state Case Commentaries

Probation Has a Fixed Expiration Date: No Judge-Made “Absconding Extension,” and Bench Warrants Do Not Toll Without Proof at Gagnon II

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Probation Has a Fixed Expiration Date: No Judge-Made “Absconding Extension,” and Bench Warrants Do Not Toll Without Proof at Gagnon II Case: Commonwealth v. Hitchner (Pa. July 21, 2026) Court:...

Juvenile Adjudications May Rebut “Peaceful and Law-Abiding” Reputation Evidence: § 6354(b)(4) Not Limited by Pa.R.E. 405(a)(2)

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Juvenile Adjudications May Rebut “Peaceful and Law-Abiding” Reputation Evidence: § 6354(b)(4) Not Limited by Pa.R.E. 405(a)(2) Commentary on Commonwealth v. Serrano-Delgado (Pa. July 21, 2026)...

Ordinary Waiver, Not “Departure” Waiver: Article I, Section 8 Challenges Must Be Raised at Suppression Under Pa.R.A.P. 302

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Ordinary Waiver, Not “Departure” Waiver: Article I, Section 8 Challenges Must Be Raised at Suppression Under Pa.R.A.P. 302 1. Introduction Commonwealth v. Shivers reached the Supreme Court of...

Coffman Is Not a Bright-Line Bar to Failure-to-Warn Claims Involving Combined Use of Two Sound Products

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Coffman Is Not a Bright-Line Bar to Failure-to-Warn Claims Involving Combined Use of Two Sound Products 1. Introduction In Sarah Elizabeth Woodruff v. Ford Motor Company (Tenn. July 21, 2026), the...

Coffman Does Not Create a Per Se Bar to Failure-to-Warn Claims Involving Combined Use of Two Sound Products

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Coffman Does Not Create a Per Se Bar to Failure-to-Warn Claims Involving Combined Use of Two Sound Products 1. Introduction In Sarah Elizabeth Woodruff ex rel. Ethan Woodruff v. Ford Motor Company...

Colt’s Neck: “Any Order” in Joint-County Ditch Proceedings Is Immediately Appealable; R.C. 6133.10(A) Requires a Multi-County Panel; Jurisdictional-Priority Errors Are Voidable and Forfeitable

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Colt’s Neck: “Any Order” in Joint-County Ditch Proceedings Is Immediately Appealable; R.C. 6133.10(A) Requires a Multi-County Panel; Jurisdictional-Priority Errors Are Voidable and Forfeitable...

State v. Barnes (2026-Ohio-2750): Marsy’s Law Victims Must Follow App.R. 4(A) and Cannot Use App.R. 5(A) Delayed Appeals Reserved to Defendants

Date: Jul 24, 2026

State v. Barnes (2026-Ohio-2750): Marsy’s Law Victims Must Follow App.R. 4(A) and Cannot Use App.R. 5(A) Delayed Appeals Reserved to Defendants I. Introduction State v. Barnes, Slip Opinion No....

Heatley v. State: Reasonable Doubt Is the Only Mandatory Standard—No “Consistency/Conclusive Guilt” Requirement in Circumstantial-Evidence Jury Charges

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Heatley v. State: Reasonable Doubt Is the Only Mandatory Standard—No “Consistency/Conclusive Guilt” Requirement in Circumstantial-Evidence Jury Charges Court: Supreme Court of South Carolina Date:...

Greenfield Cannot Supply an “Overriding Public Policy” Bar to an Insurer’s Duty to Defend in Sex-Trafficking Negligence Suits

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Greenfield Cannot Supply an “Overriding Public Policy” Bar to an Insurer’s Duty to Defend in Sex-Trafficking Negligence Suits Case: Samsung v. RI Settlement; Apl. of: RI Settlement (Concurring...

IFPA and New Jersey RICO PIP-Fraud Claims Are Not Subject to AICRA PIP Arbitration

Date: Jul 24, 2026

IFPA and New Jersey RICO PIP-Fraud Claims Are Not Subject to AICRA PIP Arbitration 1. Introduction Allstate New Jersey Insurance Company v. Carteret Comprehensive Medical Care, P.C. addresses a...

