All High Courts Case Commentaries

Strict “Due Diligence” Standard for Post-Evidence Filing of Public Revenue Records under Order 8 Rule 1-A CPC

Date: Mar 25, 2026

Strict “Due Diligence” Standard for Post-Evidence Filing of Public Revenue Records under Order 8 Rule 1-A CPC 1. Introduction In Khem Singh v. Dila Ram (Himachal Pradesh High Court, decided on...

Election petitions on Form 26 non-disclosure: strict pleading of pendency/particulars and “materially affected” is mandatory

Date: Mar 25, 2026

Election petitions alleging Form 26 defects must plead (i) pendency/status and full particulars, and (ii) how the result was “materially affected”—a bald assertion is insufficient Case: NAYANA MANOJ...

Expired Select Panels Cannot Be Revived for Fence-Sitters: Parity Is Barred by Laches and Negative Equality

Date: Mar 25, 2026

Expired Select Panels Cannot Be Revived for Fence-Sitters: Parity Is Barred by Laches and Negative Equality 1. Introduction This Letters Patent Appeal (Letters Patent Appeal No.891 of 2025) arose...

Rule 45 (60-day) testing timeline and preservation of Section 25 re-testing rights as a precondition to sustainable prosecution under the Drugs & Cosmetics Act

Date: Mar 25, 2026

Mandatory 60-day testing under Rule 45 and timely prosecution to protect Section 25 re-testing rights: failure renders Drugs Act proceedings an abuse of process Case: C. B. HEALTHCARE, THROUGH ITS...

IP-Anchored Composite Commercial Suits & Targeted Interim Takedown of Ex Facie Disparaging Remarks in Media-Critique Content (Delhi High Court)

Date: Mar 24, 2026

IP-Anchored Composite Commercial Suits & Targeted Interim Takedown of Ex Facie Disparaging Remarks in Media-Critique Content 1. Introduction In TV TODAY NETWORK LIMITED v. NEWS LAUNDRY MEDIA PRIVATE...

Mutual Exclusivity of Cheating (Section 420 IPC) and Criminal Breach of Trust (Section 406 IPC) in Job-Procurement Fraud

Date: Mar 24, 2026

Mutual Exclusivity of Cheating (Section 420 IPC) and Criminal Breach of Trust (Section 406 IPC) in Job-Procurement Fraud 1) Introduction Case: Rameshchandra v. The State Of Madhya Pradesh (2026...

Unreliable Sole Eyewitness and Chance Dock Identification (Without TIP) Cannot Sustain a Section 302/34 IPC Conviction

Date: Mar 24, 2026

Unreliable Sole Eyewitness and Chance Dock Identification (Without TIP) Cannot Sustain a Section 302/34 IPC Conviction 1. Introduction In VIRENDER ALIAS BABLU v. STATE NCT OF DELHI (Delhi High Court,...

Combatisation “Inheres in the Cadre”: Ex-servicemen appointed in combatised ranks cannot claim civilian superannuation; Rules for non-combatised posts do not apply

Date: Mar 24, 2026

Combatisation “Inheres in the Cadre”: Ex-servicemen appointed in combatised ranks cannot claim civilian superannuation; non-combatised recruitment rules cannot be used to extend retirement to 60...

Maintenance under Section 125 CrPC: “May Earn” vs “Is Earning”—Qualified Wife Entitled Absent Proof of Income; Streedhan Not a Defence; Modification under BNSS §145

Date: Mar 24, 2026

Maintenance under Section 125 CrPC: “May Earn” vs “Is Earning”—Qualified Wife Entitled Absent Proof of Income; Streedhan Not a Defence; Modification under BNSS §145 1) Introduction The decision in...

Visitation/Interim Custody Orders Must Be Prayer-Based, Child-Centric, and Cannot Flow from a Mere Pursis

Date: Mar 24, 2026

Visitation/Interim Custody Orders Must Be Prayer-Based, Child-Centric, and Cannot Flow from a Mere Pursis 1) Introduction In MANSIBEN W/O DHARMENDRABHAI KESHAVJIBHAI GHETIYA D/O BHAGVANJIBHAI...

