Montana Case Commentaries

Plain Error Must Be Requested in the Opening Brief; Napue Relief Requires Proof of Actual Falsity (State v. Stinger, 2026 MT 46)

Date: Mar 12, 2026

Plain Error Must Be Requested in the Opening Brief; Napue Relief Requires Proof of Actual Falsity 1. Introduction In State v. J. Stinger, the Supreme Court of Montana affirmed Justin Casey Stinger’s...

State v. Sandberg (2026 MT 45): “Victim” Labeling in Disputed-Crime Trials and the Limits of Consciousness-of-Guilt Evidence

Date: Mar 12, 2026

State v. Sandberg (2026 MT 45): “Victim” Labeling in Disputed-Crime Trials and the Limits of Consciousness-of-Guilt Evidence 1. Introduction In State v. K. Sandberg, the Supreme Court of Montana...

State v. Haacke (2026 MT 40): No Per Se For-Cause Strike for a Juror’s “Preference” That the Defense Rebut the State—Bias Assessed by Totality of Statements and Voir Dire Context

Date: Mar 7, 2026

No Per Se For-Cause Strike for a Juror’s “Preference” That the Defense Rebut the State—Impartiality Turns on the Totality of Statements and Voir Dire Context Case: State v. R. Haacke, 2026 MT 40...

Centron v. Hollewijn: Summary Judgment Must Track the Motion; “Reasonable Time” to Object in Account-Stated Claims Is Generally for the Jury

Date: Mar 7, 2026

Centron v. Hollewijn: Summary Judgment Must Track the Motion; “Reasonable Time” to Object in Account-Stated Claims Is Generally for the Jury 1. Introduction In Centron Services, Inc. d/b/a Rocky...

Permanent Protection Orders May Bar Parent-Child Contact Until Age 18 When Necessary to Prevent Harm

Date: Mar 7, 2026

Permanent Protection Orders May Bar Parent-Child Contact Until Age 18 When Necessary to Prevent Harm I. Introduction Darrah v. Haggag (Mont. 2026 MT 43N) concerns whether the Seventeenth Judicial...

State v. Hinkle (2026 MT 42): No Hearing Required on a Motion to Discharge a Jury Panel Absent Facts Showing Substantial Noncompliance Affecting Randomness/Objectivity

Date: Mar 6, 2026

State v. Hinkle (2026 MT 42): No Hearing Required on a Motion to Discharge a Jury Panel Absent Facts Showing Substantial Noncompliance Affecting Randomness/Objectivity Court: Supreme Court of Montana...

Closely Related “Initiative-and-Referendum Right” Amendments Satisfy Montana’s Separate-Vote Rule; Fiscal Statements Require a Determinable Fiscal Impact

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Closely Related “Initiative-and-Referendum Right” Amendments Satisfy Montana’s Separate-Vote Rule; Fiscal Statements Require a Determinable Fiscal Impact Introduction In T. Kendrick v. A. Knudsen...

Stability Over Equal Time: No Requirement to Find “Detriment” Before Declining Equal Residential Parenting Under § 40-4-212, MCA

Date: Feb 27, 2026

Stability Over Equal Time: No Requirement to Find “Detriment” Before Declining Equal Residential Parenting Under § 40-4-212, MCA Introduction In re the Marriage of Cool, 2026 MT 38N, is a Montana...

Notice and Element-by-Element Proof Required Before the Water Court May Generate Implied Pre-1973 Use Rights Outside a Decreed Period of Use

Date: Feb 27, 2026

Notice and Element-by-Element Proof Required Before the Water Court May Generate Implied Pre-1973 Use Rights Outside a Decreed Period of Use Petrich Family Limited Partnership & Melin v. Trout...

Ambiguity Between “Bench-Trial” Jury Waivers and Permissive Arbitration Clauses Renders Arbitration Unenforceable in Montana

Date: Feb 26, 2026

Ambiguity Between “Bench-Trial” Jury Waivers and Permissive Arbitration Clauses Renders Arbitration Unenforceable in Montana Introduction In Bluebird Property Rentals, LLC and Alaina Garcia v. World...

