All High Courts Case Commentaries

Procedural Fairness Under PMLA Section 8(1): Adjudicating Authority Must Decide “Relied Upon Documents” (RUDs) Disputes Before Proceeding Further

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Procedural Fairness Under PMLA Section 8(1): Adjudicating Authority Must Decide “Relied Upon Documents” (RUDs) Disputes Before Proceeding Further Case: DIPAK DE v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS. (W.P.A. No....

Election-Surveillance Tenders: Courts Will Not Dilute Experience Eligibility (Counting-Centre CCTV & GPS Tracking) Absent Arbitrariness or Mala Fides

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Election-Surveillance Tenders: Courts Will Not Dilute Experience Eligibility (Counting-Centre CCTV & GPS Tracking) Absent Arbitrariness or Mala Fides 1) Introduction In M/s Innovatiview India Limited...

From Dowry Death (S.304-B) to Abetment of Suicide (S.306) on Evidentiary Uncertainty of Administration of Poison Despite Proof of Dowry-Cruelty

Date: Mar 20, 2026

From Dowry Death (S.304-B) to Abetment of Suicide (S.306) on Evidentiary Uncertainty of Administration of Poison Despite Proof of Dowry-Cruelty Case: VEER PAL v. STATE N.C.T. OF DELHI (Delhi High...

Injured Witness Primacy & TIP Reliability in Section 307 IPC; Sentence Leniency Denied Despite Time Lapse Where Conduct/Antecedents Adverse

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Injured Witness Primacy & TIP Reliability in Section 307 IPC; Sentence Leniency Denied Despite Time Lapse Where Conduct/Antecedents Adverse 1. Introduction Case: AJAY @ SHANTU v. STATE (NCT OF DELHI)...

MOYA Recognition as the Decisive معيار for Railways’ Scouts & Guides Recruitment Quota: WOSM Affiliation Not a Valid Exclusionary Test

Date: Mar 20, 2026

MOYA Recognition as the Decisive معيار for Railways’ Scouts & Guides Recruitment Quota: WOSM Affiliation Not a Valid Exclusionary Test Case: HINDUSTAN SCOUTS AND GUIDES ASSOCIATION THROUGH ITS...

Rash and Negligent Driving Under Sections 279/304A IPC Can Be Inferred from the Site Plan and Circumstances (Res Ipsa Loquitur), Reinforced by Section 313 Cr.P.C. Admission

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Rash and Negligent Driving Under Sections 279/304A IPC Can Be Inferred from the Site Plan and Circumstances (Res Ipsa Loquitur), Reinforced by Section 313 Cr.P.C. Admission 1. Introduction The Delhi...

Intestacy Petition Must Yield to a Propounded Will: Letters of Administration under Section 278 Not Maintainable Once Section 276 Proceedings on the Same Estate Are Filed

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Intestacy Petition Must Yield to a Propounded Will: Letters of Administration under Section 278 Not Maintainable Once Section 276 Proceedings on the Same Estate Are Filed 1) Introduction The Delhi...

Abu Sufian v. State of Tripura: Award to L2 Despite Valid L1 Bid Held Mala Fide; Cancellation and One-Year Blacklisting Directed

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Award to L2 Despite Valid L1 Bid Held Mala Fide: Out-of-State Enlistment Must Be Honoured; “Emergency” Cannot Mask Bias; Cancellation and One-Year Blacklisting as Public Law Remedies 1) Introduction...

Family pension for pre-2005 retired/deceased deficit-college employees: 2020 extension under Section 8A cures CPF-refund delay; rejection on irrelevant 2012 “option” grounds is perverse

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Family pension for pre-2005 retired/deceased deficit-college employees: 2020 extension under Section 8A cures CPF-refund delay; rejection on irrelevant 2012 “option” grounds is perverse Case: NIZARA...

Rule 139(c) Pension Cut Requires Rule 43(b)-Compliant Proof of Grave Misconduct and Whole-Service Assessment

Date: Mar 20, 2026

Rule 139(c) Pension Cut Requires Rule 43(b)-Compliant Proof of Grave Misconduct and Whole-Service Assessment 1. Introduction Case: THE STATE OF JHARKHAND v. BRAJESHWAR SINGH (L.P.A. No.102 of 2025),...

