Montana Case Commentaries

Matter of A.J.C., N.M.C., A.R.C., & S.J.C.: Failure to Object Waives Treatment-Plan Challenge on Appeal; Guardianship Not a Prerequisite to Termination

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Failure to Object Waives Treatment-Plan Challenge on Appeal; Guardianship Not a Prerequisite to Termination 1. Introduction In 2026 MT 80, In the Matter of A.J.C., N.M.C., A.R.C., and S.J.C., Youths...

Matter of A.R.C., YINC (2026 MT 80) — Waiver of Treatment-Plan Challenges Absent Timely Objection; No Requirement to Consider Guardianship Before Termination

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Waiver of Treatment-Plan Challenges Absent Timely Objection; No Requirement to Consider Guardianship Before Termination I. Introduction In Matter of A.R.C., YINC, 2026 MT 80, the Montana Supreme...

Treatment-Plan Waiver and No Duty to Consider Guardianship Absent a Petition in YINC Terminations (Mont. 2026 MT 80)

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Treatment-Plan Waiver and No Duty to Consider Guardianship Absent a Petition in YINC Terminations Case: In the Matter of: A.J.C., N.M.C., A.R.C., and S.J.C., Youths in Need of Care (2026 MT 80)...

Failure to Object Waives Treatment-Plan Challenges; No Sua Sponte Duty to Consider Guardianship Before Termination

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Failure to Object Waives Treatment-Plan Challenges; No Sua Sponte Duty to Consider Guardianship Before Termination Case: In the Matter of: A.J.C., N.M.C., A.R.C., and S.J.C., Youths in Need of Care,...

State v. Horn: Mandatory-Minimum DUI Fines Require Ability-to-Pay Findings (and Written Judgments Must Match Oral Sentences)

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Mandatory-Minimum DUI Fines Require Ability-to-Pay Findings Under § 46-18-231(3) (and Written Judgments Must Conform to Oral Pronouncements) Case: State v. C. Horn, 2026 MT 79 (Mont. Apr. 21, 2026)...

“Noting It for the Record” Does Not Preserve a Speedy-Trial Claim After a Guilty Plea (State v. Hill, 2026 MT 84)

Date: Apr 23, 2026

“Noting It for the Record” Does Not Preserve a Speedy-Trial Claim After a Guilty Plea (State v. Hill, 2026 MT 84) 1. Introduction State v. Hill is a Montana Supreme Court decision addressing whether...

Prefiling Leave Requirement for Repetitive, Meritless Original Writ Proceedings in Montana

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Prefiling Leave Requirement for Repetitive, Meritless Original Writ Proceedings in Montana 1. Introduction In Vaska v. Salmonsen (Mont. Apr. 21, 2026), petitioner Harlan Gerald Vaska, an inmate at...

Proposed § 3-1-804, MCA: Random, Documented, Proximity-Based Selection of Substitute District Judges (Notice-and-Comment Order)

Date: Apr 20, 2026

Proposed § 3-1-804, MCA: Random, Documented, Proximity-Based Selection of Substitute District Judges (Notice-and-Comment Order) 1. Introduction In re Revised Rules on Substitution of District Judges...

Kalarchik v. State: Article II, Section 4 Treats Transgender Status Discrimination as Sex Discrimination in Identity-Document Amendments (Strict Scrutiny at the Preliminary-Injunction Stage)

Date: Apr 17, 2026

Kalarchik v. State: Article II, Section 4 Treats Transgender Status Discrimination as Sex Discrimination in Identity-Document Amendments (Strict Scrutiny at the Preliminary-Injunction Stage) Court:...

State v. Trombley: Ability-to-Pay Harmonization Validates Mandatory DUI Minimum Fines (If Suspendable), and Probation Cannot Reinstate Suspended Monetary Sanctions

Date: Apr 17, 2026

State v. Trombley: Ability-to-Pay Harmonization Validates Mandatory DUI Minimum Fines (If Suspendable), and Probation Cannot Reinstate Suspended Monetary Sanctions 1. Introduction In State v....