Dismissal in Minority Schools: Termination Must Be by the “Manager” (Office-Holder) and Cannot Be Effected Through Ad-hoc Authorisation of a Non-Office Bearer

Date: Mar 21, 2026

Dismissal in Minority Schools: Termination Must Be by the “Manager” (Office-Holder) and Cannot Be Effected Through Ad-hoc Authorisation of a Non-Office Bearer Case: THE TRUSTEE, AHMEDABAD JESUITS...

Family Pensioners Under State Health Schemes Cannot Be Treated as “Dependents” for Age-Barred Medical Reimbursement; State Bound by Scheme Coverage and Deductions

Date: Mar 21, 2026

Family Pensioners Under State Health Schemes Cannot Be Treated as “Dependents” for Age-Barred Medical Reimbursement; State Bound by Scheme Coverage and Deductions 1. Introduction The Uttarakhand High...

Acquittal on Proven Alibi Rendering Departmental Findings “No Evidence”: Reinstatement of Police Personnel Despite Parallel Misconduct Proceedings

Date: Mar 21, 2026

Acquittal on Proven Alibi Rendering Departmental Findings “No Evidence”: Reinstatement of Police Personnel Despite Parallel Misconduct Proceedings Case: STATE OF ODISHA v. BANSIDHAR BARIKI, W.A. No....

Earned Annual Increment Cannot Be Denied Merely Because It Becomes Payable the Day After Retirement

Date: Mar 21, 2026

Earned Annual Increment Cannot Be Denied Merely Because It Becomes Payable the Day After Retirement Case: UNION OF INDIA & ORS. v. NARESH KUMAR GUPTA (2026 DHC 2369-DB) | Court: Delhi High Court |...

Post-Retirement Recovery in Pending Departmental Proceedings: Only Government May Impose Penalty Under Rule 7(2)(a) Proviso, OCS (Pension) Rules, 1992

Date: Mar 21, 2026

Post-Retirement Recovery in Pending Departmental Proceedings: Only Government May Impose Penalty Under Rule 7(2)(a) Proviso, OCS (Pension) Rules, 1992 1) Introduction In Somanath Rout (dead) through...

Secretariat–Non-Secretariat Pay Parity: Historical Parity and Common Recruitment Do Not Compel Judicially-Directed Pay Equality Contrary to Pay Commission Design

Date: Mar 21, 2026

Secretariat–Non-Secretariat Pay Parity: Historical Parity and Common Recruitment Do Not Compel Judicially-Directed Pay Equality Contrary to Pay Commission Design Case: ITGOA & ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA...

Suspicious Non‑Magisterial Dying Declaration and Non‑Recording of Section 164 CrPC Statements: Acquittal in a Burn‑Death Prosecution

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Suspicious Non‑Magisterial Dying Declaration and Non‑Recording of Section 164 CrPC Statements: Acquittal in a Burn‑Death Prosecution 1. Introduction In KADER MIA v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL (Calcutta...

Benefit of Doubt Where Demand Is Attributed to a Third Person and a Listed Trap Witness Is Withheld

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Benefit of Doubt Where Demand Is Attributed to a Third Person and a Listed Trap Witness Is Withheld 1. Introduction Case: Rajinder Kumar v. C.B.I. (2026 DHC 2130), Delhi High Court, decided on...

Trap-Evidence Corruption Prosecutions Not Quashed at Section 482 Stage Despite Alleged Breach of West Bengal ACB “Assignment & Preliminary Enquiry” Protocol

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Trap-Evidence Corruption Prosecutions Not Quashed at Section 482 Stage Despite Alleged Breach of West Bengal ACB “Assignment & Preliminary Enquiry” Protocol Case: SANDIP KUMAR ROY v. STATE OF WEST...

Section 175(3) BNSS: Magistrate’s “Inquiry” Must Be Conducted by the Magistrate (No Police-Delegation) and Must Test Cognizable Offence + Sufficient Ground to Investigate

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Section 175(3) BNSS: Magistrate’s “Inquiry” Must Be Conducted by the Magistrate (No Police-Delegation) and Must Test Cognizable Offence + Sufficient Ground to Investigate Court: Calcutta High Court...