All High Courts Case Commentaries

Bombay High Court (Aurangabad): Penalty for Alleged Illegal Sand Excavation Cannot Rest on an Undated/Ex Parte Panchanama and Contradictory Official Record

Date: Mar 27, 2026

Penalty for Alleged Illegal Sand Excavation Cannot Rest on an Undated/Ex Parte Panchanama and Contradictory Official Record Case: Gunaji Ramji Surnar Vs The State of Maharashtra Through Secretary and...

Section 47 Disability Protection Does Not Carry Cadre Seniority on Shift/Absorption

Date: Mar 27, 2026

Section 47 Disability Protection Does Not Carry Cadre Seniority on Shift/Absorption; Existing Cadre Seniority Cannot Be Disturbed 1. Introduction In RAMESHWAR S/O. MAHADEORAO SURVE v. STATE OF MAHA.,...

EWS/RTE Allotment Rights Lapse After the Academic Year Absent Interim Protection; No Enforceable Right to a Particular School

Date: Mar 26, 2026

EWS/RTE Allotment Rights Lapse After the Academic Year Absent Interim Protection; No Enforceable Right to a Particular School 1. Introduction This Delhi High Court Division Bench decision in POOJA AS...

Reasoned Differentiation and Proportionality in Bank Disciplinary Penalties: Dismissal Set Aside for Reconsideration Where Parity and Retiral Consequences Were Not Addressed

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Reasoned Differentiation and Proportionality in Bank Disciplinary Penalties: Dismissal Set Aside for Reconsideration Where Parity and Retiral Consequences Were Not Addressed 1. Introduction P K VARUN...

Preventive Detention under the J&K Public Safety Act Requires Fresh, Proximate Material and Independent Application of Mind—Mechanical “Dossier-as-Grounds” Detentions are Illegal

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Preventive Detention under the J&K Public Safety Act Requires Fresh, Proximate Material and Independent Application of Mind—Mechanical “Dossier-as-Grounds” Detentions are Illegal 1. Introduction In...

Physical (Non-Electronic) Service of Section 35(3) BNSS Notice as a Precondition to the “Notice-First” Arrest Regime for ≤7-Year Offences

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Physical (Non-Electronic) Service of Section 35(3) BNSS Notice as a Precondition to the “Notice-First” Arrest Regime for ≤7-Year Offences 1. Introduction Case: MR. YUGADEV R v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA...

Publicity Interest Litigation Bar in Custodial-Death Matters Under Judicial Monitoring & Article 21 Duty to Ensure Dignified Last Rites

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Publicity Interest Litigation Bar in Custodial-Death Matters Under Judicial Monitoring & Article 21 Duty to Ensure Dignified Last Rites 1. Introduction In C.Selvakumar v. The Chief Election...

Courts Will Not Compel Universities to Issue or Validate “Post‑Review” Marksheets That Do Not Tally With the Official Database

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Courts Will Not Compel Universities to Issue or Validate “Post‑Review” Marksheets That Do Not Tally With the Official Database Case: ABHISHEK MISTRY v. THE WEST BENGAL STATE UNIVERSITY AND ORS Court:...

Preventive Detention under the J&K PSA: Referenced (but Not Relied-Upon) FIRs Need Not Be Supplied and DSB Intelligence May Be Withheld under Section 13(2)

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Preventive Detention under the J&K PSA: Referenced (but Not Relied-Upon) FIRs Need Not Be Supplied and DSB Intelligence May Be Withheld under Section 13(2) 1. Introduction This judgment of the Jammu...

Foundational Facts as a Threshold in Railway “Untoward Incident” Claims: Material Inconsistencies and Unexplained Delay Can Defeat Compensation

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Foundational Facts as a Threshold in Railway “Untoward Incident” Claims: Material Inconsistencies and Unexplained Delay Can Defeat Compensation 1. Introduction The Delhi High Court in Tulsi Das v....