Co-owners’ Parity in Land Acquisition Compensation: Enhanced Market Value Cannot Be Denied on Technical Non-Invocation of Section 18/28-A

Date: Mar 19, 2026

Co-owners’ Parity in Land Acquisition Compensation: Enhanced Market Value Cannot Be Denied on Technical Non-Invocation of Section 18/28-A 1. Introduction The Himachal Pradesh High Court in Sohan Lal...

Section 494 IPC and Muslim Polygamy: Bigamy Requires a “Void” Second Marriage—Charge Quashable Where Muslim Personal Law Permits Second Marriage

Date: Mar 19, 2026

Section 494 IPC and Muslim Polygamy: Bigamy Requires a “Void” Second Marriage—Charge Quashable Where Muslim Personal Law Permits Second Marriage Case: Mohd. Arif Ahmad Jahagir Khan v. The State Of...

Judicial Power to Order an Independent Medical Board Re‑Examination When Medico‑Legal Evidence Is Alleged to Be Fabricated

Date: Mar 19, 2026

Judicial Power to Order an Independent Medical Board Re‑Examination When Medico‑Legal Evidence Is Alleged to Be Fabricated 1. Introduction In AJEET SINGH v. STATE OF RAJASTHAN (2026 RJ-JD 13421,...

Writ Petitioners Cannot Reframe Temple Office Claims by Withdrawing and Refiling: Constructive Res Judicata, Omitted Relief, and Limitation Bar

Date: Mar 19, 2026

Writ Petitioners Cannot Reframe Temple Office Claims by Withdrawing and Refiling: Constructive Res Judicata, Omitted Relief, and Limitation Bar Case: HARI RAM v. STATE OF HP AND ORS Citation: 2026...

Sentencing Leniency for Extraordinary Appellate Delay: Imprisonment Reduced to Period Undergone with Enhanced Fine Despite Affirmed Conviction (Section 325 IPC)

Date: Mar 19, 2026

Sentencing Leniency for Extraordinary Appellate Delay: Imprisonment Reduced to Period Undergone with Enhanced Fine Despite Affirmed Conviction (Section 325 IPC) 1. Introduction In PALAS DOLUI@TANAI...

Expedited Commitment to Sessions Court and Split-Up Procedure Where Co-Accused Are Absconding

Date: Mar 19, 2026

Expedited Commitment to Sessions Court and Split-Up Procedure Where Co-Accused Are Absconding 1. Introduction In ANIL CHANDRA BARMAN v. THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL (Calcutta High Court, Circuit Bench at...

Interim Bail in NDPS Commercial Quantity Cases on Compelling Humanitarian Medical Grounds

Date: Mar 19, 2026

Interim Bail in NDPS Commercial Quantity Cases on Compelling Humanitarian Medical Grounds (with Mandatory Surrender) 1. Introduction In MULAGAPAKA VENKATESH v. The State of Andhra Pradesh (Andhra...

Unconstitutionality of Section 497 IPC Bars Continuation of Pending Adultery Prosecutions (No Prospective Saving)

Date: Mar 17, 2026

Unconstitutionality of Section 497 IPC Bars Continuation of Pending Adultery Prosecutions (No Prospective Saving) 1. Introduction The Gujarat High Court in MANSUKHBHAI DHANJIBHAI MAKWANA v. STATE OF...

English Passed as an Additional 10+2 Subject Treated as Meeting “English Compulsory” Eligibility; Fence-Sitter and Delay Objections Limited Where Delay is Condoned and Candidate is PwD

Date: Mar 17, 2026

English Passed as an Additional 10+2 Subject Treated as Meeting “English Compulsory” Eligibility; Fence-Sitter and Delay Objections Limited Where Delay is Condoned and Candidate is PwD 1....

Exaggerated Income Claims in Section 125 Proceedings Do Not Automatically Justify Perjury Complaint: “Expedient in the Interests of Justice” as the Controlling Threshold under Section 340 CrPC / 379 BNSS

Date: Mar 14, 2026

Exaggerated Income Claims in Section 125 Proceedings Do Not Automatically Justify Perjury Complaint: “Expedient in the Interests of Justice” as the Controlling Threshold under Section 340 CrPC / 379...