state Case Commentaries

State v. Manczuk: Statute of Limitations Is Waivable (Not Jurisdictional) and Cannot Be Revived on Appeal as “Sufficiency”

Date: Jul 27, 2026

State v. Manczuk: Statute of Limitations Is Waivable (Not Jurisdictional) and Cannot Be Revived on Appeal as “Sufficiency” Court: Supreme Court of Kansas Date: July 24, 2026 Case: State v. Manczuk,...

Arizona Rule: Permanent Crops Are Valued With Agricultural Land Under § 42-13101; Agency Manual Cannot Impose Separate Market Valuation

Date: Jul 27, 2026

Arizona Rule: Permanent Crops Are Valued With Agricultural Land Under § 42-13101; Agency Manual Cannot Impose Separate Market Valuation 1. Introduction Case: A & P RANCH LTD v. COCHISE COUNTY (Ariz....

Conditional Plea Waiver in Wyoming: Ineffective Assistance Claims Require a Voluntariness Nexus; Kitzke Limited

Date: Jul 27, 2026

Conditional Plea Waiver in Wyoming: Ineffective Assistance Claims Require a Voluntariness Nexus; Kitzke Limited Introduction In Thomas Avery Glenn v. The State of Wyoming, 2026 WY 85, the Wyoming...

State v. West (Kan. 2026): Joinder Requires Multiple Commonalities; K.S.A. 60-455 Admissibility Not a Prerequisite

Date: Jul 27, 2026

State v. West (Kan. 2026): Joinder Requires Multiple Commonalities; K.S.A. 60-455 Admissibility Not a Prerequisite 1. Introduction In State v. West (Supreme Court of Kansas, July 24, 2026), Laroy M....

State v. Scott: Enumerated Jessica’s Law Mitigators Must Be Considered; Erroneous Exclusion Is Subject to Harmless-Error Review

Date: Jul 27, 2026

State v. Scott: Enumerated Jessica’s Law Mitigators Must Be Considered; Erroneous Exclusion Is Subject to Harmless-Error Review 1. Introduction In State v. Scott (Kan. 2026), the Kansas Supreme Court...

Postconviction DNA Testing Denied When Testing Cannot Yield Noncumulative, Exculpatory Evidence (Kansas K.S.A. 21-2512)

Date: Jul 27, 2026

Postconviction DNA Testing Denied When Testing Cannot Yield Noncumulative, Exculpatory Evidence (Kansas K.S.A. 21-2512) 1. Introduction In State v. Dotson (Kan. July 24, 2026), the Kansas Supreme...

People v. Cooper — Minimal Inquiry Requires a Fair Opportunity to Be Heard Before Denying Substitute Counsel

Date: Jul 27, 2026

Minimal Inquiry Requires a Fair Opportunity to Be Heard Before Denying Substitute Counsel Introduction In People v Cooper (2026 NY Slip Op 04561 [1st Dept July 23, 2026]), the Appellate Division,...

Post-Roberts J-51 Deregulations: Totality-of-Circumstances Fraud Can Be Resolved on Summary Judgment; Pre-Roberts Requires Trial Where Intent Is Disputed

Date: Jul 27, 2026

Post-Roberts J-51 Deregulations: Totality-of-Circumstances Fraud Can Be Resolved on Summary Judgment; Pre-Roberts Requires Trial Where Intent Is Disputed Case: Najera-Ordonez v. 260 Partners L.P.,...

Matter of Lemoine: Reciprocal Disbarment and “Venal Intent” for Misuse of Escrowed Client/Third-Party Funds

Date: Jul 27, 2026

Matter of Lemoine: Reciprocal Disbarment and “Venal Intent” for Misuse of Escrowed Client/Third-Party Funds Court: Appellate Division of the Supreme Court, New York, First Department (Per Curiam)...

Denemark v New Chapter Capital, Inc.: When “Litigation Funding” Becomes a Usurious Loan

Date: Jul 27, 2026

Denemark v New Chapter Capital, Inc.: Litigation Funding Is a Usurious Loan When Repayment Is Effectively Guaranteed (Security Interest, Escrow Controls, and “Trigger” Guaranties) 1. Introduction In...