Disciplinary Authority as Enquiry Officer: Inquiry Vitiated Where Authority Also Acts as Prosecutor and Denies Cross‑Examination; No Fresh Inquiry After Superannuation Without Enabling Rule

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Disciplinary Authority as Enquiry Officer: Inquiry Vitiated Where Authority Also Acts as Prosecutor and Denies Cross‑Examination; No Fresh Inquiry After Superannuation Without Enabling Rule 1)...

Marriage-Expense Narratives and Omnibus Dowry Allegations: Quashing 498A/DP Act Proceedings Against In-Laws for Want of Specific Overt Acts

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Marriage-Expense Narratives and Omnibus Dowry Allegations: Quashing 498A/DP Act Proceedings Against In-Laws for Want of Specific Overt Acts 1) Introduction In SMT SUMITHRA v. STATE OF KARNATAKA...

Amendment of Written Statement Cannot Withdraw Clear Admissions Conferring Valuable Rights

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Amendment of Written Statement Cannot Withdraw Clear Admissions Conferring Valuable Rights (Even Pre-Trial), Especially After Unexplained Delay 1. Introduction The Division Bench of the Delhi High...

Humanitarian Mandamus to Retrieve a Deported Long-Term Visa Holder to Pursue Citizenship Under Section 5(1)(d) of the Citizenship Act, 1955

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Humanitarian Mandamus to Retrieve a Deported Long-Term Visa Holder to Pursue Citizenship Under Section 5(1)(d) of the Citizenship Act, 1955 1. Introduction In Sajjad Ahmed v. Union of India th...

Post-2019 Motor Vehicles Act: Driving Licence Renewal Does Not “Relate Back” for Recruitment Cut-off Eligibility

Date: Mar 26, 2026

Post-2019 Motor Vehicles Act: Driving Licence Renewal Does Not “Relate Back” for Recruitment Cut-off Eligibility Case: DELHI POLICE & ANR. v. SUDHEER KUMAR Citation: 2026 DHC 2471-DB Court & Date:...

Prematurity Bar: Section 340 CrPC Not to Be Invoked on Mere Alleged Contradictions in Affidavits Pending Trial

Date: Mar 25, 2026

Prematurity Bar: Section 340 CrPC Not to Be Invoked on Mere Alleged Contradictions in Affidavits Pending Trial 1. Introduction This decision of the Delhi High Court (Subramonium Prasad, J.) dated...

Non-obstante/Validating Clauses Cannot Nullify Final Tax Judgments; Only Prospective Six-Year Revision Survives (KMC Act s.179(2)(d))

Date: Mar 25, 2026

Non-obstante/Validating Clauses Cannot Nullify Final Tax Judgments; Only Prospective Six-Year Revision Survives (KMC Act s.179(2)(d)) 1. Introduction In SAHUJAIN CHARITABLE SOCIETY AND ANR. v. THE...

State Duty to Independently Enquire into Katta Panchayat “Social Boycott” and Initiate Criminal Action to Protect Article 21 Rights

Date: Mar 25, 2026

State Duty to Independently Enquire into Katta Panchayat “Social Boycott” and Initiate Criminal Action to Protect Article 21 Rights 1. Introduction In P.REVATHI v. THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR (Madras High...

Mandatory Tender Documents Cannot Be Supplemented Post-Submission: “Substantial Responsiveness” and the Non-Curability of Material Omissions

Date: Mar 25, 2026

Mandatory Tender Documents Cannot Be Supplemented Post-Submission: “Substantial Responsiveness” and the Non-Curability of Material Omissions 1. Introduction In M/s Anirudh Sarswati Construction v....

Insurer Must “Pay and Recover” Even for a Gratuitous Passenger in a Goods Vehicle (Kerala HC)

Date: Mar 25, 2026

Insurer Must “Pay and Recover” Even for a Gratuitous Passenger in a Goods Vehicle Case: SHAJI v. SOMAN Citation: 2026 KER 26694 (2026:KER:26694) Court: High Court of Kerala (M.B. Snehalatha, J.)...