Montana Case Commentaries

Untimely Guilty-Plea Withdrawal in Montana Requires an Evidence-Supported Innocence Claim—Suppression and Non-Innocence IAC Theories Do Not Trigger the Miscarriage-of-Justice Exception

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Untimely Guilty-Plea Withdrawal in Montana Requires an Evidence-Supported Innocence Claim—Suppression and Non-Innocence IAC Theories Do Not Trigger the Miscarriage-of-Justice Exception 1....

Hoskin v. Wall: Rule 52(c) Bench-Trial Judgment on Partial Findings Requires Admissible Proof, Preserved Evidentiary Error, and Cohesive Appellate Briefing

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Hoskin v. Wall: Rule 52(c) Bench-Trial Judgment on Partial Findings Requires Admissible Proof, Preserved Evidentiary Error, and Cohesive Appellate Briefing Nonprecedential posture. The Court...

Reaffirmation of Little/Johnston: Appellate Courts Must Review Contested Evidence In Camera Before Assessing Exculpatory Value in Post-Conviction Litigation

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Reaffirmation of Little/Johnston: Appellate Courts Must Review Contested Evidence In Camera Before Assessing Exculpatory Value in Post-Conviction Litigation Case: Mathis v. State, 2026 MT 211 (Mont....

Therapy-Based Visitation Pauses and Late-Stage Compliance Do Not Defeat Termination After Prolonged Out-of-Home Placement (Mont. YINC)

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Therapy-Based Visitation Pauses and Late-Stage Compliance Do Not Defeat Termination After Prolonged Out-of-Home Placement (Mont. YINC) Case: Matter of H.T., S.T., & D.L., YINCC, 2026 MT 213N (Mont....

Defendant’s Motion to Reset Trial “at the Court’s Earliest Convenience” Constitutes a Postponement that Defeats § 46-13-401(2) Six-Month Dismissal

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Defendant’s Motion to Reset Trial “at the Court’s Earliest Convenience” Constitutes a Postponement that Defeats § 46-13-401(2) Six-Month Dismissal Introduction State v. J. Kelly (Mont. Sup. Ct. 2026...

State v. Laroque (2026 MT 209) Commentary

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Implied-Consent Blood Draws in Montana Require Record Evidence of Understanding and Voluntary Consent; Good-Faith Reliance Must Be Preserved Below Case: State v. Laroque, 2026 MT 209 (DA 25-0465)...

Due Process Timing for Challenging a Temporary Guardian’s Out-of-State Placement

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Due Process Timing for Challenging a Temporary Guardian’s Out-of-State Placement (Review Satisfied by a Full Contested Hearing Before Temporary Order Expiration) 1. Introduction Matter of K.D.G....

State v. J.A. Miller: Uniformed Officer Spectators Are Not Inherently Prejudicial; Unrequested Jury Polling Is Unpreserved; Graphic Photo Error May Be Harmless Under Cumulative Evidence

Date: Sep 3, 2026

State v. J.A. Miller: Uniformed Officer Spectators Are Not Inherently Prejudicial; Unrequested Jury Polling Is Unpreserved; Graphic Photo Error May Be Harmless Under Cumulative Evidence 1....

Supervisory Control Compels Prompt Title 41 Dismissal After Remittitur; Title 41 Dismissal Does Not Modify Separate Title 40 Parenting Plan

Date: Aug 28, 2026

Supervisory Control Compels Prompt Title 41 Dismissal After Remittitur; Title 41 Dismissal Does Not Modify Separate Title 40 Parenting Plan 1. Introduction R.F. v. 13th Judicial Dist. Court (Mont....

State v. Freeman: Continuous Probation Violations May Justify Denial of “Street Time” Credit, but Courts Must Credit Discrete Compliant Periods and Explain Any Denial

Date: Aug 27, 2026

State v. Freeman: Continuous Probation Violations May Justify Denial of “Street Time” Credit, but Courts Must Credit Discrete Compliant Periods and Explain Any Denial Introduction In State v. C....

