state Case Commentaries

Contract Clauses that Eliminate All Judicial and Nonjudicial Review Are Void as Against Public Policy (Hochhauser v Urban Off. Architecture, PLLC)

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Contract Clauses that Eliminate All Judicial and Nonjudicial Review Are Void as Against Public Policy 1. Introduction Hochhauser v Urban Off. Architecture, PLLC (2026 NY Slip Op 04491 [2d Dept 2026])...

Municipal Bid Specifications May Require DOL-Approved Apprenticeships With Graduation-Rate Thresholds for High-Value Public Works Without Preemption

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Municipal Bid Specifications May Require DOL-Approved Apprenticeships With Graduation-Rate Thresholds for High-Value Public Works Without Preemption 1. Introduction In Matter of Peckham Rd. Corp. v....

Lusk v. McNamee: Contemporaneous Deed–Contract–Note Read as One; Extrinsic Emails Resolve Ambiguity and Prior Holdover Notice Can Satisfy Ejectment Notice-to-Quit

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Lusk v. McNamee: Contemporaneous Deed–Contract–Note Read as One; Extrinsic Emails Resolve Ambiguity and Prior Holdover Notice Can Satisfy Ejectment Notice-to-Quit Case: Lusk v McNamee, 2026 NY Slip...

Violation Petitions Must Allege Post–Order Conduct; Consent Orders of Protection Are Not Modifiable Under Family Ct Act § 844 Absent a Dispositional Hearing

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Violation Petitions Must Allege Post–Order Conduct; Consent Orders of Protection Are Not Modifiable Under Family Ct Act § 844 Absent a Dispositional Hearing Case: Matter of King v. King, 2026 NY Slip...

RPAPL 1304 Strict-Compliance Requires the Statutory Notice Language in Effect When the Foreclosure Is Commenced

Date: Jul 25, 2026

RPAPL 1304 Strict-Compliance Requires the Statutory Notice Language in Effect When the Foreclosure Is Commenced 1. Introduction Case: Bank of Am., N.A. v Thomas, 2026 NY Slip Op 04485 (App Div, 2d...

Reputation and Employability Alone Do Not Justify Pseudonymous Article 78 Litigation or Sealing Absent “Unusual” or “Compelling” Circumstances

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Reputation and Employability Alone Do Not Justify Pseudonymous Article 78 Litigation or Sealing Absent “Unusual” or “Compelling” Circumstances 1. Introduction Matter of Smith v New York State Educ....

Binding Shock Incarceration Orders Under Penal Law § 60.04(7)(a) Despite Concurrent Non-Disqualifying Non-Drug Convictions

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Binding Shock Incarceration Orders Under Penal Law § 60.04(7)(a) Despite Concurrent Non-Disqualifying Non-Drug Convictions 1. Introduction Matter of Adams v Martuscello (2026 NY Slip Op 04542) is a...

Buy/Sell “Net-Out” Oil Transactions Treated as Inventory Exchanges (Not Business Receipts) for Article 9-A BAP; Tribunal May Apply Step-Transaction to Prevent Distorted Receipts Factors

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Buy/Sell “Net-Out” Oil Transactions Treated as Inventory Exchanges (Not Business Receipts) for Article 9-A BAP; Tribunal May Apply Step-Transaction to Prevent Distorted Receipts Factors 1....

No Parcel-Specific Findings Required to Include Property in a State Historic District; Owner Objections Limit National Register Action to an Eligibility Submission

Date: Jul 25, 2026

No Parcel-Specific Findings Required to Include Property in a State Historic District; Owner Objections Limit National Register Action to an Eligibility Submission 1. Introduction Matter of Sunoco,...

Matter of Uzamere: A Relationship That Began During Representation Cannot Be “Pre‑Existing” for Later Domestic-Relations Appointments

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Matter of Uzamere: A Relationship That Began During Representation Cannot Be “Pre‑Existing” for Later Domestic-Relations Appointments 1. Introduction Matter of Uzamere (2026 NY Slip Op 04511 [App...

