Calcutta High Court Case Commentaries

Stigmatic “Probation Termination” is Punitive: Misconduct-Based Discharge Cannot Be Passed as Termination Simpliciter

Date: Jan 29, 2026

Stigmatic “Probation Termination” is Punitive: Misconduct-Based Discharge Cannot Be Passed as Termination Simpliciter 1. Introduction The Calcutta High Court (Division Bench: Tapabrata Chakraborty,...

Mandatory termination of petty-offence juvenile proceedings if Section 14(2) JJ Act timeline lapses: reasoned extension is essential

Date: Jan 28, 2026

Mandatory termination of petty-offence juvenile proceedings if Section 14(2) JJ Act timeline lapses: reasoned extension is essential 1. Introduction The Calcutta High Court in Child in conflict with...

Executor/Legatee May Sue to Protect Estate Pre-Probate in Section 57 Territories; Copyright Infringement as Continuing Cause Defeats Order IX Rule 9 Bar

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Executor/Legatee May Sue to Protect Estate Pre-Probate in Section 57 Territories; Copyright Infringement as Continuing Cause Defeats Order IX Rule 9 Bar 1. Introduction DEV SAHITYA KUTIR PVT LTD v....

Child-Witness Competency Must Be Properly Recorded; Inquest Omissions and FIR Delay Can Undermine a Homicide Prosecution

Date: Jan 21, 2026

Child-Witness Competency Must Be Properly Recorded; Inquest Omissions and FIR Delay Can Undermine a Homicide Prosecution 1) Introduction In SK. MORSED ALI & ORS. v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL (Calcutta...

Administrative Recall of a Void Appellate Order for Lack of Jurisdiction (Recall ≠ Review) and Consequential Withholding of Promotion Pending Statutory Appeal

Date: Jan 16, 2026

Administrative Recall of a Void Appellate Order for Lack of Jurisdiction (Recall ≠ Review) and Consequential Withholding of Promotion Pending Statutory Appeal 1. Introduction Case: Debanjan Guha v....

Commissioner’s Report Cannot “Construct” Reasonable Requirement: Landlord’s Evolving Need Prevails Unless Shown to be Fantasy or Exaggeration

Date: Jan 16, 2026

Commissioner’s Report Cannot “Construct” Reasonable Requirement: Landlord’s Evolving Need Prevails Unless Shown to be Fantasy or Exaggeration Case: RATAN KARMAKAR AND ORS. v. SMT. CHAINA DAS AND ORS....

“Immediate” Forwarding Under Section 19(2) PMLA Means Reasonable Promptness: Holidays/After-Hours Delay Not Fatal; Writ Review Confined to Statutory Safeguards

Date: Jan 8, 2026

“Immediate” Forwarding Under Section 19(2) PMLA Means Reasonable Promptness: Holidays/After-Hours Delay Not Fatal; Writ Review Confined to Statutory Safeguards 1. Introduction In Yogesh Dua v/s....

Reasoned Patent Examination Mandate: Teaching-Away, Claim-Mapping for Inventive Step, and Synergy Assessment under Section 3(e)

Date: Jan 7, 2026

Reasoned Patent Examination Mandate: Teaching-Away, Claim-Mapping for Inventive Step, and Synergy Assessment under Section 3(e) 1. Introduction In OCV INTELLECTUAL CAPITAL LLC (SR. NO....

Shareholder Locus to Challenge RBI Permission for NRI Share Allotment: Judicial Review Limited to Illegality, Mala Fides, or Non-Application of Mind

Date: Dec 25, 2025

Shareholder Locus to Challenge RBI Permission for NRI Share Allotment: Judicial Review Limited to Illegality, Mala Fides, or Non-Application of Mind 1. Introduction The decision in SAJAL DUTTA v....

Once an Advertisement is Held Disparaging, Cosmetic Editing Cannot Cure It: Commentary on Shree Baidyanath Ayurved Bhawan Pvt. Ltd. v. Dabur India Ltd.

Date: Dec 15, 2025

Once a Comparative Advertisement is Found Disparaging, Deletion of Isolated Words Cannot Save It: A Commentary on Shree Baidyanath Ayurved Bhawan Pvt. Ltd. v. Dabur India Limited Court: High Court at...

