Hawaii Case Commentaries

Hawaiʻi PIP Benefits Require Proof of Prepaid-Plan Comparability; Statutory Definitions Defeat “Ambiguity”

Date: Jul 31, 2026

Hawaiʻi PIP Benefits Require Proof of Prepaid-Plan Comparability; Statutory Definitions Defeat “Ambiguity” I. Introduction Case: In the Matter of the Request for Payment of, Christopher Lawinski,...

Small Claims Courts in Hawaiʻi Lack Jurisdiction to Decide Pet Ownership (Replevin/Title) Disputes

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Small Claims Courts in Hawaiʻi Lack Jurisdiction to Decide Pet Ownership (Replevin/Title) Disputes 1. Introduction In Miller v. Collins (Haw. July 27, 2026), petitioner Alexandra Miller sought...

State v. Dela Cruz: A Tachibana Waiver Remains Valid Under the Totality of the Circumstances Even Without the Exact “Is Anyone Forcing You Not to Testify?” Question

Date: Jul 24, 2026

State v. Dela Cruz: A Tachibana Waiver Remains Valid Under the Totality of the Circumstances Even Without the Exact “Is Anyone Forcing You Not to Testify?” Question I. Introduction In State v. Dela...

Counties May Streamline SMA Permitting, Not Eliminate the Non‑Delegable CZMA “Assessment” (Final EA Required; No Categorical Self‑Certification Exemptions)

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Counties May Streamline SMA Permitting, Not Eliminate the Non‑Delegable CZMA “Assessment” (Final EA Required; No Categorical Self‑Certification Exemptions) I. Introduction In Maui Tomorrow Foundation...

Discredited Forensic Microscopy as “False Evidence”: HRPP Rule 40 Relief When Science Invalidates Trial Expert Testimony

Date: Jul 21, 2026

Discredited Forensic Microscopy as “False Evidence”: HRPP Rule 40 Relief When Science Invalidates Trial Expert Testimony 1. Introduction Case: Granillo v. State, SCWC-22-0000740 (Haw. July 15, 2026)....

State v. Woody: Two-Step Standard for State Continuances Based on Witness Unavailability; Rejection of the Lee Test

Date: Jul 14, 2026

State v. Woody: A Two-Step Standard for State Continuances Based on Witness Unavailability (HRPP Rule 48 Due Diligence First; Common-Law Good Cause Totality Second) and Rejection of the “Lee Test”...

“Involved in a Collision” Under HRS § 291C-12(a) Includes Non-Contact Drivers (and Vagueness Challenges Are As-Applied Absent First Amendment Concerns)

Date: Jul 4, 2026

“Involved in a Collision” Under HRS § 291C-12(a) Includes Non-Contact Drivers (and Vagueness Challenges Are As-Applied Absent First Amendment Concerns) Case: State v. Nahulu (Haw. July 2, 2026)...

State v. Tolentino (Haw. 2026): Mandatory Pretrial Evidentiary Voluntariness Hearings for Inculpatory Statements; New-Trial Remedy; Partial Overruling of State v. Goers

Date: Jul 4, 2026

Hawaiʻi’s Mandatory Pretrial Evidentiary Voluntariness Hearing Rule for Inculpatory Statements (and the New-Trial Remedy), with State v. Goers Partially Overruled I. Introduction In State v....

HRS § 291C-12(a) “Involved in a Collision” Includes Non-Contact Pursuit; Vagueness Challenges Are As-Applied Only; Bill of Particulars Can Supply Constitutionally Adequate Notice

Date: Jul 3, 2026

HRS § 291C-12(a) “Involved in a Collision” Includes Non-Contact Pursuit; Vagueness Challenges Are As-Applied Only; Bill of Particulars Can Supply Constitutionally Adequate Notice Case: State v....

Summary Judgment in Title-Contested Trespass Requires Deraignment of Title; Unchallenged Summary-Judgment Findings Are Not Binding on Appeal

Date: Jul 2, 2026

Summary Judgment in Title-Contested Trespass Requires Deraignment of Title; Unchallenged Summary-Judgment Findings Are Not Binding on Appeal I. Introduction In ATC Makena N Golf LLC v. Kaiama (Haw....

