Montana Case Commentaries

Difolco v. Montana State Hospital: MAPA Judicial Review Limits—Courts May Not Reweigh Evidence and Must Confine Review to the Administrative Record

Date: Feb 18, 2026

MAPA Judicial Review Limits—Courts May Not Reweigh Evidence and Must Confine Review to the Administrative Record Case: Difolco v. MT State Hospital, 2026 MT 26 Court: Supreme Court of Montana Date:...

Unresolved § 46-18-116 Sentence-Modification Motions Do Not Toll Finality or Extend Postconviction Deadlines

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Unresolved § 46-18-116 Sentence-Modification Motions Do Not Toll Finality or Extend Postconviction Deadlines Case: K.B. v. State, 2026 MT 29N (Mont. Feb. 17, 2026) Court: Supreme Court of Montana...

Pretrial Order Waiver: Stipulating to Trial on a Document Bars Later Hearsay Objections; Statutory Damage Cap Issues Deemed Unripe Pending Insurance Coverage

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Pretrial Order Waiver: Stipulating to Trial on a Document Bars Later Hearsay Objections; Statutory Damage Cap Issues Deemed Unripe Pending Insurance Coverage Case: Collins v. Whitefish Housing...

Matter of S.A. and J.P.: Parent Lacks Standing to Press Tribal Guardianship Preference Where ICWA-Termination Findings Are Supported Beyond a Reasonable Doubt

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Parent Lacks Standing to Press Tribal Guardianship Preference Where ICWA-Termination Findings Are Supported Beyond a Reasonable Doubt Introduction Matter of S.A. and J.P., Youths in Need of Care...

Inadmissible Hearsay Text Messages Are Not Harmless When They Bolster the Complainant and Undercut the Defense on Theft Elements and Value

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Inadmissible Hearsay Text Messages Are Not Harmless When They Bolster the Complainant and Undercut the Defense on Theft Elements and Value Case: State v. B. Henderson, 2026 MT 17 (Mont. Feb. 10,...

Atkinson v. Livingston: Montana’s Construction Statute of Repose Applies to Municipal Permitting and Inspection; “Completion” Triggered by Certificate of Substantial Completion

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Atkinson v. Livingston: Montana’s Construction Statute of Repose Applies to Municipal Permitting and Inspection; “Completion” Triggered by Certificate of Substantial Completion 1. Introduction In...

Unpreserved First Amendment As-Applied Challenges to Obstruction Convictions Require Plain-Error Showing; Police May Impose Reasonable Filming Distance Orders

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Unpreserved First Amendment As-Applied Challenges to Obstruction Convictions Require Plain-Error Showing; Police May Impose Reasonable Filming Distance Orders Case: City of Kalispell v. S. Doman,...

Parenting Plan Modification: “Changed Circumstances” Turns on the Children’s Impact, Not the Source of the Change

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Parenting Plan Modification: “Changed Circumstances” Turns on the Children’s Impact, Not the Source of the Change Introduction In re the Parenting of G.L.M.S. and T.L.S., Minor Children (Mont. 2026...

Decree-First Enforcement in § 85-5-301 Proceedings: Water Commissioners Must Administer the Controlling Preliminary Decree (Including Abstract Remarks from Court-Approved Stipulations)

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Decree-First Enforcement in § 85-5-301 Proceedings: Water Commissioners Must Administer the Controlling Preliminary Decree (Including Abstract Remarks from Court-Approved Stipulations) 1....

Imprecise “Change in Circumstances” Language Is Not Reversible Error When Title 41 Permanency Standards Are Substantively Applied

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Imprecise “Change in Circumstances” Language Is Not Reversible Error When Title 41 Permanency Standards Are Substantively Applied Introduction Matter of M.L.O.-L., 2026 MT 18, arises from Montana...

Long-Term Incarceration as an Independent Ground to Terminate Parental Rights Under § 41-3-609(4)(c), MCA

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Long-Term Incarceration as an Independent Ground to Terminate Parental Rights Under § 41-3-609(4)(c), MCA Introduction Matter of R.L.B., YINC, 2026 MT 22N (Mont. Feb. 10, 2026), arises from...

