Montana’s 2027 Lawyer Disciplinary Enforcement Framework: Comprehensive Regulation, Separated Functions, and Mandatory Interim Administrator Planning Court: Supreme Court of Montana Case Title: RULES...
State v. Morrissey Jr.: “Evidence as a Whole” Supports Denial of Directed Verdict Where Victim’s “Same Spot” Testimony Permits Inferences of Sexual Contact and Knowing Mental State 1. Introduction In...
Orders of Protection Must Defer to Existing Parenting Plans While Permitting Only Logistics-Limited Contact 1. Introduction Gemar v. Gemar (Mont. 2026 MT 173N) concerns whether a district court...
Platted Express Easements Cannot Be “Supplanted” by a Non‑Signatory Easement Agreement; Obstruction Remedies Must Be Precisely Tied to Proven Encroachments Introduction Vicevich v. Kultgen (2026 MT...
State v. Veltkamp (2026 MT 169): SANE Reports Are Not “Medical Diagnosis” Hearsay; Jury-Room Access Is Error but May Be Harmless When Cumulative 1. Introduction In State v. Veltkamp, the Montana...
State Tortfeasor Cannot Use Interpleader to Impose the Tort Claims Act Cap; Constitutional Challenges to § 2-9-108, MCA, Are Unripe Absent a Filed Tort Action and Excess Damages Determination 1....
Montana Lawyer Discipline: Felony Drug Convictions Trigger Rule 8.4 Charges, While Interim Suspension Requires a Separate Rule 23(B) Showing 1. Introduction Matter of Kenneth B. Cotter arises from...
Utility-Owned Streetlight Evidence Is Admissible in Municipal Premises-Liability Claims; Public Duty Doctrine Does Not Categorically Bar Lighting-Based Unsafe-Intersection Theories I. Introduction In...
Matter of Douglas Marshall: Text Messages Do Not Satisfy Montana’s “Signed Writing” Requirement for Contingent-Fee Agreements Without Client Adoption 1. Introduction Matter of Douglas Marshall is a...
Claim Preclusion Bars Post-Judgment Tort Claims Against an Estate and Its Personal Representative Acting Only in a Fiduciary Capacity 1. Introduction Kahle v. Estate of Tosch (Mont. 2026 MT 159N) is...
State v. Reed: No Ineffective Assistance Absent Prejudice Where Evidence Does Not Support a Lesser-Included Instruction; Bail-Jumping “Lawful Excuse” Survives Vagueness Challenge Under Trombley 1....
ICWA Diligent Inquiry and IAC in Termination: Tattoos and Speculative Parole Dates Do Not Undermine Termination Under § 41-3-609(4)(c), MCA Introduction Matter of D.J.L. and R.J.M., Youths in Need of...
Montana’s 2026 Rule: Documented Random, Proximate Judge Reassignment and Strict Timing/Fee Controls for District Judge Substitution (§ 3-1-804, MCA) 1. Introduction In re Revised Rules on...
Counterman Does Not Invalidate Montana’s Threatening-an-Officer Statute Where It Requires Purposeful/Knowing Threats, and 911-Driven Domestic-Disturbance Exigency Can Justify Warrantless Entry...
Reversal of a Conditional Federal Habeas Writ Extinguishes Substitution Rights and Permits Reinstatement of a Vacated Montana Conviction—But Only After the Defendant Is Heard Case: State v. K....
Diligent ICWA Inquiry Is Satisfied by Prompt Notice and Conclusive Tribal Responses; Speculative Parole Date Does Not Establish Ineffective Assistance or Defeat Termination Under § 41-3-609(4)(c),...
Montana Due Process Rule: Failure to Hold a Timely § 41-3-432 Show Cause Hearing and Expiration of EPS Authority Requires Dismissal 1. Introduction In S.M. v. 2nd Judicial Dist.Court (Mont. Sup. Ct....
Distinctive Vehicle Match Creates Particularized Suspicion for a Terry Stop; Probation Search Authorized by Reasonable Cause Based on Probation Violations Introduction In State v. J. Stewart, the...
State v. Proctor (2026 MT 150): “All Data” Cell-Phone Search Warrants Are Overbroad General Warrants Without Particularized Limits—But Admission May Be Harmless 1. Introduction In State v. Proctor,...
Rule 37 Sanctions in Parenting Cases: Courts May Limit Mental-Health Testimony to the Period Disclosed to the Parenting Evaluator 1. Introduction Parenting of C.R.J. (Mont. 2026 MT 151) arises from...