Montana Case Commentaries

State v. Adams (2026 MT 130) Commentary

Date: Jun 30, 2026

Decades-Old, Uncharged Prior Sexual-Abuse Allegations May Survive Rule 403 When Highly Similar and Offered for Non-Propensity Purposes; No Automatic Duty to Seek Contemporaneous Limiting Instructions...

Legislative “Random-Selection” Directives Do Not Supersede Montana’s Judicial Substitution Rule Absent Supreme Court Amendment

Date: Jun 30, 2026

Legislative “Random-Selection” Directives Do Not Supersede Montana’s Judicial Substitution Rule Absent Supreme Court Amendment Case: J. Williams v. G. Gianforte (2026 MT 131) | Court: Supreme Court...

Full Replacement Cost Restitution May Be the Price of a New Model When the Defendant Offers No Contrary Evidence

Date: Jun 30, 2026

Full Replacement Cost Restitution May Be the Price of a New Model When the Defendant Offers No Contrary Evidence 1. Introduction State v. T. Peterson (Mont. 2026 MT 129) arises from a break-in at Get...

Local Initiatives Cannot Create Countywide Land-Use Permitting Regimes Outside Title 76 (Treasure County v. Edlund)

Date: Jun 30, 2026

Local Initiatives Cannot Create Countywide Land-Use Permitting Regimes Outside Title 76 (Treasure County v. Edlund) 1. Introduction In Treasure County v. Edlund, 2026 MT 134 (DA 25-0498), the Montana...

Montana’s Emerging “Limited Admission Waiver” Framework for Community Justice Workers

Date: Jun 19, 2026

Montana’s Emerging “Limited Admission Waiver” Framework for Community Justice Workers 1. Introduction This Supreme Court of Montana administrative matter (AF 11-0765) arises from a September 15, 2025...

Non-Compelled Supervised Visitation for Traumatized Children Is Not Improper Delegation; Extracurricular Costs Must Be Reasonably Scoped and Properly Allocated

Date: Jun 17, 2026

Non-Compelled Supervised Visitation for Traumatized Children Is Not Improper Delegation; Extracurricular Costs Must Be Reasonably Scoped and Properly Allocated 1. Introduction Marriage of Bull (Mont....

Boyden v. Salmonsen — Prima Facie Habeas Pleading and Pre‑Filing Limits for Repetitive Sentence‑Credit Challenges

Date: Jun 10, 2026

Boyden v. Salmonsen: Prima Facie Habeas Pleading Requirements and Pre‑Filing Limits for Repetitive Sentence‑Credit Challenges 1. Introduction In Boyden v. Salmonsen (Mont. Sup. Ct. OP 26-0345, filed...

Bellamah v. Datsopoulas, MacDonald & Lind, P.C. (2026 MT 124) Commentary

Date: Jun 10, 2026

When Legal Malpractice Is Not a “Lost Appeal” Case: Pre‑Appeal Negligence Allegations Defeat Richards Summary Judgment and Are Properly Clarified Through Discovery 1. Introduction In Bellamah v....

Foster Parents Cannot Obtain Title 41 Dismissal/Custody as “Noncustodial Parents,” and Title 40 Parenting Plans Cannot Create Nonparent Parental Interests While a Title 41 Case Is Pending

Date: Jun 10, 2026

Foster Parents Cannot Obtain Title 41 Dismissal/Custody as “Noncustodial Parents,” and Title 40 Parenting Plans Cannot Create Nonparent Parental Interests While a Title 41 Case Is Pending 1....

Attorney General Discretion to Rewrite Initiative Ballot Statements, Limited by the “True and Impartial” Rule and Judicial Excisions of Argumentative Framing

Date: Jun 10, 2026

Attorney General Discretion to Rewrite Initiative Ballot Statements, Limited by the “True and Impartial” Rule and Judicial Excisions of Argumentative Framing Case: Transparent Election Initiative v....

