased. Those circumstances call for careful scrutiny, not a predetermined conclusion.

F. Judicial review corrected the refusal without replacing the committee

The Court found the stated reasons inconsistent with the statutory framework, but left the fresh approval decision to the Authorisation Committee. This preserves the distinction between judicial review of an unlawful administrative decision and the committee’s specialist responsibility to assess transplant eligibility.

The two-week deadline also recognises the practical urgency of a renal-transplant application. However, the judgment creates neither automatic approval on expiry of that period nor an exemption from other applicable medical and legal requirements.

7. Scope and Potential Impact

More disciplined reasons for refusal

Committees will be expected to connect adverse findings to the statutory questions: genuine motivation, authenticity of the relationship, voluntariness, and absence of commercial dealing. Peripheral inconsistencies should not become decisive without an explanation of their significance.

Recognition of relationships formed through informal work

The decision is particularly relevant where an affectionate association develops through informal employment or service arrangements. Such relationships may be genuine despite limited documentary records. Requiring formal records in every case could disproportionately disadvantage applicants whose working and social lives are less extensively documented.

Protection against both exploitation and excessive suspicion

The judgment encourages a balanced approach. Authorities must remain alert to organ trafficking, inducement, and fabricated affection, but should not presume that an unrelated or economically disadvantaged donor lacks a genuine humanitarian motive.

Limits of the ruling

  • It does not create an unrestricted entitlement to donate to a non-relative.
  • It does not remove the applicants’ obligation to establish genuine reasons for donation.
  • It does not make police clearance conclusive.
  • It does not prohibit requests for documents or further verification.
  • It does not authorise transplantation without prior statutory approval.

Its precedential value is therefore best understood as a fact-sensitive restriction on inadequately reasoned refusal, not a general relaxation of anti-trafficking safeguards.

8. Complex Concepts Simplified

Near relative
A relationship category defined by the transplantation legislation, rather than simply someone emotionally close. A person outside that category may still donate through the statutory approval process.
Affection, attachment, or special reasons
Genuine non-commercial motives for donation, such as an established emotional bond or gratitude. The committee must assess whether the claimed motive is authentic.
Authorisation Committee
The statutory decision-making body that examines whether a proposed transplantation satisfies the legal safeguards.
Commercial dealing
An arrangement involving payment or other prohibited commercial inducement for an organ. The absence of a middleman does not, by itself, establish the absence of every possible commercial arrangement.
Collateral discrepancy
An inconsistency about a surrounding matter, such as the date of a driving licence. Its importance depends on whether it genuinely undermines the central account.
Quashing and reconsideration
The Court cancels the defective decision and requires the competent authority to decide again lawfully. This is different from the Court itself granting transplant approval.

9. Conclusion

RANJEET KUMAR GHOSH v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS. requires transplant scrutiny to be rigorous without becoming mechanically suspicious. The Court held that the particular documentary deficiencies did not justify rejecting a donation supported by evidence of affection, a sustained acquaintance, and verification disclosing no commercial dealing.

Its central lesson is that anti-trafficking safeguards must be applied through relevant evidence and reasoned assessment, not through collateral doubts alone. By ordering time-bound reconsideration rather than directly permitting transplantation, the Court protected both the statutory approval process and the petitioner’s interest in a lawful, timely decision.