Prison Time Is Service of Sentence, Not “Credit for Time Served”: No Double-Credit and No Parolee Elapsed-Time Credit

Date: Feb 26, 2026

Prison Time Is Service of Sentence, Not “Credit for Time Served”: No Double-Credit and No Parolee Elapsed-Time Credit Introduction In L. Short v. Salmonsen (Mont. Feb. 24, 2026), the Montana Supreme...

Repeated Custodial Flight as a Material Change Supporting Primary Placement and Progressive Supervised Contact (Mont. § 40-4-219, MCA)

Date: Feb 26, 2026

Repeated Custodial Flight as a Material Change Supporting Primary Placement and Progressive Supervised Contact (Mont. § 40-4-219, MCA) Case: In re the Parenting of L.D.K.-R. and H.I.K.-R., 2026 MT...

Due Process Notice and Element-by-Element Proof Required Before Generating Implied Water Right Claims Beyond a Decreed Period of Use

Date: Feb 26, 2026

Due Process Notice and Element-by-Element Proof Required Before Generating Implied Water Right Claims Beyond a Decreed Period of Use 1. Introduction Petrich Family Limited Partnership and James R....

PCR Mailbox Rule in Montana: Filing Is Complete Upon Clerk’s Receipt Despite Later Docketing for Fee Waiver

Date: Feb 26, 2026

PCR Mailbox Rule in Montana: Filing Is Complete Upon Clerk’s Receipt Despite Later Docketing for Fee Waiver Introduction In Rodriguez v. State (2026 MT 35N), Juan Anastasio Rodriguez sought...

Circumstantial Evidence Plus Corroborating Urinalysis Can Prove Knowing Possession Without Fingerprints/DNA (Mont. § 45-9-102, MCA)

Date: Feb 26, 2026

Circumstantial Evidence Plus Corroborating Urinalysis Can Prove Knowing Possession Without Fingerprints/DNA (Mont. § 45-9-102, MCA) 1. Introduction State v. Bunse, 2026 MT 36N (Mont. Feb. 24, 2026),...

Sentencing Illegality When a Court Penalizes the Exercise of Jury-Trial and Silence Rights

Date: Feb 26, 2026

Sentencing Illegality When a Court Penalizes the Exercise of Jury-Trial and Silence Rights 1. Introduction State v. Darrin William Matt (2026 MT 31) addresses a recurring constitutional fault line in...

State v. Johnson: Montana Clarifies that Two‑Way Video Testimony Requires Craig Necessity and Reliability—Not Witness Unavailability or Prosecutorial Good Faith

Date: Feb 26, 2026

State v. Johnson: Montana Clarifies that Two‑Way Video Testimony Requires Craig Necessity and Reliability—Not Witness Unavailability or Prosecutorial Good Faith Introduction In State v. Johnson (2026...

State v. Redd: The IAD Does Not Apply Until a Defendant Is “Serving a Term of Imprisonment,” and Pre-Sentence Federal Custody Is Not “Institutional Delay”

Date: Feb 26, 2026

State v. Redd: The IAD Does Not Apply Until a Defendant Is “Serving a Term of Imprisonment,” and Pre-Sentence Federal Custody Is Not “Institutional Delay” Court: Supreme Court of Montana | Date:...

Equitable Distribution in Montana Dissolution: No Mandatory Net-Worth Finding; Dissipation Considered Without Required Offsets

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Equitable Distribution in Montana Dissolution: No Mandatory Net-Worth Finding; Dissipation Considered Without Required Offsets Introduction Marriage of Long & Batista (Mont. Sup. Ct. Feb. 17, 2026)...

Attorney Assurances and Fiduciary Tolling Can Defeat a Rule 12(b)(6) Time-Bar in Criminal-Defense Malpractice; One Amendment as of Course Before a Responsive Pleading

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Attorney Assurances and Fiduciary Tolling Can Defeat a Rule 12(b)(6) Time-Bar in Criminal-Defense Malpractice; One Amendment as of Course Before a Responsive Pleading 1. Introduction In Rex Allen v....