“In Means In”: HRS § 711-1110.9(1)(a) Requires the Recording Device (or Its Use) to Occur Inside the Private Place

Date: Jun 23, 2026

“In Means In”: HRS § 711-1110.9(1)(a) Requires the Recording Device (or Its Use) to Occur Inside the Private Place Case: State v. Kaakimaka (Haw. Sup. Ct. June 22, 2026, SCWC-22-0000690) (opinion by...

Preston v. Hiraoka: Meaningful Appellate Review Requires Kelepolo-Based Consideration of Bond or Alternative Security to Stay Ejectment Possession Judgments

Date: Jun 22, 2026

Preston v. Hiraoka: Meaningful Appellate Review Requires Kelepolo-Based Consideration of Bond or Alternative Security to Stay Ejectment Possession Judgments I. Introduction Preston v. Hiraoka (Haw....

Hawaiʻi Guardianship Termination: Parental Presumption Survives Consent; Unfitness Requires Clear and Convincing Proof

Date: Jun 22, 2026

Hawaiʻi Guardianship Termination: Parental Presumption Survives Consent; Unfitness Requires Clear and Convincing Proof Case: In the Matter of the Guardianship of I.W. and T.E., SCWC-23-0000356 (Haw....

State v. Jercy: Show-Up Identifications Must Be Evaluated Under HAWJIC 3.19A and the Effect of Suggestiveness, with Suppression Required When the Record Shows Unreliability

Date: Jun 18, 2026

State v. Jercy: Show-Up Identifications Must Be Evaluated Under HAWJIC 3.19A and the Effect of Suggestiveness, with Suppression Required When the Record Shows Unreliability 1. Introduction State v....

Unambiguous Video Evidence Limits “Reasonably Susceptible” Inferences at Summary Judgment in Hawaiʻi

Date: Jun 8, 2026

Unambiguous Video Evidence Limits “Reasonably Susceptible” Inferences at Summary Judgment in Hawaiʻi I. Introduction Bellamy v. City and County of Honolulu (Haw. June 5, 2026) is a...

Premature Termination Before a Set Corrective-Action Deadline Does Not Prove “Misconduct” Disqualifying Hawaiʻi Unemployment Benefits

Date: Jun 7, 2026

Premature Termination Before a Set Corrective-Action Deadline Does Not Prove “Misconduct” Disqualifying Hawaiʻi Unemployment Benefits Introduction Choi v. Tachibana Enterprises, LLC (Hawaiʻi Supreme...

State v. Ellway: Mid‑Evidence Judge Replacement in a Criminal Bench Trial Ends the First Trial and Triggers Double Jeopardy Absent a Proper Mistrial

Date: Jun 7, 2026

State v. Ellway: Mid‑Evidence Judge Replacement in a Criminal Bench Trial Ends the First Trial and Triggers Double Jeopardy Absent a Proper Mistrial I. Introduction In State v. Ellway (Haw. June 5,...

“Good Cause” for Untimely Intervention Before the Maui Planning Commission Means a “Sufficient Reason,” Not the Chen v. Mah Default Standard

Date: May 24, 2026

“Good Cause” for Untimely Intervention Before the Maui Planning Commission Means a “Sufficient Reason,” Not the Chen v. Mah Default Standard Gutschmidt v. Maui Planning Commission (Haw. May 22, 2026)...

JK v. HK (Haw. 2026): Gender-Neutral “Holding Out” Presumption Establishes Parentage for Unmarried, Nonbiological Parents Under the 1973 UPA

Date: May 20, 2026

Gender-Neutral “Holding Out” Presumption Establishes Parentage for Unmarried, Nonbiological Parents Under the 1973 UPA 1. Introduction In JK v. HK (Supreme Court of Hawaiʻi, May 18, 2026), the court...

State v. Wilhelm: Harmless-Error Treatment of a Late Voluntariness Determination Under HRS § 621-26

Date: May 20, 2026

State v. Wilhelm: Harmless-Error Treatment of a Late Voluntariness Determination Under HRS § 621-26 Court: Intermediate Court of Appeals of the State of Hawaiʻi (Summary Disposition Order; Not for...