Act Petitions: No Credibility Determinations Without an Evidentiary Hearing

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Act Petitions: No Credibility Determinations Without an Evidentiary Hearing Introduction In Scott County Tyrel Lamar Patterson v. State of Minnesota (Minn. July 22, 2026), the Minnesota Supreme Court...

Bowerman v Red Oak: “Mere Inconvenience” Is Not Dispositive Under MCL 554.139(1)(a); Fitness Turns on Intended Use in Context (Including Elderly/Disabled Tenants)

Date: Jul 24, 2026

“Mere Inconvenience” Is Not Dispositive Under MCL 554.139(1)(a); Fitness Turns on Intended Use in Context (Including Elderly/Disabled Tenants) Case: Jan Bowerman v. Red Oak Management Co., Inc. and...

Termination of the General Contractor Contract Triggers Accrual Under Minn. Stat. § 541.051

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Termination of the General Contractor Contract Triggers Accrual Under Minn. Stat. § 541.051 1. Introduction In American Family Insurance Company a/s/o Nicholas Oelke v. NB Electric, Inc. dba East...

State v. Dela Cruz: A Tachibana Waiver Remains Valid Under the Totality of the Circumstances Even Without the Exact “Is Anyone Forcing You Not to Testify?” Question

Date: Jul 24, 2026

State v. Dela Cruz: A Tachibana Waiver Remains Valid Under the Totality of the Circumstances Even Without the Exact “Is Anyone Forcing You Not to Testify?” Question I. Introduction In State v. Dela...

Counties May Streamline SMA Permitting, Not Eliminate the Non‑Delegable CZMA “Assessment” (Final EA Required; No Categorical Self‑Certification Exemptions)

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Counties May Streamline SMA Permitting, Not Eliminate the Non‑Delegable CZMA “Assessment” (Final EA Required; No Categorical Self‑Certification Exemptions) I. Introduction In Maui Tomorrow Foundation...

Compelling Circumstances Permit Separation-Date Valuation of Marital Equity Awards; Unvested Stock/RSUs May Be Treated as Post-Separation Compensation

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Compelling Circumstances Permit Separation-Date Valuation of Marital Equity Awards; Unvested Stock/RSUs May Be Treated as Post-Separation Compensation Introduction In Patrick M. Hogan v. Amanda H....

People v Wilkins: Automobile-Exception Probable Cause Must Target Evidence of a Crime, Not a Civil Infraction

Date: Jul 24, 2026

People v Wilkins: Automobile-Exception Probable Cause Must Target Evidence of a Crime, Not a Civil Infraction Introduction In People of Michigan v. Freddie Wilkins, III (Mich Sup Ct, July 22, 2026),...

Michigan SORA “Recapture” Registration for Nonsexual Felonies Is Cruel or Unusual Punishment (As Applied)

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Michigan SORA “Recapture” Registration for Nonsexual Felonies Is Cruel or Unusual Punishment (As Applied) I. Introduction People v Ellis (Mich. Sup. Ct., July 22, 2026) addresses the...

Revocable-at-Death Trust Liability to Creditors and EPIC Exemptions for 401(k) Payments and Life-Insurance Proceeds Paid to a Trustee

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Revocable-at-Death Trust Liability to Creditors and EPIC Exemptions for 401(k) Payments and Life-Insurance Proceeds Paid to a Trustee 1. Introduction Case: In re FOWLER ESTATE / In re FOWLER TRUST...

Specific-Unanimity Required for Single-Count, Multi-Act Proof of Penetration; Rucker Overruled

Date: Jul 24, 2026

Specific-Unanimity Required for Single-Count, Multi-Act Proof of Penetration; State v. Rucker Overruled 1. Introduction In State of Minnesota v. Ge Yang (Minn. July 22, 2026), the Minnesota Supreme...