Montana Case Commentaries

Pope v. DOC: Conflicting CBA/Offer-Letter Probation Terms Create Triable Fact Issues; Probation Extensions Must Track CBA Mutual-Assent Limits

Date: May 7, 2026

Pope v. DOC: Conflicting CBA/Offer-Letter Probation Terms Create Triable Fact Issues; Probation Extensions Must Track CBA Mutual-Assent Limits 1. Introduction In Pope v. Montana Department of...

Concurrent-Sentence Merger Fixes the Start Date for Cross-Case Credit; Stipulated Street-Time Credit Is Waived on Appeal

Date: May 6, 2026

Concurrent-Sentence Merger Fixes the Start Date for Cross-Case Credit; Stipulated Street-Time Credit Is Waived on Appeal Case: State v. K. Schmiedeke, 2026 MT 96 (Mont. May 5, 2026) Court: Supreme...

Affidavit-Threshold Requirement for Parenting-Plan Modification: Courts May Deny Without Hearing Absent a Statutory Showing of Changed Child Circumstances

Date: May 6, 2026

Affidavit-Threshold Requirement for Parenting-Plan Modification: Courts May Deny Without Hearing Absent a Statutory Showing of Changed Child Circumstances 1. Introduction Case: In re the Parenting of...

Sentencing Courts Must Conduct an Independent § 46-14-311/312 MCA Mental-Condition Determination When the Issue Is Raised at Sentencing

Date: May 6, 2026

Sentencing Courts Must Conduct an Independent § 46-14-311/312 MCA Mental-Condition Determination When the Issue Is Raised at Sentencing Introduction In State v. Myers Starks, 2026 MT 93, the Montana...

Repetitive Habeas Challenges to a Settled Montana Sentence May Trigger a Supreme Court Leave-to-File Requirement

Date: May 6, 2026

Repetitive Habeas Challenges to a Settled Montana Sentence May Trigger a Supreme Court Leave-to-File Requirement 1. Introduction Case: J. Eves v. Borchert (Order), Supreme Court of Montana, filed May...

Due Process and Specific Findings Required Before Montana Courts Impose Vexatious-Litigant Prefiling Orders

Date: May 6, 2026

Due Process and Specific Findings Required Before Montana Courts Impose Vexatious-Litigant Prefiling Orders Introduction Heaven v. Weber (2026 MT 95) arose after Matthew Heaven sued Steven Paul Weber...

“Sexual Contact” Under Montana Law: “Knowingly” Is an Alternative to “Purposely,” and Omitting “Purposely” from the Instruction Was Not Plain Error (State v. Steffens)

Date: May 6, 2026

“Sexual Contact” Under Montana Law: “Knowingly” Is an Alternative to “Purposely,” and Omitting “Purposely” from the Instruction Was Not Plain Error (State v. Steffens) Court: Supreme Court of Montana...

Appealability and Timeliness in Montana When a Court Authorizes Sale of Real Property Without Rule 77(d) Notice

Date: Apr 29, 2026

Appealability and Timeliness in Montana When a Court Authorizes Sale of Real Property Without Rule 77(d) Notice Case: Keltz v. KMW Enterprises (Order denying motion to dismiss appeal) Court: Supreme...

Opie v. Wead — Pre-Filing Leave Requirement for Repetitive Habeas Corpus Original Proceedings

Date: Apr 29, 2026

Opie v. Wead: The Montana Supreme Court’s Notarized Motion-for-Leave Gatekeeping Rule for Repetitive Habeas Original Proceedings 1. Introduction Opie v. Wead (Mont. Apr. 28, 2026) is an original...

Section 61-8-343 “Driveway Yield” Negligence Per Se Is Not Automatic on Summary Judgment When Pre-Crash Circumstances Are Disputed (Murray v. Steinmetz)

Date: Apr 29, 2026

Section 61-8-343 “Driveway Yield” Negligence Per Se Is Not Automatic on Summary Judgment When Pre-Crash Circumstances Are Disputed Murray v. Steinmetz, 2026 MT 89 (Mont. Apr. 28, 2026) 1....