Enforcing Prevailing-Party Fee Clauses in Parenting Plans: Untimely Contempt Appeals and Reasonableness Proven by Competent Evidence

Date: Jun 10, 2026

Enforcing Prevailing-Party Fee Clauses in Parenting Plans: Untimely Contempt Appeals and Reasonableness Proven by Competent Evidence Introduction In Okragly v. Keitel, 2026 MT 127N (Mont. June 9,...

Mandamus-Ordered MEPA Review Will Not Be Stayed Absent Concrete Mootness/Irreparable Harm Showing

Date: Jun 7, 2026

Mandamus-Ordered MEPA Review Will Not Be Stayed Absent Concrete Mootness/Irreparable Harm Showing 1. Introduction Case: American Prairie v. MT DNRC (Mont. Sup. Ct., Order dated 2026-06-04). Parties:...

MAS v. Board of Barbers: “Best Practices” and Internal Policy Deviations Alone Do Not Establish “Generally Accepted Standards of Practice” for License Discipline

Date: Jun 4, 2026

MAS v. Board of Barbers: “Best Practices” and Internal Policy Deviations Alone Do Not Establish “Generally Accepted Standards of Practice” for License Discipline Introduction In Montana Academy of...

Conclusive “Witness Unavailable” Is Not “Good Cause”: Montana Requires Record-Supported Specificity for Misdemeanor Speedy-Trial Continuances

Date: Jun 4, 2026

Conclusive “Witness Unavailable” Is Not “Good Cause”: Montana Requires Record-Supported Specificity for Misdemeanor Speedy-Trial Continuances Introduction In City of Helena v. Mayfield, the Montana...

ICWA Diligent-Efforts Challenges Must Be Timely: Acquiescence Waives Later Objections, and Putative Paternity Cannot Trigger ICWA Eligibility

Date: Jun 4, 2026

ICWA Diligent-Efforts Challenges Must Be Timely: Acquiescence Waives Later Objections, and Putative Paternity Cannot Trigger ICWA Eligibility Introduction In Matters of L.C., X.P. & N.C., YINC (2026...

Helt v. Guess (2026 MT 117): Child-Specific Findings Required to Restrict Parent-Child Contact in Orders of Protection

Date: Jun 3, 2026

Helt v. Guess (2026 MT 117): Child-Specific Findings Required to Restrict Parent-Child Contact in Orders of Protection 1. Introduction In Helt v. Guess, the Supreme Court of Montana reviewed a...

Reaffirming UCCJEA Limits on Relinquishment: A Pending Out-of-State Custody Proceeding Is Required, and Immaterial Inconvenient-Forum Factors Need Not Be Expressly Addressed

Date: Jun 3, 2026

Reaffirming UCCJEA Limits on Relinquishment: A Pending Out-of-State Custody Proceeding Is Required, and Immaterial Inconvenient-Forum Factors Need Not Be Expressly Addressed Introduction Marriage of...

CCYA Noncompliance as “Substantial Injustice”: Two-Year Remand for Rehabilitative Implementation and Meaningful Sentence Review

Date: Jun 3, 2026

CCYA Noncompliance as “Substantial Injustice”: Two-Year Remand for Rehabilitative Implementation and Meaningful Sentence Review 1. Introduction State v. I. Pehringer (2026 MT 115) addresses what...

Mailing (Not Actual Receipt) Satisfies Montana Notice of Foreign Judgment; Lis Pendens Is Not Stay Security; Unrelated Prior Firm Representation Does Not Require Disqualification

Date: Jun 3, 2026

Mailing (Not Actual Receipt) Satisfies Montana Notice of Foreign Judgment; Lis Pendens Is Not Stay Security; Unrelated Prior Firm Representation Does Not Require Disqualification Introduction In...

Montana Rule: A Buy-Sell + Seller-Financing Amendment Is Enforceable Despite Later “Mutually Agreed” Contract-for-Deed Terms; Added Public-Access Encumbrances Breach Condition-of-Title

Date: Jun 3, 2026

Montana Rule: A Buy-Sell + Seller-Financing Amendment Is Enforceable Despite Later “Mutually Agreed” Contract-for-Deed Terms; Added Public-Access Encumbrances Breach Condition-of-Title I....