state Case Commentaries

Statutory Damages for Wrongful Denial of Prison Video Records Despite Later Overwrite; Work Contact Information May Not Be Redacted Absent a Statutory Exemption

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Statutory Damages for Wrongful Denial of Prison Video Records Despite Later Overwrite; Work Contact Information May Not Be Redacted Absent a Statutory Exemption I. Introduction Case: State ex rel....

Conditional Treatment Recommendations Render First-Time Methamphetamine Sentences Illegal Under 9 GCA § 67.401.12

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Conditional Treatment Recommendations Render First-Time Methamphetamine Sentences Illegal Under 9 GCA § 67.401.12 Case: People of Guam v. Colleen Sherise Castillon Yurko, 2026 Guam 9 (Supreme Court...

State v. Laroque (2026 MT 209) Commentary

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Implied-Consent Blood Draws in Montana Require Record Evidence of Understanding and Voluntary Consent; Good-Faith Reliance Must Be Preserved Below Case: State v. Laroque, 2026 MT 209 (DA 25-0465)...

Probation-Revocation Sentencing: No Separate On-the-Record Justification Required to Impose the Statutory Maximum Under 9 GCA § 80.66(b)

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Probation-Revocation Sentencing: No Separate On-the-Record Justification Required to Impose the Statutory Maximum Under 9 GCA § 80.66(b) I. Introduction In People of Guam v. Michael John Toves...

Owner-Occupied “Guest” Restrictions Upheld: “Guest” Means Invitee, Not Tenant, and Falls Within RSA 674:16 General Welfare Zoning Authority

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Owner-Occupied “Guest” Restrictions Upheld: “Guest” Means Invitee, Not Tenant, and Falls Within RSA 674:16 General Welfare Zoning Authority Introduction In Christopher Andrews & a. v. Kearsarge...

Harmless-Error Review for Limited 404(b) and CAC-Interview Evidence, Unaffected by Jury Impasse — State v. Giroux (N.H. 2026)

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Harmless-Error Review for Limited 404(b) and CAC-Interview Evidence, Unaffected by Jury Impasse — State v. Giroux (N.H. 2026) 1. Introduction In State of New Hampshire v. Max Giroux (No. 2024-0505),...

Due Process Timing for Challenging a Temporary Guardian’s Out-of-State Placement

Date: Sep 3, 2026

Due Process Timing for Challenging a Temporary Guardian’s Out-of-State Placement (Review Satisfied by a Full Contested Hearing Before Temporary Order Expiration) 1. Introduction Matter of K.D.G....

State v. J.A. Miller: Uniformed Officer Spectators Are Not Inherently Prejudicial; Unrequested Jury Polling Is Unpreserved; Graphic Photo Error May Be Harmless Under Cumulative Evidence

Date: Sep 3, 2026

State v. J.A. Miller: Uniformed Officer Spectators Are Not Inherently Prejudicial; Unrequested Jury Polling Is Unpreserved; Graphic Photo Error May Be Harmless Under Cumulative Evidence 1....

Quasi-Judicial Immunity Is Personal-Only; Rule 32 “Other Copying” Fees Must Conform to I.C. § 74-102(10)

Date: Sep 2, 2026

Quasi-Judicial Immunity Is Personal-Only; Rule 32 “Other Copying” Fees Must Conform to I.C. § 74-102(10) Introduction In BRYAN D. SMITH v. CHRIS POULTER IN HIS CAPACITY AS BONNEVILLE COUNTY CLERK,...

HRS § 12-8 as the Exclusive Pre‑Election Vehicle for Candidate-Eligibility Disputes; “Elected To” Term Limits Count Fixed Charter Terms Despite Delayed Swearing-In

Date: Sep 2, 2026

HRS § 12-8 as the Exclusive Pre‑Election Vehicle for Candidate-Eligibility Disputes; “Elected To” Term Limits Count Fixed Charter Terms Despite Delayed Swearing-In 1. Introduction Iwasa v. Nago...

