Montana Case Commentaries

Failure to Follow Mandatory CCYA Status-Report and Pre-21 Review Requirements Requires Remand for Two Years of CCYA Compliance and a Meaningful Sentence Review

Date: Jun 3, 2026

Failure to Follow Mandatory CCYA Status-Report and Pre-21 Review Requirements Requires Remand for Two Years of CCYA Compliance and a Meaningful Sentence Review 1. Introduction In State v. I....

Failure to Implement CCYA Status-Report and Pre-21 Review Mandates Requires Remand for Two Years of CCYA Compliance and a Meaningful Sentence Review

Date: Jun 3, 2026

Failure to Implement CCYA Status-Report and Pre-21 Review Mandates Requires Remand for Two Years of CCYA Compliance and a Meaningful Sentence Review Introduction State v. I. Pehringer (2026 MT 114)...

Waiver of ICWA “Diligent Efforts” Challenges and Conclusive Reliance on Unrevised Tribal Eligibility Determinations

Date: Jun 3, 2026

Waiver of ICWA “Diligent Efforts” Challenges and Conclusive Reliance on Unrevised Tribal Eligibility Determinations Case: Matters of L.C., X.P. & N.C., YINC, 2026 MT 121 (Mont. June 2, 2026) Court:...

Acquiescence Waives ICWA Diligent-Efforts Challenges in Montana YINC Termination Appeals

Date: Jun 3, 2026

Acquiescence Waives ICWA Diligent-Efforts Challenges in Montana YINC Termination Appeals Case: Matters of L.C., X.P. & N.C., YINC (Mont. 2026 MT 121) | Court: Supreme Court of Montana | Date: June 2,...

State v. Olson: Non-Speculative Nexus Required to Admit Alternative-Source Sexual-Knowledge Evidence Under Montana’s Rape Shield Statute

Date: Jun 3, 2026

State v. Olson: Non-Speculative Nexus Required to Admit Alternative-Source Sexual-Knowledge Evidence Under Montana’s Rape Shield Statute 1. Introduction In State v. Brent James Olson, 2026 MT 118,...

Uncashed Cashier’s Check Payable to Decedent Is an Estate Asset Absent Endorsement, Delivery, or Enforceable UCC Transfer

Date: May 29, 2026

Uncashed Cashier’s Check Payable to Decedent Is an Estate Asset Absent Endorsement, Delivery, or Enforceable UCC Transfer Case: In the Matter of the Estate of: Bradley James Haler, 2026 MT 111 (Mont....

Relevance Requires Defendant’s Knowledge: Limiting BDSM/Adult-Content Internet History Evidence in Strangulation Prosecutions Under M. R. Evid. 403

Date: May 29, 2026

Relevance Requires Defendant’s Knowledge: Limiting BDSM/Adult-Content Internet History Evidence in Strangulation Prosecutions Under M. R. Evid. 403 1. Introduction State v. S. Belcourt (2026 MT 113)...

“Voluntary Appearance” in an Acknowledgment of Service Triggers Rule 55(b)(2)’s Seven-Day Default-Judgment Waiting Period

Date: May 29, 2026

“Voluntary Appearance” in an Acknowledgment of Service Triggers Rule 55(b)(2)’s Seven-Day Default-Judgment Waiting Period 1. Introduction Bradley v. Yellowstone Trails Ranch Owners' Association (2026...

Reed (Mont. 2026): Communication, Diligence, and Timely Withdrawal/File/Refund Duties Under the MRPC

Date: May 22, 2026

Reed (Mont. 2026): Communication, Diligence, and Timely Withdrawal/File/Refund Duties Under the MRPC 1. Introduction Matter of Benjamin W. Reed, Attorney at Law (Supreme Court of Montana Cause No. PR...

Facial Illegality on Revocation: A Sentence That Increases the Imprisonment Term Is Unlawful Even If Credits Might “Net Out”

Date: May 21, 2026

Facial Illegality on Revocation: A Sentence That Increases the Imprisonment Term Is Unlawful Even If Credits Might “Net Out” 1. Introduction Case: R. Burton v. Salmonsen (Supreme Court of Montana,...

