Serial Habeas Filings While Postconviction Relief Is Pending: Habeas Denied and Prefiling Leave Requirement Authorized Case: Smith v. Reich (Mont. Sup. Ct. OP 26-0548) Date: August 18, 2026...
Direct-Appeal Ineffective Assistance Claims Must Be Record-Based; Pro Se Appellants Must Cite the Record and Authority (State v. B. Ackerman) 1. Introduction In State v. B. Ackerman, 2026 MT 196N,...
Stipulation and Failure to Object Waive Appellate Claims for Elapsed (Street) Time Credit in Revocation Sentencing 1. Introduction State v. R. Jore (Mont. Sup. Ct. Aug. 18, 2026) addresses a...
Withdrawal as Waiver in Dissolution Appeals: Abandoned Third-Party Property Claims and Untimely Discovery Do Not Become Due Process Violations Introduction Marriage of Ferrazzano (Mont. Sup. Ct. 2026...
Montana DUI Mandatory-Minimum Fines After State v. Cole: Sentencing Courts Must Assess Ability to Pay and Suspend the Unpayable Portion 1. Introduction Case: State v. D. Barker, 2026 MT 181N (Mont....
Waiver of “Elapsed Time” (Street-Time) Credit Challenges by Acquiescence at Revocation; Non-Objection Renders Error “Objectionable,” Not “Illegal” Introduction State v. Day (Mont. Sup. Ct. Aug. 4,...
UM-CRApp: Uniform, Record-Confined Appeals from Municipal Courts of Record to District Court—with Optional Ordinance-Based Jurisdictional Minimums and Indigency Waivers 1. Introduction On August 4,...
Parcel-Specific Severance and Scope Findings Required for Implied Easements by Preexisting Use (and Cost Memo Timing Requires a Final Decision) 1. Introduction Brock v. Tompkins (2026 MT 175) is a...
No Negligent Entrustment Between Co-Owners Absent Superior Control; No Text-Sender Duty Without Knowledge the Driver Will Read While Driving (Mont. 2026) Estate of Janice Graham v. Howell, 2026 MT...
Implied Findings Sustain Parenting-Plan Modification and Narrowly Tailored Limits on Harmful Spiritual “Influence” Nonprecedential posture: The Court issued a memorandum opinion under its Internal...
§ 41-5-208 Transfer Hearings Are Limited to Transfer—No New Disposition Without a § 41-5-1431 Revocation Petition 1. Introduction Matter of: W.D. (2026 MT 177) required the Montana Supreme Court to...
Unsupervised Jury Replay of Testimonial Dash-Cam Video During Deliberations Requires Reversal Absent Van Kirk Harmlessness Case: State v. Lewis, 2026 MT 179N (Mont. Aug. 4, 2026) Court: Supreme Court...
State v. Richards: Prosecutor May Recommend PSI Financial Obligations Without Breaching a Sentence-Recommendation Plea; Unrebutted Victim Affidavit Supports Restitution for Court-Attendance Expenses...
Affirmance for Insufficient Appellate Record in Montana Dissolution Appeals (Marriage of Hutnick) Nonprecedential posture: The Court issued a memorandum opinion under its Internal Operating Rules and...
Nonservice of Protection-Order Hearing Notice and On-the-Record Omissions as Potential MRPC 3.4 and 8.4 Misconduct (Matter of Hilary J. Oitzinger) 1. Introduction The provided text is not a merits...
State v. Martinez: “Damage” Under Montana Criminal Mischief (§ 45-6-101(1)(a), MCA) Requires Proof of Damage Producing Pecuniary Loss; Ability-to-Pay Requires a Serious, Evidence-Based Inquiry 1....
Montana Uniform District Court Rules: Statewide Uniform Procedure, Mandatory Motion Conferencing, and New Simplified/Informal Trial Frameworks Introduction On July 28, 2026 (Case No. AF 07-0110), the...
Settled-Party Comparative-Fault Defense Is Not a “Malpractice Claim” Triggering § 26-2-601 Expert-Qualification Limits Introduction Stricker v. Blaine County (Mont. 2026 MT 170N) is the fourth...
Res Judicata Bars Untimely Collateral Restitution Challenges; § 46-18-246, MCA Permits Prospective Reduction to Zero Upon Proven Inability to Pay Introduction In State v. J. Rodriguez (Mont. Sup. Ct....
State v. Thomas (2026 MT 171N): Vague Continuance Requests and Non-Substantial Counsel Complaints Do Not Compel Delay or Substitute Counsel—Especially Where Defendant Insists on Speedy Trial...