Missouri Rule 74.06(b)(5): A Change in Law Alone Cannot Dissolve a Permanent Injunction; Changed Facts and Equity Must Be Proven

Date: Jul 27, 2026

Missouri Rule 74.06(b)(5): A Change in Law Alone Cannot Dissolve a Permanent Injunction; Changed Facts and Equity Must Be Proven 1. Introduction Glendale Shooting Club, Inc. v. Landolt (Mo. banc July...

Rule 60(a) Correction of Attorney-Drafted Findings That Deviate from Oral Custody Rulings; Law of the Case Bars Late Clear-Error Attacks

Date: Jul 27, 2026

Rule 60(a) Correction of Attorney-Drafted Findings That Deviate from Oral Custody Rulings; Law of the Case Bars Late Clear-Error Attacks 1. Introduction Darren M. v. Destiny D. (Alaska Supreme Court,...

Leiser v. Virginia State Bar: RPC 8.2 Is Constitutional and Reaches False/Reckless Integrity Attacks on Any Judicial Officer (Including the Judiciary as a Whole)

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Leiser v. Virginia State Bar: RPC 8.2 Is Constitutional and Reaches False/Reckless Integrity Attacks on Any Judicial Officer (Including the Judiciary as a Whole) 1. Introduction In Leiser v. Virginia...

Home Improvement Contracts: Noncompliance with GBL § 771 Not Per Se Unenforceable; Written Change-Order Clauses May Be Waived by Conduct; Owner Credits Must Offset Extra Costs

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Home Improvement Contracts: Noncompliance with GBL § 771 Not Per Se Unenforceable; Written Change-Order Clauses May Be Waived by Conduct; Owner Credits Must Offset Extra Costs 1. Introduction P.E....

Ohio Supreme Court: Civ.R. 9(B) Requires Element-Level Particularity to Plead “Manifest Mistake” to Set Aside a Binding Insurance Appraisal; “Hidden Damages” Allegation Alone Is Insufficient

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Ohio Supreme Court: Civ.R. 9(B) Requires Element-Level Particularity to Plead “Manifest Mistake” to Set Aside a Binding Insurance Appraisal; “Hidden Damages” Allegation Alone Is Insufficient 1....

Tax Regulation Challenges Are Unripe Before a Notice of Deficiency: Ripeness, Administrative Review, and Retroactivity Due Process in New York Franchise Tax Apportionment

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Tax Regulation Challenges Are Unripe Before a Notice of Deficiency: Ripeness, Administrative Review, and Retroactivity Due Process in New York Franchise Tax Apportionment 1. Introduction Matter of...

Stava v. Stava (2026): Collateral Does Not Create Marital Acquisition Under the Source of Funds Rule

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Stava v. Stava (2026): Collateral Does Not Create Marital Acquisition Under the Source of Funds Rule (and Premarital Equity Must Be Counted as a Separate Contribution) I. Introduction In Stava v....

State v. Evans (321 Neb. 841): Proving Nonenumerated “Deadly Weapon” by Injury Patterns and Treating Generalized “Safety Concerns” as Non-Acts Under § 27-404(2)

Date: Jul 25, 2026

State v. Evans (321 Neb. 841): Proving Nonenumerated “Deadly Weapon” by Injury Patterns and Treating Generalized “Safety Concerns” as Non-Acts Under § 27-404(2) I. Introduction In State v. Evans, 321...

People v. Dacosta: A Vacated Plea Extinguishes Its Appeal Waiver; Police-Controlled Buys Can Supply Probable Cause Without a Darden Hearing

Date: Jul 25, 2026

People v. Dacosta: A Vacated Plea Extinguishes Its Appeal Waiver; Police-Controlled Buys Can Supply Probable Cause Without a Darden Hearing 1. Introduction In People v Dacosta (2026 NY Slip Op 04532...

Strategic Use of Uncharged Molineux Evidence and a Narrow Molineux Instruction Can Defeat Ineffective-Assistance Claims (People v Chauhan)

Date: Jul 25, 2026

Strategic Use of Uncharged Molineux Evidence and a Narrow Molineux Instruction Can Defeat Ineffective-Assistance Claims (People v Chauhan) 1. Introduction In People v Chauhan (2026 NY Slip Op 04531...