Absconding from Probation Justifies Charging Pre-Arrest Speedy-Trial Delay to the Accused; Forensic Mirror Images Satisfy “Substantial Equivalent” Discovery

Date: May 21, 2026

Absconding from Probation Justifies Charging Pre-Arrest Speedy-Trial Delay to the Accused; Forensic Mirror Images Satisfy “Substantial Equivalent” Discovery Case: State v. M. Smith, 2026 MT 106...

Conveying a Life Estate to One Joint Tenant Severs the Joint Tenancy by Destroying the Unity of Interest (Mont. 2026)

Date: May 21, 2026

Conveying a Life Estate to One Joint Tenant Severs the Joint Tenancy by Destroying the Unity of Interest (Mont. 2026) 1. Introduction In MacLaurin v. Fischer Law, PLLC, 2026 MT 109, the Montana...

Mandatory Felony-DUI Fines After Cole: Fine Must Be Imposed, Then Ability-to-Pay Evaluated with Possible Suspension

Date: May 21, 2026

Mandatory Felony-DUI Fines After Cole: Fine Must Be Imposed, Then Ability-to-Pay Evaluated with Possible Suspension Case: State v. C. Spang, 2026 MT 107 (Mont. May 19, 2026) Court: Supreme Court of...

Cline v. Pritchard (Mont. 2026): No Rule 55(b)(2) Default-Hearing Notice Absent an “Appearance,” and Veterans’ Disability Benefits Lose Exemption Once Converted into Marital Real Property

Date: May 21, 2026

Cline v. Pritchard (Mont. 2026): No Rule 55(b)(2) Default-Hearing Notice Absent an “Appearance,” and Veterans’ Disability Benefits Lose Exemption Once Converted into Marital Real Property 1....

Montana’s 2026 Evidence Modernization Proposal: Deepfake Authentication Gatekeeping and a Forfeiture-by-Wrongdoing Hearsay Exception

Date: May 21, 2026

Montana’s 2026 Evidence Modernization Proposal: Deepfake Authentication Gatekeeping and a Forfeiture-by-Wrongdoing Hearsay Exception 1. Introduction In re the Montana Rules of Evidence (Supreme Court...

Auditable, Clerk-Run Random Selection for Substitution of Montana District Judges (Geographically Limited Pool)

Date: May 19, 2026

Auditable, Clerk-Run Random Selection for Substitution of Montana District Judges (Geographically Limited Pool) Proceeding: IN RE REVISED RULES ON SUBSTITUTION OF DISTRICT JUDGES Court: Supreme Court...

State v. Laman: Talksabout “Community Protection” Facts Are Not Mandatory; Patterned Predatory Sexual-Offense Allegations Can Defeat Youth-Court Transfer

Date: May 19, 2026

State v. Laman: Talksabout “Community Protection” Facts Are Not Mandatory; Patterned Predatory Sexual-Offense Allegations Can Defeat Youth-Court Transfer 1. Introduction In State v. G. Laman (2026 MT...

Guardianship in YINC Proceedings: No Dispositional-Hearing Prerequisite and Statutory Limits on a Guardian’s Adoption Consent

Date: May 19, 2026

Guardianship in YINC Proceedings: No Dispositional-Hearing Prerequisite and Statutory Limits on a Guardian’s Adoption Consent Introduction Matter of K.S., YINC (2026 MT 105N) is a Montana Supreme...

“Usable Form” Means Usable to the Commissioner: Agency-Specified Record Formats and Maximum Fines Upheld Under Montana Insurance Code

Date: May 19, 2026

“Usable Form” Means Usable to the Commissioner: Agency-Specified Record Formats and Maximum Fines Upheld Under Montana Insurance Code Case: Victory Insurance Co. v. State Auditor, 2026 MT 100 (Mont....

Ten-Year Lookback Limits DUI “Second-Offense” Penalties Despite a Second DUI Conviction

Date: May 13, 2026

Ten-Year Lookback Limits DUI “Second-Offense” Penalties Despite a Second DUI Conviction Introduction In State v. Snyder, 2026 MT 103N (Mont. May 12, 2026) (memorandum opinion; noncitable), the...