Primacy of Overall Trade Dress and Average Consumer Recall in Passing Off: Commentary on Edible Products (India) Ltd v. Shalimar Chemical Works Pvt Ltd

Date: Dec 10, 2025

Primacy of Overall Trade Dress and Average Consumer Recall in Passing Off: Commentary on Edible Products (India) Ltd v. Shalimar Chemical Works Pvt Ltd 1. Introduction The Division Bench of the...

Presumption of Trademark Ownership in Foreign Manufacturers and the Limits of Importers’ Rights under Section 30: Commentary on Parul Ruparelia v. Camme Wang

Date: Dec 8, 2025

Presumption of Trademark Ownership in Foreign Manufacturers and the Limits of Importers’ Rights under Section 30: A Commentary on Parul Ruparelia & Anr v. Camme Wang & Anr, Calcutta High Court (IPD),...

Primacy of NCLT and Limits of Writ Jurisdiction over Personal Guarantor Insolvency under Section 95 IBC: Commentary on Sanjay Jhunjhunwala & Ors. v. Piramal Finance Ltd. & Ors.

Date: Dec 4, 2025

Primacy of NCLT and Limits of Writ Jurisdiction over Personal Guarantor Insolvency under Section 95 IBC I. Introduction A. Background of the Dispute The decision in Sanjay Jhunjhunwala & Ors. v....

Borrower’s Inability to Enforce Non‑Statutory One‑Time Settlements and Threshold Rejection of Suits: Commentary on Senbo Engineering Ltd v. Bank of Maharashtra

Date: Dec 4, 2025

Borrower’s Inability to Enforce Non‑Statutory One‑Time Settlements and Threshold Rejection of Suits: Commentary on Senbo Engineering Ltd v. Bank of Maharashtra 1. Introduction The decision of the...

Vague and Contradictory Allegations Cannot Sustain Conviction under Section 498-A IPC: Commentary on Ranjit Saha v. State of West Bengal & Anr.

Date: Nov 28, 2025

Vague and Contradictory Allegations Cannot Sustain Conviction under Section 498-A IPC: Commentary on Ranjit Saha & Anr. v. State of West Bengal & Anr. Case: CRA 14 of 2004 | Court: Calcutta High...

Disjunctive Service on Corporations under Order XXIX Rule 2 CPC and the Non‑Extendable 120‑Day Limit for Written Statements: Commentary on MSC Mediterranean Shipping Co. S.A. & Anr. v. NTC Industries Ltd.

Date: Nov 27, 2025

Disjunctive Service on Corporations under Order XXIX Rule 2 CPC and the Non‑Extendable 120‑Day Limit for Written Statements: Commentary on MSC Mediterranean Shipping Co. S.A. & Anr. v. NTC Industries...

Trust Rules vs Statutory Pension Rights: Calcutta High Court on Higher Pension for Employees of Exempted Establishments

Date: Nov 21, 2025

Trust Rules vs Statutory Pension Rights: Calcutta High Court’s Extension of Higher Pension to Employees of Exempted Establishments 1. Introduction This commentary examines the judgment dated 14...

Destructive Use of Human Embryos as Non‑Patentable Subject Matter under Section 3(b): Commentary on Shroff Geeta v. Assistant Controller of Patents & Designs (Calcutta High Court, 2025)

Date: Nov 19, 2025

Destructive Use of Human Embryos as Non‑Patentable Subject Matter under Section 3(b): A Detailed Commentary on Shroff Geeta (OA/10/2019/PT/KOL) v. Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs Court:...

Reversal-under-Protest Is Not a Pre-Deposit; IBC Approval Abates CESTAT Appeals and Leaves Tribunal Functus Officio: Calcutta High Court in Tata Steel Ltd. v. Union of India

Date: Nov 17, 2025

Reversal-under-Protest Is Not a Pre-Deposit; IBC Approval Abates CESTAT Appeals and Leaves Tribunal Functus Officio Introduction In a set of writ petitions arising out of tax disputes of the...

Pragmatic Condonation Within the 120‑Day Cap: Calcutta High Court Clarifies Discretion and Costs under Order VIII Rule 1 CPC

Date: Nov 11, 2025

Pragmatic Condonation Within the 120‑Day Cap: Calcutta High Court Clarifies Discretion and Costs under Order VIII Rule 1 CPC Introduction In Central Bank of India & Ors v. Jay Kumar Goyal & Ors (IA...