Montana Case Commentaries

Continued Unwanted Contact After Notice Supports a Stalking Protection Order, but Creates No New Precedent

Date: Oct 5, 2026

Continued Unwanted Contact After Notice Supports a Stalking Protection Order, but Creates No New Precedent Case: Mueller v. Haasch, 2026 MT 232N Court: Supreme Court of Montana Date: September 29,...

Marriage of Exe: Disputed Marital Assets May Be Sold and Divided Without a Separate Child-Best-Interest Analysis

Date: Oct 5, 2026

Marriage of Exe: Disputed Marital Assets May Be Sold and Divided Without a Separate Child-Best-Interest Analysis Case: In re the Marriage of Exe, 2026 MT 231N Court: Supreme Court of Montana —...

Local Ballot Access May Be Preserved Pending Appeal When Exclusion Would Irremediably Deny Initiative Rights

Date: Sep 26, 2026

Local Ballot Access May Be Preserved Pending Appeal When Exclusion Would Irremediably Deny Initiative Rights Case: 406 People First v. County of Butte-Silver Bow Court: Supreme Court of Montana Date:...

State v. J. Hubber: Bondsman Arrest Authority Does Not Independently Privilege Entry into a Third Party’s Home

Date: Sep 25, 2026

Bondsman Arrest Authority Does Not Independently Privilege Entry into a Third Party’s Home, and Mens Rea Instructional Error Requires Proven Prejudice Case: State v. J. Hubber, 2026 MT 229 Court:...

State v. Lake: Without a Renewed Motion in Limine, Contemporaneous Objections Define Rule 403 Review on Retrial

Date: Sep 25, 2026

Without a Renewed Motion in Limine, Contemporaneous Objections Define Rule 403 Review on Retrial Case: State v. A. Lake, 2026 MT 224 Court: Supreme Court of Montana Date: September 22, 2026...

Marriage of Gomez: Dissolution-Date Valuation and Flexible Equitable Apportionment Under Settled Montana Law

Date: Sep 25, 2026

Marriage of Gomez: Dissolution-Date Valuation and Flexible Equitable Apportionment Under Settled Montana Law Court: Supreme Court of Montana Decision: 2026 MT 227N Date: September 22, 2026...

Expert Testimony Is Not Required to Prove Mental Injury in Montana Vulnerable-Adult Abuse Prosecutions

Date: Sep 25, 2026

Expert Testimony Is Not Required to Prove Mental Injury in Montana Vulnerable-Adult Abuse Prosecutions Case: State v. D. Pein, 2026 MT 226 Court: Supreme Court of Montana Date: September 22, 2026...

Recorded All-Landowner Assessment Covenant Defeats Preliminary Relief Based on Association Withdrawal

Date: Sep 25, 2026

Recorded All-Landowner Assessment Covenant Defeats Preliminary Relief Based on Association Withdrawal Case: Naylor v. Roundup Mesa Landowners Court: Supreme Court of Montana Date: September 22, 2026...

State v. D. Crawford: Suspect-Initiated Dialogue After a Miranda Request for Counsel

Date: Sep 24, 2026

Suspect-Initiated Dialogue After a Miranda Request for Counsel: State v. D. Crawford Supreme Court of Montana · September 22, 2026 · 2026 MT 225 Introduction After a confrontation outside a Montana...

Rule 60 Is Not a Second Appeal; Parenting-Plan Amendments Require Statutory Threshold Showings and a Proper Record (In re Marriage of Scobee and White)

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Rule 60 Is Not a Second Appeal; Parenting-Plan Amendments Require Statutory Threshold Showings and a Proper Record Case: In re the Marriage of: Scobee and White, 2026 MT 222N (Mont. Sept. 15, 2026)...

Engellant v. Crowley Fleck (Mont. 2026): Validity of a Later Will as a “Negative Defense” Defeating Causation/Damages in Estate-Planning Malpractice

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Engellant v. Crowley Fleck (Mont. 2026): Validity of a Later Will as a “Negative Defense” Defeating Causation/Damages in Estate-Planning Malpractice 1. Introduction Case: Engellant v. Crowley Fleck,...

State v. Maas (Mont. 2026): Ongoing-Emergency Confrontation Rule for Post-Shooting Hospital Statements; Remoteness Limits on Juvenile Character Rebuttal

Date: Sep 18, 2026

State v. Maas (Mont. 2026): Ongoing-Emergency Confrontation Rule for Post-Shooting Hospital Statements; Remoteness Limits on Juvenile Character Rebuttal 1. Introduction In State v. Maas, the Supreme...

“Good Cause” in Montana Protective-Order Hearings Requires Proof by a Preponderance of Substantial, Credible Evidence

Date: Sep 18, 2026

“Good Cause” in Montana Protective-Order Hearings Requires Proof by a Preponderance of Substantial, Credible Evidence 1. Introduction In A. Nelson v. S. Frisk, 2026 MT 220, the Supreme Court of...

Removal by Participation: Dissolution Courts May Assume and Permanently Resolve Protection-Order Proceedings Under § 40-15-301(3), MCA

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Removal by Participation: Dissolution Courts May Assume and Permanently Resolve Protection-Order Proceedings Under § 40-15-301(3), MCA Case: Marriage of Cordeiro (Mont. 2026 MT 219) Court: Supreme...

Fraud-Based Rescission for Misrepresented Lease Term & Waiver of Affirmative Defenses Not Raised at Bench Trial (Shepard v. Bickham)

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Fraud-Based Rescission for Misrepresented Lease Term & Waiver of Affirmative Defenses Not Raised at Bench Trial (Shepard v. Bickham, 2026 MT 221N) Nonprecedential status. The Court designated this...

Jury Determinations Required for Unjust Enrichment “Rent,” Pritchard Setoff, and Reasonable Rental Value on Remand (Taylor v. Taylor)

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Jury Determinations Required for Unjust Enrichment “Rent,” Pritchard Setoff, and Reasonable Rental Value on Remand (Taylor v. Taylor) Introduction Case: Taylor v. Taylor, 2026 MT 223N (Mont. Sept....

Previously “Merged” (Concurrent) Sentences Cannot Be “Unmerged” by Later Silence in a Subsequent Judgment

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Previously “Merged” (Concurrent) Sentences Cannot Be “Unmerged” by Later Silence in a Subsequent Judgment 1. Introduction Gillian v. Salmonsen (Mont. Sept. 8, 2026) is a Montana Supreme Court habeas...

Therapist-Informed Visitation Limits May Still Satisfy “Reasonable Efforts,” and Ineffective Assistance Requires a Showing of Prejudice in Montana YINC Terminations

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Therapist-Informed Visitation Limits May Still Satisfy “Reasonable Efforts,” and Ineffective Assistance Requires a Showing of Prejudice in Montana YINC Terminations Introduction Matter of H.T., S.T.,...

Recorded LLC Filings Alone Do Not Start the Limitations Clock When Fiduciary Concealment and Conflicting Tax Records Support Discovery-Rule Tolling

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Recorded LLC Filings Alone Do Not Start the Limitations Clock When Fiduciary Concealment and Conflicting Tax Records Support Discovery-Rule Tolling Introduction In Hudson Revocable Trust v. Freedom...

Therapist-Driven Suspension of Parent-Child Visitation May Still Satisfy “Reasonable Efforts”; Ineffective-Assistance Claims Require a Showing of Prejudice in Montana TPR Appeals

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Therapist-Driven Suspension of Parent-Child Visitation May Still Satisfy “Reasonable Efforts”; Ineffective-Assistance Claims Require a Showing of Prejudice in Montana TPR Appeals Introduction Matter...