Torgison v. Lincoln County: Preliminary Injunctions in Open-Meeting Cases Must Preserve the Status Quo and Cannot Be Used to Unwind Completed Property Contracts

Date: Apr 17, 2026

Torgison v. Lincoln County: Preliminary Injunctions in Open-Meeting Cases Must Preserve the Status Quo and Cannot Be Used to Unwind Completed Property Contracts 1. Introduction Parties. Daniel W....

Dolan v. Guenther (2026 MT 73) — COSA “Abandon Ditches” Conditions Defeat Implied Easements by Existing Use Absent Reasonable Contemplation at Severance

Date: Apr 9, 2026

COSA “Abandon Ditches” Conditions and Constructive Notice Can Negate the Intent Element for an Implied Easement by Existing Use Dolan v. Guenther, 2026 MT 73 (Mont. Apr. 7, 2026) — Supreme Court of...

Restitution as an Evidentiary Sentencing Issue: Uncontroverted Victim Testimony, Reasonably Certain Deductibles, and Preservation Limits

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Restitution as an Evidentiary Sentencing Issue: Uncontroverted Victim Testimony, Reasonably Certain Deductibles, and Preservation Limits Introduction In City of Helena v. Ittner (Mont. Sup. Ct. 2026...

Equal Protection Requires Parity Between Abortion-Clinic and Miscarriage-Care Regulation When Procedures Are Identical

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Equal Protection Requires Parity Between Abortion-Clinic and Miscarriage-Care Regulation When Procedures Are Identical 1. Introduction All Families Healthcare; Blue Mountain Clinic; and Helen Weems,...

Mandatory Minimum Fines and Ability-to-Pay: Courts Must Impose the Statutory Minimum but Suspend It to the Extent of Inability

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Mandatory Minimum Fines and Ability-to-Pay: Courts Must Impose the Statutory Minimum but Suspend It to the Extent of Inability 1. Introduction City of Whitefish v. T. Curran (Mont. 2026 MT 65)...

D’Hooge v. Cincinnati Ins. Co. (2026 MT 63): Pre-2023 § 33-18-242, MCA, Does Not Limit Third-Party Claimants to Bad-Faith Theories

Date: Apr 4, 2026

D’Hooge v. Cincinnati Ins. Co. (2026 MT 63): Pre-2023 § 33-18-242, MCA, Does Not Limit Third-Party Claimants to Bad-Faith Theories Introduction In D’Hooge v. Cincinnati Insurance Company, the Montana...

Probate Courts May Restrain a Personal Representative Under § 72-3-617, MCA, Without Converting Informal Probate or Applying Title 27 Injunction/Bond Requirements

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Probate Courts May Restrain a Personal Representative Under § 72-3-617, MCA, Without Converting Informal Probate or Applying Title 27 Injunction/Bond Requirements Introduction Estate of Sean Edward...

Supervised Parenting Time in Montana Dissolutions: No “Actual Harm” Finding Required Under § 40-4-219, and “De Facto” Emotional-Impairment Findings Suffice Under § 40-4-218(2)

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Supervised Parenting Time in Montana Dissolutions: No “Actual Harm” Finding Required Under § 40-4-219, and “De Facto” Emotional-Impairment Findings Suffice Under § 40-4-218(2) Introduction In re the...

Lowry v. State Electrical Board: Interpreter-Request Error Warrants Relief Only on Preserved Claims and a Showing of Substantial Prejudice Under MAPA

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Lowry v. State Electrical Board: Interpreter-Request Error Warrants Relief Only on Preserved Claims and a Showing of Substantial Prejudice Under MAPA Introduction In Lowry v. State, 2026 MT 71N...

Sham “Transfer” of Inherited Real Property May Be Treated as Marital for Equitable Apportionment; Maintenance Denied Absent Proof of Statutory Need

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Sham “Transfer” of Inherited Real Property May Be Treated as Marital for Equitable Apportionment; Maintenance Denied Absent Proof of Statutory Need 1. Introduction Marriage of Barrett (2026 MT 70N)...