state Case Commentaries

Graves Amendment Requires Payment: Free “Courtesy Vehicles” Are Not “Rented” and Do Not Preempt VTL § 388

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Graves Amendment Requires Payment: Free “Courtesy Vehicles” Are Not “Rented” and Do Not Preempt VTL § 388 Case: O'Hare v. Eddo, 2026 NY Slip Op 04592 (App Div, 4th Dept July 24, 2026) Court:...

Alienation-Induced Child Refusal Supports Civil Contempt for Visitation Violations (and Termination of a Parent’s Rights Requires a Cross-Petition)

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Alienation-Induced Child Refusal Supports Civil Contempt for Visitation Violations (and Termination of a Parent’s Rights Requires a Cross-Petition) 1. Introduction Matter of Brady J. S. v Darla A. B....

Discovery “Illusory COC” Claims Rejected Where Grand Jury Minutes Were Unavailable and Later Supplemented; Delay Sounds in Sanctions, Not Invalidity

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Discovery “Illusory COC” Claims Rejected Where Grand Jury Minutes Were Unavailable and Later Supplemented; Delay Sounds in Sanctions, Not Invalidity 1. Introduction People v Coleman (2026 NY Slip Op...

People v Milton: Pedigree Exception Applies to On-Scene Identification Questions Even in Custody, Absent an Objective “Disguised” Investigatory Purpose

Date: Jul 29, 2026

People v Milton: Pedigree Exception Applies to On-Scene Identification Questions Even in Custody, Absent an Objective “Disguised” Investigatory Purpose Case: People v Milton, 2026 NY Slip Op 04584...

People v. Wightman: No Jurisdictional Defect Where SCI Omits Predicate Conviction Barred by CPL 200.60; Defects in Special Information Are Waived by Guilty Plea

Date: Jul 29, 2026

People v. Wightman: No Jurisdictional Defect Where SCI Omits Predicate Conviction Barred by CPL 200.60; Defects in Special Information Are Waived by Guilty Plea Case: People v Wightman Citation: 2026...

“Furtherance” Under CPL 722.23(2)(c)(ii) Requires More Than Mere Display When the Charged Offense Is Weapon Possession

Date: Jul 29, 2026

“Furtherance” Under CPL 722.23(2)(c)(ii) Requires More Than Mere Display When the Charged Offense Is Weapon Possession 1. Introduction People v. Neyshaliz M. V. (2026 NY Slip Op 04581 [4th Dept July...

People v. Wright: Tarasoff-Style “Public Peril” Disclosures Do Not Authorize Later Trial Testimony; Physician–Patient Privilege Reattaches Once Exigency Ends

Date: Jul 29, 2026

People v. Wright: Tarasoff-Style “Public Peril” Disclosures Do Not Authorize Later Trial Testimony; Physician–Patient Privilege Reattaches Once Exigency Ends Court: Appellate Division, Fourth...

People v. Bentley: Orders of Protection Must State a CPL 530.13-Compliant Expiration Date and May Not Exceed Eight Years Beyond the Maximum Prison Term Expiration

Date: Jul 29, 2026

People v. Bentley: Orders of Protection Must State a CPL 530.13-Compliant Expiration Date and May Not Exceed Eight Years Beyond the Maximum Prison Term Expiration 1. Introduction In People v Bentley...

CPLR 213-c Extends the Limitations Period Without Creating Penal Law Civil Claims; “Physically Helpless” May Include Conscious Incapacity to Communicate Nonconsent

Date: Jul 29, 2026

CPLR 213-c Extends the Limitations Period Without Creating Penal Law Civil Claims; “Physically Helpless” May Include Conscious Incapacity to Communicate Nonconsent 1. Introduction In Gianna T. D. v...

Edwards v. Singer — Sequelae of Known Injuries Do Not Establish Mutual Mistake to Void a Broad Personal-Injury Release on a CPLR 3211(a)(5) Motion

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Edwards v. Singer — Sequelae of Known Injuries Do Not Establish Mutual Mistake to Void a Broad Personal-Injury Release on a CPLR 3211(a)(5) Motion 1. Introduction In Edwards v Singer (2026 NY Slip Op...