“Adequate Remedy” Limits Interlocutory Judicial Review Under Tenn. Code Ann. § 4-5-322(a)(1); Judicial Economy Is Not a Jurisdictional Factor

Date: Sep 2, 2026

“Adequate Remedy” Limits Interlocutory Judicial Review Under Tenn. Code Ann. § 4-5-322(a)(1); Judicial Economy Is Not a Jurisdictional Factor I. Introduction Jamesway Construction, Inc. v. David W....

Disbelief Alone Cannot Prove Lack of Authorization in Tennessee Forgery Sufficiency Review

Date: Sep 1, 2026

Disbelief Alone Cannot Prove Lack of Authorization in Tennessee Forgery Sufficiency Review Case: State of Tennessee v. Ginny Elizabeth Parker (Dissenting) Court: Supreme Court of Tennessee Date:...

NRS 175.151: Two-Counsel Jury Argument Is Required Only When the State Seeks the Death Penalty

Date: Sep 1, 2026

NRS 175.151: Two-Counsel Jury Argument Is Required Only When the State Seeks the Death Penalty Case: RANDOLPH (THOMAS) v. STATE (CRIMINAL) (Nev. Sup. Ct. No. 88625) Date: 2026-08-31 Disposition:...

State v. Parker: Corroborated False Exculpatory Statements as Affirmative Proof of Non-Authorization in Forgery

Date: Sep 1, 2026

Corroborated False Exculpatory Statements as Affirmative Proof of Non-Authorization in Tennessee Forgery Sufficiency Review Case: State of Tennessee v. Ginny Elizabeth Parker (Tenn. Aug. 31, 2026)...

Kortmeyer v. Hendrix (322 Neb. 102)

Date: Aug 31, 2026

Routine Yard Maintenance Does Not Establish “Notorious” Possession, and Renting the Record Lot Makes Use Permissive—Defeating Nebraska Adverse Possession Introduction In Kortmeyer v. Hendrix, 322...

Pure Self-Defense Only Negates Criminal-Discharge Predicate Felony Murder; “Light Most Favorable” Applies Even to Unrequested Instructions

Date: Aug 31, 2026

Pure Self-Defense Only Negates Criminal-Discharge Predicate Felony Murder; “Light Most Favorable” Applies Even to Unrequested Instructions Introduction State v. Banks is a direct appeal from Sedgwick...

Alaska Supreme Court Upholds DNR Rule Requiring Rent on Expired Leases During Appeals

Date: Aug 31, 2026

New Rule Confirmed: DNR May Require Annual Rent on Expired Oil & Gas Leases During Pending Unitization Applications/Appeals, and Nonpayment Validly Terminates Leases—Rendering Related Unitization...

State v. Cavitt: Kidnapping “Facilitation” Returns to the Statute—State v. Buggs Overruled

Date: Aug 31, 2026

State v. Cavitt: Kidnapping “Facilitation” Returns to the Statute—State v. Buggs Overruled Introduction In State v. Cavitt (Kan. Aug. 28, 2026), the Kansas Supreme Court affirmed Shannon Berry Cavitt...

Successive K.S.A. 21-2512 DNA Petitions: “At Any Time” Means Not Barred by Res Judicata When New Grounds Are Raised, but Retesting Requires Specific “New Technique” Pleading and Testing Still Must Be Potentially Exculpatory

Date: Aug 31, 2026

Successive K.S.A. 21-2512 DNA Petitions: “At Any Time” Means Not Barred by Res Judicata When New Grounds Are Raised, but Retesting Requires Specific “New Technique” Pleading and Testing Still Must Be...

Clerical Misstatement on DMV Medical Review Form by Treating Physician Sounds in Ordinary Negligence (3-Year Limitations Period), Not Medical Malpractice

Date: Aug 31, 2026

Clerical Misstatement on DMV Medical Review Form by Treating Physician Sounds in Ordinary Negligence (3-Year Limitations Period), Not Medical Malpractice I. Introduction Case: Lafferty v Avila, 2026...