Production of Nonprofit Records in Discovery Moots Inspection Claims; Courts Decline to Intervene in Uncontested, Superseded Officer Elections Absent Injury

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Production of Nonprofit Records in Discovery Moots Inspection Claims; Courts Decline to Intervene in Uncontested, Superseded Officer Elections Absent Injury 1. Introduction E. Kragh v. MADC is a 2026...

Marriage of French: Rule 60(b) Relief Cannot Substitute for an Untimely Appeal; Voidness Requires a Fundamental Due Process Defect Shown on an Adequate Record

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Marriage of French: Rule 60(b) Relief Cannot Substitute for an Untimely Appeal; Voidness Requires a Fundamental Due Process Defect Shown on an Adequate Record 1. Introduction Case: In re the Marriage...

State v. M. Mitchell (2026 MT 201): Custody During Revocation Is Credited to the Active DOC Term Being Served; the State Is Judicially Estopped From Reclaiming Detention-Credit Error It Invited

Date: Aug 26, 2026

State v. M. Mitchell (2026 MT 201): Custody During Revocation Is Credited to the Active DOC Term Being Served; the State Is Judicially Estopped From Reclaiming Detention-Credit Error It Invited 1....

Plain-Error Resentencing Required When a Court Applies a Post-Offense Sentencing Amendment as “Mandatory”

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Plain-Error Resentencing Required When a Court Applies a Post-Offense Sentencing Amendment as “Mandatory” Case: State v. M. Partridge, 2026 MT 204N (Mont. Aug. 25, 2026) (memorandum opinion;...

State v. Hatfield (2026 MT 202) — No Delegation of Financial Sentencing Obligations to Parole; Mislabeling “Crime of Violence” Requires Striking, Not Resentencing Absent Reliance

Date: Aug 26, 2026

No Delegation of Financial Sentencing Obligations to Parole; Mislabeling “Crime of Violence” Requires Striking, Not Resentencing Absent Reliance Case: State v. T.W. Hatfield, 2026 MT 202 (Mont. Aug....

Will-Serve Letters Imply Performance Within a “Reasonable Time” and Do Not Create Perpetual Municipal Capacity Obligations

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Will-Serve Letters Imply Performance Within a “Reasonable Time” and Do Not Create Perpetual Municipal Capacity Obligations Introduction West Dev. v. Town of W. Yellowstone (2026 MT 203) arose from a...

Supervisory Control Will Not Correct Denial of Intervention Where Interests Are Fact-Dependent and Lobbying Alone Is Not a Legally Protectable Interest

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Supervisory Control Will Not Correct Denial of Intervention Where Interests Are Fact-Dependent and Lobbying Alone Is Not a Legally Protectable Interest Case: Chamber of Commerce v. 1st Judicial...

Continuing Loss-of-Use Contract Damages After Property Sale and Full Contract Fee Recovery When Contract and MCPA Claims Are Inextricably Intertwined

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Continuing Loss-of-Use Contract Damages After Property Sale and Full Contract Fee Recovery When Contract and MCPA Claims Are Inextricably Intertwined 1. Introduction Mcnain Holdings v. Wilderness...

MAPA’s 30-Day Judicial-Review Deadline Is Strict, with Only Narrow Equitable Relief Requiring Diligence and External Impediment

Date: Aug 21, 2026

MAPA’s 30-Day Judicial-Review Deadline Is Strict, with Only Narrow Equitable Relief Requiring Diligence and External Impediment Introduction In NOCR v. MT Dept. of Revenue (2026 MT 197N), the Montana...

ICWA Nonwaivability in Private Termination/Stepparent Adoption Proceedings: Courts Must Independently Determine Applicability; Stipulation Error Is Harmless Absent “Reason to Know”

Date: Aug 21, 2026

ICWA Nonwaivability in Private Termination/Stepparent Adoption Proceedings: Courts Must Independently Determine Applicability; Stipulation Error Is Harmless Absent “Reason to Know” Case: Parenting...