Summary Judgment on a Personal Guaranty Requires Proof of the Specific “Guaranteed Obligations” in a Revenue Purchase Agreement

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Summary Judgment on a Personal Guaranty Requires Proof of the Specific “Guaranteed Obligations” in a Revenue Purchase Agreement Case: EBF Holdings, LLC v Defiant Arms, L.L.C. (2026 NY Slip Op 04563,...

“Along” Is Not “Within”: Highway Law § 349-e Does Not Plainly Alienate Humboldt Parkway Parkland, and Green Amendment Claims May Proceed Based on Ongoing Expressway Operations

Date: Jul 29, 2026

“Along” Is Not “Within”: Highway Law § 349-e Does Not Plainly Alienate Humboldt Parkway Parkland, and Green Amendment Claims May Proceed Based on Ongoing Expressway Operations I. Introduction East...

Postconviction Relief Is Limited to Vacating or Setting Aside the Judgment—Not a Standalone Vehicle to Litigate the Act’s Constitutionality or Obtain an Evidentiary Hearing

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Postconviction Relief Is Limited to Vacating or Setting Aside the Judgment—Not a Standalone Vehicle to Litigate the Act’s Constitutionality or Obtain an Evidentiary Hearing I. Introduction In State...

Royce v. State Farm: Umbrella UIM Waiver Does Not Carry Forward to Later Coverage Increases Under the 1991 RSA 264:15, I

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Royce v. State Farm: Umbrella UIM Waiver Does Not Carry Forward to Later Coverage Increases Under the 1991 RSA 264:15, I Introduction In Royce v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., 2026 N.H. 28 (N.H. July...

Michigan Rejects Oregon v Kennedy Under Const 1963, art 1, § 15 and Adopts Pool v Superior Court to Bar Retrial After Prosecutorial-Misconduct Mistrials

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Michigan Rejects Oregon v Kennedy Under Const 1963, art 1, § 15 and Adopts Pool v Superior Court to Bar Retrial After Prosecutorial-Misconduct Mistrials Case: People of Michigan v. Devante Kyran...

Ordinance-Based Administrative Discretion Does Not Make a City Manager a “Public Body” Under Michigan’s Open Meetings Act

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Ordinance-Based Administrative Discretion Does Not Make a City Manager a “Public Body” Under Michigan’s Open Meetings Act I. Introduction Exclusive Capital Partners LLC v City of Royal Oak (Mich Sup...

Plea-Colloquy Admissions Control Rule 32(e): No “Fair and Just Reason” to Withdraw Guilty Plea Where Withdrawal Grounds Contradict the Record

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Plea-Colloquy Admissions Control Rule 32(e): No “Fair and Just Reason” to Withdraw Guilty Plea Where Withdrawal Grounds Contradict the Record 1. Introduction Case: State of West Virginia v. Edward...

State v. Holley: Appellate Courts Must Not Dismiss Manner-of-Service Appeals for Missing Guilty Plea Transcripts Without Case-by-Case Sufficiency Review and Party Notice

Date: Jul 28, 2026

State v. Holley: Appellate Courts Must Not Dismiss Manner-of-Service Appeals for Missing Guilty Plea Transcripts Without Case-by-Case Sufficiency Review and Party Notice 1. Introduction In State of...

Custody Orders Are Only a Starting Point for Minor-Child Domicile Under Michigan No-Fault (Overruling Grange)

Date: Jul 27, 2026

Custody Orders Are Only a Starting Point for Minor-Child Domicile Under Michigan No-Fault (Overruling Grange) Case: Frownfelter v Esurance Property & Casualty Insurance Company (Docket Nos. 168356 &...

Venue for Vulnerable-Adult Exploitation Lies Where the Property Is Located and the Transfer Takes Effect; Restitution May Include Replacement Clothing When Defendant’s Control Prevents Access

Date: Jul 27, 2026

Venue for Vulnerable-Adult Exploitation Lies Where the Property Is Located and the Transfer Takes Effect; Restitution May Include Replacement Clothing When Defendant’s Control Prevents Access 1....