Calcutta High Court Case Commentaries

Conviction Set Aside for Unreliable Related-Witness Testimony, Unnatural Conduct, and FIR/Investigation Infirmities

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Conviction Set Aside for Unreliable Related-Witness Testimony, Unnatural Conduct, and FIR/Investigation Infirmities 1. Introduction Case: Bishnupada Choudhury & Ors. v. The State of West Bengal...

Maintenance Tribunals Cannot Order Eviction Under Sections 4–5 of the 2007 Act; Their Orders Are Amenable to Article 226 Review

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Maintenance Tribunals Cannot Order Eviction Under Sections 4–5 of the 2007 Act; Their Orders Are Amenable to Article 226 Review 1. Introduction These connected writ petitions before the Calcutta High...

Final Partition Decree Incorporating a Commissioner’s Plan Is a Dutiable “Instrument of Partition” Even Where Physical Partition Is Impracticable

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Final Partition Decree Incorporating a Commissioner’s Plan Is a Dutiable “Instrument of Partition” Even Where Physical Partition Is Impracticable 1. Introduction Case: Subrata Nundy v. The Collector...

DV Act Jurisdiction at Temporary Shelter: Section 482 CrPC Maintainable and “Economic Abuse” Creates a Continuing Cause of Action

Date: Feb 19, 2026

DV Act Jurisdiction at Temporary Shelter: Section 482 CrPC Maintainable and “Economic Abuse” Creates a Continuing Cause of Action 1. Introduction In RANI BIBI v. SK NURULLAH AND ORS (Calcutta High...

Family Quarrel, Household Weapons, and a Three-Minute Interval: When Homicide Falls Under Section 304 Part I (Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC), Not Section 302

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Family Quarrel, Household Weapons, and a Three-Minute Interval: When Homicide Falls Under Section 304 Part I (Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC), Not Section 302 Case: AIMUDDIN SHEIKH & ANR v. STATE OF...

Only Statutory Deductions (Income Tax/Professional Tax) Reduce “Monthly Income” in Motor Accident Dependency Claims; GPF/Group Insurance Not Deductible

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Only Statutory Deductions (Income Tax/Professional Tax) Reduce “Monthly Income” in Motor Accident Dependency Claims; GPF/Group Insurance Not Deductible Case: SWAPNA BHATTACHARJEE & ANR. v. THE NEW...

Parity in Recruitment: Illegally Introduced Interview Cut-offs Must Not Defeat Higher Merit of Similarly Situated Candidates

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Parity in Recruitment: Illegally Introduced Interview Cut-offs Must Not Defeat Higher Merit of Similarly Situated Candidates 1. Introduction The Calcutta High Court in NIRMAL CHANDRA BISWAS v. State...

Employer-Driven Delay Cannot Defeat Compassionate Employment: Age-Bar Not Determinative; Notional Seniority from Date of Reference

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Employer-Driven Delay Cannot Defeat Compassionate Employment: Age-Bar Not Determinative; Notional Seniority from Date of Reference Case: EASTERN COALFIELDS LIMITED v. UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS Court:...

Non-renewal of a fixed-term contract is not punitive “termination”; ministerial backdoor engagement without a sanctioned post/procedure is void

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Non-renewal of a fixed-term contract is not punitive “termination”; ministerial backdoor engagement without a sanctioned post/procedure is void Case TITHI ADHIKARY v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Court...

Delay in Seeking Probate Is Not a Bar: It Is Only a Rebuttable Suspicious Circumstance; Limitation Runs From When Probate Becomes Necessary

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Delay in Seeking Probate Is Not a Bar: It Is Only a Rebuttable Suspicious Circumstance; Limitation Runs From When Probate Becomes Necessary Case: RAJA SHAH AND ORS v. KOWSHIK SHOW AND ORS Court:...

Execution of Partition Final Decree: Decree-Holder May Pay Total Stamp Duty to Make Decree Executable, With Liberty to Recover From Co-sharers

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Execution of Partition Final Decree: Decree-Holder May Pay Total Stamp Duty to Make Decree Executable, With Liberty to Recover From Co-sharers 1. Introduction In SANDIP KUMAR SAHA v. SOMNATH SAHA AND...

Article 226 Cannot Be Used to Bypass an Appellate Remedy Against an Appealable Municipal Demolition Order

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Article 226 Cannot Be Used to Bypass an Appellate Remedy Against an Appealable Municipal Demolition Order 1. Introduction In Smti. Kishori Bala Das v. The Andaman and Nicobar Administration and Ors....

Section 20 Presumption Under the PC Act Is Not Automatic: Demand-and-Acceptance Must Be Proved as Foundational Facts

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Section 20 Presumption Under the PC Act Is Not Automatic: Demand-and-Acceptance Must Be Proved as Foundational Facts 1. Introduction In THE STATE v. SHRI. M. HARI KRISHNA (Calcutta High Court,...

Omnibus Allegations and Unproved Common Intention Cannot Sustain a Section 323 IPC Conviction in Revision

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Omnibus Allegations and Unproved Common Intention Cannot Sustain a Section 323 IPC Conviction in Revision 1. Introduction In Sambhu Das @ Shambhu Das & Ors. v. State of West Bengal & Anr. (Calcutta...

Conviction under the Essential Commodities Act Requires Reliable Stock Verification: “Stick-measurement” of Sloped Underground Tanks and Hostile Raid Witnesses Create Reasonable Doubt

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Conviction under the Essential Commodities Act Requires Reliable Stock Verification: “Stick-measurement” of Sloped Underground Tanks and Hostile Raid Witnesses Create Reasonable Doubt 1. Introduction...

Contempt Jurisdiction Cannot Be Used as a Vehicle for Supplemental Relief Beyond the Original Writ Directions

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Contempt Jurisdiction Cannot Be Used as a Vehicle for Supplemental Relief Beyond the Original Writ Directions 1. Introduction This decision of the Calcutta High Court (Madhuresh Prasad, J. and...

Disaster Compensation for Tsunami Losses Cannot Be Denied Solely Due to Later Expiry of Land Grant; Corporate Farming Grantees Eligible Subject to Surrender Condition under 30.07.2012 Policy

Date: Feb 6, 2026

Disaster Compensation for Tsunami Losses Cannot Be Denied Solely Due to Later Expiry of Land Grant; Corporate Farming Grantees Eligible Subject to Surrender Condition under 30.07.2012 Policy 1....

Quashing of a Second 156(3) Complaint on the Same Incident for Abuse of Process and Non-Compliance with Section 154 Preconditions

Date: Jan 31, 2026

Quashing of a Second 156(3) Complaint on the Same Incident for Abuse of Process and Non-Compliance with Section 154 Preconditions 1. Introduction The Calcutta High Court, in ASISH BERA AND OTHERS v....

Preconditions for Section 156(3) CrPC Complaints and Gender-Specific Scope of Section 354B IPC

Date: Jan 31, 2026

Preconditions for Section 156(3) CrPC Complaints and Gender-Specific Scope of Section 354B IPC: Quashing as Abuse of Process 1. Introduction The Calcutta High Court (Criminal Revisional Jurisdiction)...

Civil Suit Dismissal Without a Finding on Forgery Does Not Warrant Quashing of Forgery/Cheating FIR Under Section 482 CrPC

Date: Jan 30, 2026

Civil Suit Dismissal Without a Finding on Forgery Does Not Warrant Quashing of Forgery/Cheating FIR Under Section 482 CrPC 1. Introduction The Calcutta High Court (Circuit Bench at Jalpaiguri), in...