Matter of S.A. and J.P.: Parent Lacks Standing to Enforce Tribal Guardianship Preferences When ICWA Termination Findings Are Supported Beyond a Reasonable Doubt

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Matter of S.A. and J.P.: Parent Lacks Standing to Enforce Tribal Guardianship Preferences When ICWA Termination Findings Are Supported Beyond a Reasonable Doubt Court: Supreme Court of Montana Date:...

Discipline Exposure for Repeated Noncompliance and Unfounded Attacks on Judicial Integrity Under MRPC 1.1, 3.1, 3.4(c), 8.2, and 8.4

Date: Feb 10, 2026

Discipline Exposure for Repeated Noncompliance and Unfounded Attacks on Judicial Integrity Under MRPC 1.1, 3.1, 3.4(c), 8.2, and 8.4 Introduction Matter: In the Matter of Davina Attar, An Attorney at...

Disciplinary Enforcement Against Serial Non‑Meritorious Litigation, False Evidence, and Prejudicial Trial Publicity (MRPC 3.1, 3.3, 3.4, 3.6, 4.1, 8.4)

Date: Feb 10, 2026

Disciplinary Enforcement Against Serial Non‑Meritorious Litigation, False Evidence, and Prejudicial Trial Publicity (MRPC 3.1, 3.3, 3.4, 3.6, 4.1, 8.4) 1. Introduction Matter of John P. Meyer,...

State v. West: Preserving Appellate Review of Closing-Argument “Overlay” Videos and Waiver of Plain-Error Claims Raised Only in Reply

Date: Feb 5, 2026

State v. West: Preserving Appellate Review of Closing-Argument “Overlay” Videos and Waiver of Plain-Error Claims Raised Only in Reply Introduction State v. Grant Alan West (2026 MT 13) arose from an...

State v. Fish: Property-Owner “Move Along” Requests Supply Particularized Suspicion for a Post–Welfare-Check Trespass Stop (and Permit Identity/Warrant Checks)

Date: Feb 5, 2026

Property-Owner “Move Along” Requests Supply Particularized Suspicion for a Post–Welfare-Check Trespass Stop (and Permit Identity/Warrant Checks) Introduction In State v. R. Fish, the Montana Supreme...

Primary Custodial Parent Presumptively Receives Child Tax Dependency Deductions Absent Best-Interests Findings Justifying Allocation

Date: Jan 29, 2026

Primary Custodial Parent Presumptively Receives Child Tax Dependency Deductions Absent Best-Interests Findings Justifying Allocation Introduction Case: Marriage of Turek, 2026 MT 11N (Mont. Jan. 27,...

Excusable Neglect and the Necessity/Reasonableness of Post-Decree Attorney-Fee Awards Under § 40-4-110, MCA

Date: Jan 29, 2026

Excusable Neglect and the Necessity/Reasonableness of Post-Decree Attorney-Fee Awards Under § 40-4-110, MCA Introduction In re the Marriage of Craythorn & Beitler-Williams, 2026 MT 10N, is a...

Implied Public Notice Duty from Public-Comment Rights in Subdivision Exemption Reviews (Sapphire Coalition v. Ravalli County)

Date: Jan 29, 2026

Implied Public Notice Duty from Public-Comment Rights in Subdivision Exemption Reviews Case: Sapphire Coalition v. Ravalli County (2026 MT 9) Court: Supreme Court of Montana Date: January 27, 2026 1....

MSPA Environmental Assessments Need Only “Available” Information; Counties Need Not Resolve Scientific Uncertainty and May Rely on the Record as a Whole

Date: Jan 29, 2026

MSPA Environmental Assessments Need Only “Available” Information; Counties Need Not Resolve Scientific Uncertainty and May Rely on the Record as a Whole Case: Thompson Chain of Lakes Stewardship...