Montana Case Commentaries

Reaffirming Trial-Court Discretion: Orders of Protection, Courtroom Control, and Best-Interest Parenting Plans Under § 40-4-212, MCA

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Reaffirming Trial-Court Discretion: Orders of Protection, Courtroom Control, and Best-Interest Parenting Plans Under § 40-4-212, MCA Introduction In re the Marriage of Snelson and Baez, 2026 MT 69N...

Matter of T.J.M.: Detention-Center Clinician May Serve as “Friend of Respondent” Absent Showing of Conflict; Technical Timing of Appointment Will Not Defeat Waiver

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Matter of T.J.M.: Detention-Center Clinician May Serve as “Friend of Respondent” Absent Showing of Conflict; Technical Timing of Appointment Will Not Defeat Waiver Introduction Matter of T.J.M....

Executed Oral Modification of Parenting-Plan Child Support Can Bar Arrears After a Long-Term Custody Shift (Marriage of Nevin, 2026 MT 62N)

Date: Mar 27, 2026

Executed Oral Modification of Parenting-Plan Child Support Can Bar Arrears After a Long-Term Custody Shift (In re the Marriage of Nevin, 2026 MT 62N) Nonprecedential status: The Court issued a...

State v. Pratt (2026 MT 58): Charging-Statute Controls—No Retroactive Prosecution Under Post‑2007 SVORA for Pre‑2007 Convictions

Date: Mar 27, 2026

Charging-Statute Controls: Montana Bars Retroactive Prosecution Under Post‑2007 SVORA When the Information Pleads Only the Current Act 1. Introduction In State v. Pratt, 2026 MT 58, the Montana...

Revocation Limits in Montana: Courts May Revoke Only Suspended/Deferred Time—Not the Probationary Remainder of a Custodial Sentence

Date: Mar 27, 2026

Revocation Limits in Montana: Courts May Revoke Only Suspended/Deferred Time—Not the Probationary Remainder of a Custodial Sentence Case: State v. Sanchez, 2026 MT 61 (Mont. Mar. 24, 2026) | Court:...

Roaring Lion Ranch v. YC Properties: Limits on Rule 12(d) Conversion When a Court References the Underlying Proceeding

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Roaring Lion Ranch v. YC Properties: Rule 12(d) Conversion Is Unnecessary (and Prejudicial) When the Court Only References the Underlying Proceeding Supreme Court of Montana — 2026 MT 60 (DA 25-0331)...

State v. Trombley: “Lawful Excuse” in Montana Bail Jumping Functions as an Affirmative Defense; the State Need Not Plead Its Absence

Date: Mar 26, 2026

State v. Trombley: “Lawful Excuse” in Montana Bail Jumping Functions as an Affirmative Defense; the State Need Not Plead Its Absence 1. Introduction In State v. Trombley, 2026 MT 59, the Montana...

Pierce v. Salmonsen (Mont. 2026): Prefiling Leave Requirement for Repetitive Postconviction Filings and Territorial Habeas Jurisdiction

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Pierce v. Salmonsen (Mont. 2026): Prefiling Leave Requirement for Repetitive Postconviction Filings and Territorial Habeas Jurisdiction Introduction In Pierce v. Salmonsen (caption amended by the...

State v. Emmings: Coordinate-Jurisdiction Law-of-the-Case Limits Reconsideration; Out-of-State Residency on Conditional Discharge Does Not Terminate a Sentence

Date: Mar 20, 2026

State v. Emmings: Coordinate-Jurisdiction Law-of-the-Case Limits Reconsideration; Out-of-State Residency on Conditional Discharge Does Not Terminate a Sentence Case: State v. A. Emmings, 2026 MT 54...

Front-End Participation Satisfies Article II, Section 8: MLUPA Site-Specific Limits Survive Facial Challenge (and Covenant Declaration Vacated as Advisory)

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Front-End Participation Satisfies Article II, Section 8: MLUPA Site-Specific Limits Survive Facial Challenge (and Covenant Declaration Vacated as Advisory) Introduction M.A.I.D. v. State (2026 MT 53)...