State v. Mann (2026 MT 92) Commentary

Date: Apr 29, 2026

“Power-and-Control” Motive as a Non-Propensity Basis for Same-Victim Domestic-Abuse Other-Acts Evidence Under M. R. Evid. 404(b), Subject to Rule 403 Line-Drawing Case: State v. S. Mann, 2026 MT 92...

In re Marriage of Handy (2026 MT 90): Mandatory Evidentiary Hearing and Cross-Examination Rights Before Parenting Plan Amendment

Date: Apr 29, 2026

Mandatory Evidentiary Hearing and Cross-Examination Rights Before Parenting Plan Amendment Under § 40-4-220(1), MCA Introduction In re Marriage of Handy, 2026 MT 90, arises from post-dissolution...

Harmless-Error Treatment of “Delayed Complaint” Jury Instruction Imported from § 45-5-511(4), MCA, in a Nonsexual Intimidation Prosecution

Date: Apr 29, 2026

Harmless-Error Treatment of “Delayed Complaint” Jury Instruction Imported from § 45-5-511(4), MCA, in a Nonsexual Intimidation Prosecution 1. Introduction State v. R. Strobel (Mont. 2026 MT 88)...

State v. Strobel: Circumstantial Proof of Intimidation Intent and Harmlessness of a Borrowed “Delayed Complaint” Instruction

Date: Apr 29, 2026

State v. Strobel: Circumstantial Proof of Intimidation Intent and Harmlessness of a Borrowed “Delayed Complaint” Instruction Introduction In State v. R. Strobel (2026 MT 88), the Montana Supreme...

Separate-Vote Compliance in Montana Initiatives: “New Matter” Is Not Double-Counted, and Necessary Scope Definitions Do Not Create Extra Amendments

Date: Apr 27, 2026

Separate-Vote Compliance in Montana Initiatives: “New Matter” Is Not Double-Counted, and Necessary Scope Definitions Do Not Create Extra Amendments 1. Introduction In Transparent Election Initiative...

Hert v. MHSA: Montana Students’ Constitutionally Protected Interest in Offered Extracurriculars Requires Notice, Evidence, and a Written, Reviewable MHSA Eligibility Decision

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Hert v. MHSA: Montana Students’ Constitutionally Protected Interest in Offered Extracurriculars Requires Notice, Evidence, and a Written, Reviewable MHSA Eligibility Decision Introduction Hert v....

Montana Must Treat a Foreign Country as a “State” Under the UCCJEA When Determining Home-State Custody Jurisdiction

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Montana Must Treat a Foreign Country as a “State” Under the UCCJEA When Determining Home-State Custody Jurisdiction Case: In re the Parenting of R.A.A., 2026 MT 83 (Mont. Apr. 21, 2026) Court:...

Rule 60(b) Cannot Reopen Probate Distribution Where Statutory Mailed Notice Was Given and the Party Failed to Appeal

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Rule 60(b) Cannot Reopen Probate Distribution Where Statutory Mailed Notice Was Given and the Party Failed to Appeal Introduction In re the Matter of the Estate of: John William Lea, 2026 MT 85N, is...

Hyslop v. State (2026 MT 82): Postconviction IAC Requires an Arguably Meritorious Underlying Claim and Bars Record-Based Waiver Issues Not Raised on Direct Appeal

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Hyslop v. State (2026 MT 82): Postconviction IAC Requires an Arguably Meritorious Underlying Claim and Bars Record-Based Waiver Issues Not Raised on Direct Appeal 1) Introduction In Hyslop v. State,...

Implied-Consent Judicial Review Is Not Moot After Suspension Expiration When Collateral Relief Remains Available

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Implied-Consent Judicial Review Is Not Moot After Suspension Expiration When Collateral Relief Remains Available Case: Kalafat v. State, 2026 MT 81 (Mont. Apr. 21, 2026) | Court: Supreme Court of...