Montana Case Commentaries

Unanswered Motions and Unauthorized Amendments: Applying Montana’s Settled Procedural Rules

Date: Oct 29, 2026

Unanswered Motions and Unauthorized Amendments: Applying Montana’s Settled Procedural Rules Case: Norwood v. Bozeman, 2026 MT 258N, No. DA 26-0018 Court: Supreme Court of Montana Decided: October 27,...

Missing Sentencing Records Require Resentencing When No Adequate Alternative Permits Meaningful Appellate Review

Date: Oct 29, 2026

Missing Sentencing Records Require Resentencing When No Adequate Alternative Permits Meaningful Appellate Review State v. Erickson, 2026 MT 253, No. DA 24-0072 Supreme Court of Montana — October 27,...

Preserving Consolidation Objections and Establishing Prior PFMA Convictions: A Nonprecedential Application of Montana Law

Date: Oct 29, 2026

Preserving Consolidation Objections and Establishing Prior PFMA Convictions: A Nonprecedential Application of Montana Law Case: State v. M. Smith, 2026 MT 257N, No. DA 24-0392 Court: Supreme Court of...

Preserving Consolidation Challenges and Establishing Prior PFMA Convictions: Applying Settled Montana Law

Date: Oct 29, 2026

Preserving Consolidation Challenges and Establishing Prior PFMA Convictions: Applying Settled Montana Law Case: State v. M. Smith, 2026 MT 257N, No. DA 24-0392 Court: Supreme Court of Montana...

Limited Rehearing Review in Montana: Reframed Probate and Malpractice Arguments Do Not Justify Reconsideration

Date: Oct 22, 2026

Limited Rehearing Review in Montana: Reframed Probate and Malpractice Arguments Do Not Justify Reconsideration Case: Engellant v. Crowley Fleck Court: Supreme Court of Montana Case number: DA 24-0485...

State v. Pierre: Rebutting a Recanting Witness’s Denial and Crediting Court-Ordered Residential Treatment

Date: Oct 21, 2026

State v. Pierre: Rebutting a Recanting Witness’s Denial and Crediting Court-Ordered Residential Treatment Supreme Court of Montana | 2026 MT 250 | October 20, 2026 1. Introduction In State v. Pierre,...

Interim Lawyer Suspension: Alleged Misconduct and Serious-Harm Risk Warrant a Show-Cause Response

Date: Oct 16, 2026

Interim Lawyer Suspension: Alleged Misconduct and Serious-Harm Risk Warrant a Show-Cause Response Case: Matter of the Commission on Practice (no formal complaint), concerning Tad J. Quinn Court:...

Uniform Record-Based Appeals from Montana’s Limited-Jurisdiction Courts: Access, Security, and Protective-Order Safeguards

Date: Oct 16, 2026

Uniform Record-Based Appeals from Montana’s Limited-Jurisdiction Courts: Access, Security, and Protective-Order Safeguards Court: Supreme Court of Montana Matter: MONTANA UNIFORM LIMITED JURISDICTION...

Out-of-Jurisdiction Custody Earns Sentence Credit Only When the Defendant Is Also Detained Under the Sentencing Court’s Authority

Date: Oct 15, 2026

Out-of-Jurisdiction Custody Earns Sentence Credit Only When the Defendant Is Also Detained Under the Sentencing Court’s Authority Case: State v. E. Fowler, 2026 MT 245, No. DA 25-0410 Court: Supreme...

Montana’s Exhaustion Rule: Permit-Linked Constitutional Challenges Must Await Final Administrative Review

Date: Oct 14, 2026

Montana’s Exhaustion Rule: Permit-Linked Constitutional Challenges Must Await Final Administrative Review Case: GCA v. State, 2026 MT 243, No. DA 25-0808 Court: Supreme Court of Montana Decided:...

Amending Montana Parenting Plans: Changed Circumstances, Best Interests, and Retained Judicial Control

Date: Oct 14, 2026

Amending Montana Parenting Plans: Changed Circumstances, Best Interests, and Retained Judicial Control Case: Marriage of: Sage, 2026 MT 248N, No. DA 26-0148 Court: Supreme Court of Montana Decided:...

Treatment-Plan Success and Child Protection in Montana Parental-Rights Termination

Date: Oct 14, 2026

Treatment-Plan Success and Child Protection in Montana Parental-Rights Termination Case: Matter of S.O. & T.O., YINC Court: Supreme Court of Montana Decision: October 13, 2026; 2026 MT 247N; DA...

Parental-Rights Termination: Protective Capacity, Treatment-Plan Success, and Reasonable Reunification Efforts

Date: Oct 14, 2026

Parental-Rights Termination: Protective Capacity, Treatment-Plan Success, and Reasonable Reunification Efforts Case: Matter of S.O. & T.O., YINC Court: Supreme Court of Montana Decision: October 13,...

Matter of: R.V., A Youth: Determinate Juvenile Commitments Must Respect the Applicable Adult Sentencing Maximum

Date: Oct 14, 2026

Determinate Juvenile Commitments Must Respect the Applicable Adult Sentencing Maximum Case: Matter of: R.V., A Youth Court: Supreme Court of Montana Citation: 2026 MT 244, No. DA 23-0660 Decided:...

Habeas Relief Requires Illegal Restraint, and Weller’s Future Challenges Require Prior Leave

Date: Oct 14, 2026

Habeas Relief Requires Illegal Restraint, and Weller’s Future Challenges Require Prior Leave Case: S. Weller v. J. Williams Court: Supreme Court of Montana Date: October 13, 2026 Docket: OP 26-0554...

Early, Incidental Consent Requests May Remain Lawful During Traffic Stops Motivated by Drug Investigations

Date: Oct 14, 2026

Early, Incidental Consent Requests May Remain Lawful During Traffic Stops Motivated by Drug Investigations Case: State v. C. Idhen, 2026 MT 246, No. DA 24-0551 Court: Supreme Court of Montana...

Jury-Trial Waiver Defects Under Plain-Error Review: A Nonprecedential Application of Montana Law

Date: Oct 14, 2026

Jury-Trial Waiver Defects Under Plain-Error Review: A Nonprecedential Application of Montana Law Case: State v. J. Bernard, 2026 MT 249N, No. DA 24-0275 Court: Supreme Court of Montana Decided:...

MS4 Permit Duties Do Not Create County Regulatory Power: Lawful Compliance and the Federal-Statute Exception

Date: Oct 14, 2026

MS4 Permit Duties Do Not Create County Regulatory Power: Lawful Compliance and the Federal-Statute Exception Case: Yellowstone County v. MTDEQ, 2026 MT 242, No. DA 25-0710 Court: Supreme Court of...

Issue Preclusion Cannot Support Pleading-Stage Dismissal When a Settlement’s Scope Depends on Disputed Facts

Date: Oct 6, 2026

Issue Preclusion Cannot Support Pleading-Stage Dismissal When a Settlement’s Scope Depends on Disputed Facts Case: Copper City Gaming v. Allen, 2026 MT 230 Court: Supreme Court of Montana | Decided:...

Supervisory Control Is Unavailable for Fact-Bound Property Disputes Where Final Appeal Provides an Adequate Remedy

Date: Oct 5, 2026

Supervisory Control Is Unavailable for Fact-Bound Property Disputes Where Final Appeal Provides an Adequate Remedy Case: R. Drollinger v. 6th Jud. District Court Court: Supreme Court of Montana Date:...