State v. Flores-Reyes: Third-Party Vehicle Consent Does Not Extend to Sealed Containers Hidden From View Absent Common Authority

Date: Mar 20, 2026

State v. Flores-Reyes: Third-Party Vehicle Consent Does Not Extend to Sealed Containers Hidden From View Absent Common Authority 1. Introduction In State v. Flores-Reyes (2026 MT 56), the Montana...

State v. Larson (2026 MT 55): Speedy-Trial Delay Is Counted Only When an Act Postpones the Trial/Disposition Date; Plea Negotiations Are Not a Waiver and the Clock Ends at the Plea

Date: Mar 20, 2026

State v. Larson (2026 MT 55): Speedy-Trial Delay Is Counted Only When an Act Postpones the Trial/Disposition Date; Plea Negotiations Are Not a Waiver and the Clock Ends at the Plea Court: Supreme...

Mandatory DUI Minimum Fines Are Constitutional When Courts Suspend the Unpayable Portion After a Required Ability-to-Pay Inquiry (Overruling State v. Gibbons)

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Mandatory DUI Minimum Fines Are Constitutional When Courts Suspend the Unpayable Portion After a Required Ability-to-Pay Inquiry (Overruling State v. Gibbons) Case: State v. N. Cole, 2026 MT 52...

Street-Time Credit on Revocation: Continuous-Violation Findings May Be Period-Based, Not a Daily Accounting

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Street-Time Credit on Revocation: Continuous-Violation Findings May Be Period-Based, Not a Daily Accounting Case: State v. Valenzuela, 2026 MT 57N (Mont. Mar. 17, 2026) (memorandum opinion,...

State v. Walton: Plain-Error Limits on Unpreserved Evidentiary Claims, Non-Mandatory 404(b) Limiting Instructions, and Permissible “Blind Expert” Testimony in Child Sexual Abuse Trials

Date: Mar 13, 2026

State v. Walton: Plain-Error Limits on Unpreserved Evidentiary Claims, Non-Mandatory 404(b) Limiting Instructions, and Permissible “Blind Expert” Testimony in Child Sexual Abuse Trials Introduction...

Record Silence Sends Ineffective-Assistance and Right-to-Testify Claims to Postconviction Review (State v. Roope)

Date: Mar 13, 2026

Record Silence Sends Ineffective-Assistance and Right-to-Testify Claims to Postconviction Review (State v. Roope) 1. Introduction In State v. Roope, 2026 MT 51N (Mont. Mar. 10, 2026) (memorandum...

Buck v. Conrad: Oral Pronouncement Controls; No Double-Counting of Jail Credit on Revocation

Date: Mar 13, 2026

Buck v. Conrad: Oral Pronouncement Controls; No Double-Counting of Jail Credit on Revocation 1. Introduction In Buck v. Conrad (Mont. Mar. 10, 2026), petitioner Michael A. Buck sought habeas corpus...

Flat-Fee Retainers and Counsel Withdrawal: No Cronic Presumption When Withdrawal Is Granted and New Counsel Appointed

Date: Mar 13, 2026

Flat-Fee Retainers and Counsel Withdrawal: No Cronic Presumption When Withdrawal Is Granted and New Counsel Appointed Case: K. Briggs v. State (2026 MT 47) | Court: Supreme Court of Montana | Date:...

Parenting-Plan Modification Requires Admissible Proof of Changed Circumstances; Judge’s Remote (Zoom) Appearance Is Not Structural/Plain Error Absent Prejudice

Date: Mar 13, 2026

Parenting-Plan Modification Requires Admissible Proof of Changed Circumstances; Judge’s Remote (Zoom) Appearance Is Not Structural/Plain Error Absent Prejudice Introduction Case: In re the Marriage...

Guilty Pleas to Some Counts in a Single Information Do Not Trigger § 46-11-503(1)(b) Double-Jeopardy Bar Absent a Judgment or Sentence

Date: Mar 12, 2026

Guilty Pleas to Some Counts in a Single Information Do Not Trigger § 46-11-503(1)(b) Double-Jeopardy Bar Absent a Judgment or Sentence 1. Introduction State v. Standifur (2026 MT 49) addresses the...