Agency-Consent Jurisdiction Bar in New York Agency Adoptions: No Best-Interests Hearing After Consent Is Withdrawn

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Agency-Consent Jurisdiction Bar in New York Agency Adoptions: No Best-Interests Hearing After Consent Is Withdrawn I. Introduction Matter of Aurora A. (Leigh A.--Giuseppe A.) (2026 NY Slip Op 04500)...

Pre-Answer Pleading in New York: Alter-Ego Liability and Unjust Enrichment May Proceed, While Duplicative Tort/Accounting and Unsupported Constructive Trust Claims Are Dismissed

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Pre-Answer Pleading in New York: Alter-Ego Liability and Unjust Enrichment May Proceed, While Duplicative Tort/Accounting and Unsupported Constructive Trust Claims Are Dismissed 1. Introduction In...

Nonprejudicial Motion-Paper Defects Must Not Eclipse Merits Under CPLR 2001; Alter-Ego and Unjust-Enrichment Claims Survive, but Constructive-Trust and Contract-Duplicative Claims Do Not

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Nonprejudicial Motion-Paper Defects Must Not Eclipse Merits Under CPLR 2001; Alter-Ego and Unjust-Enrichment Claims Survive, but Constructive-Trust and Contract-Duplicative Claims Do Not 1....

Utility-Owned Streetlight Evidence Is Admissible in Municipal Premises-Liability Claims; Public Duty Doctrine Does Not Categorically Bar Lighting-Based Unsafe-Intersection Theories

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Utility-Owned Streetlight Evidence Is Admissible in Municipal Premises-Liability Claims; Public Duty Doctrine Does Not Categorically Bar Lighting-Based Unsafe-Intersection Theories I. Introduction In...

Dramshop Act Contribution Requires an “Award” Imposed Against the Defendant—Settlements Do Not Qualify

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Dramshop Act Contribution Requires an “Award” Imposed Against the Defendant—Settlements Do Not Qualify Introduction In RMB v. Celotto, 2026 UT 19, the Utah Supreme Court addressed a recurring...

Tang v. State (Del. 2026) — No Per Se Duty to Activate MVR at First Suspicion; BAC Results Admissible Without Manufacturer Manual Upon Adequate Foundation

Date: Jul 24, 2026

No Per Se Duty to Activate Dash-Cam at First Suspicion; BAC Results Admissible Without Manufacturer Manual When an Adequate Foundation Is Laid Introduction Tang v. State (Del. July 23, 2026)...

Rule 40(e)(1) Nighttime-Execution Violations Do Not Trigger Automatic Suppression Absent a Constitutional Violation, Bad Faith, or Prejudice

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Rule 40(e)(1) Nighttime-Execution Violations Do Not Trigger Automatic Suppression Absent a Constitutional Violation, Bad Faith, or Prejudice Introduction In State v. Jaramillo, 2026 UT 20, the Utah...

In re J.M.: Nonjudicial Adjustment Ineligibility Is an Objective Felony Inquiry, and Prosecutors May File a Petition to Correct an Improper Diversion

Date: Jul 24, 2026

In re J.M.: Nonjudicial Adjustment Ineligibility Is an Objective Felony Inquiry, and Prosecutors May File a Petition to Correct an Improper Diversion 1. Introduction Case: In re J.M., 2026 UT 21...

County of Fulton Confined: Appellate Courts Cannot Use Fulton to Impose Trial-Level Fee Liability on Counsel Absent Trial-Court Findings

Date: Jul 24, 2026

County of Fulton Confined: Appellate Courts Cannot Use County of Fulton to Impose Trial-Level Fee Liability on Counsel Absent Trial-Court Findings 1. Introduction In Lukasik, G. v. Scotchlas, S.;...

Henson v. SCDC: No Interlocutory Appeals of Class Certification and Predominance Inherent in Rule 23(a)

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Henson v. SCDC: No Interlocutory Appeal of Class-Certification Orders; “Predominance” and a Qualitative Commonality Test Are Inherent in Rule 23(a) Court: Supreme Court of South Carolina Date: July...