state Case Commentaries

No-Action Clause Voting Rights Turn on Outstanding Certificate Principal Balance—Physical Possession of “Worthless” RMBS Certificates Does Not Confer Standing

Date: Aug 31, 2026

No-Action Clause Voting Rights Turn on Outstanding Certificate Principal Balance—Physical Possession of “Worthless” RMBS Certificates Does Not Confer Standing 1. Introduction In Matter of HBK Master...

People v. Hazlett: The California Racial Justice Act Does Not Reach Peremptory Challenges (and Race-Inflected Trial Themes Require Prejudicial Effect for Relief)

Date: Aug 31, 2026

People v. Hazlett: The California Racial Justice Act Does Not Reach Peremptory Challenges (and Race-Inflected Trial Themes Require Prejudicial Effect for Relief) Supreme Court of California — August...

Matter of Chen: Federal Felony Convictions Without “Essential Similarity” Do Not Trigger Automatic Disbarment on a Thin Record, But Still Support Disbarment as “Serious Crimes”

Date: Aug 31, 2026

Matter of Chen: Federal Felony Convictions Without “Essential Similarity” Do Not Trigger Automatic Disbarment on a Thin Record, But Still Support Disbarment as “Serious Crimes” Introduction Matter of...

Matter of Debbra L. v Jenna L. — One Misstep Cannot Justify Wholesale Denial of Grandparent Visitation; Individualized Best-Interests Review Required

Date: Aug 31, 2026

One Misstep Cannot Justify Wholesale Denial of Grandparent Visitation; Individualized Best-Interests Review Required 1. Introduction Matter of Debbra L. v Jenna L. (2026 NY Slip Op 05135, 3d Dept...

People v. Guilbault: Typographical Errors in Indictment Waivers and Nonessential Omissions Do Not Create SCI Jurisdictional Defects; Plea Stands Where the Bargained-For Maximum Exposure Is Preserved

Date: Aug 31, 2026

People v. Guilbault: Typographical Errors in Indictment Waivers and Nonessential Omissions Do Not Create SCI Jurisdictional Defects; Plea Stands Where the Bargained-For Maximum Exposure Is Preserved...

Smith v. State: Superior Court’s Near-Complete Discretion to Depart from Nonbinding SENTAC Guidelines (Aggravators Are Nonexclusive)

Date: Aug 31, 2026

Smith v. State: Superior Court’s Near-Complete Discretion to Depart from Nonbinding SENTAC Guidelines (Aggravators Are Nonexclusive) 1. Introduction In Smith v. State (Del. Aug. 27, 2026), the...

Florida Appellate Rule Amendments Establish “Petition-Only” Service on Order-Issuing Officials Unless They Elect Further Service

Date: Aug 31, 2026

Florida Appellate Rule Amendments Establish “Petition-Only” Service on Order-Issuing Officials Unless They Elect Further Service 1. Introduction In In Re: Amendments to Florida Rules of Appellate...

Deliberate Design May Be Inferred from Repeated Shooting and Reloading; Invited-Error Bar for Omitted Lesser-Included Homicide Instruction

Date: Aug 31, 2026

Deliberate Design May Be Inferred from Repeated Shooting and Reloading; Invited-Error Bar for Omitted Lesser-Included Homicide Instruction 1. Introduction In White v. State of Mississippi (Miss. Aug....

Bush v. Marion General Hospital — COVID-19 Emergency Immunity Requires a Proven Causal Nexus to the Alleged Negligent Act or Omission

Date: Aug 31, 2026

COVID-19 Emergency Immunity Requires a Proven Causal Nexus to the Alleged Negligent Act or Omission Case: Bush v. Marion General Hospital (Supreme Court of Mississippi, Aug. 27, 2026) | Disposition:...

Presuming Understanding of “Guilty” Under Crim.R. 11: Omission of “Complete Admission” Is Not a Complete Failure Absent Actual Innocence (State v. Fontanez)

Date: Aug 29, 2026

Presuming Understanding of “Guilty” Under Crim.R. 11: Omission of “Complete Admission” Is Not a Complete Failure Absent Actual Innocence (State v. Fontanez) Case: State v. Fontanez, Slip Opinion No....

Legislative Repeal Moots Mandamus Appeal and Warrants Vacatur Where Mootness Is Not Appellant-Caused

Date: Aug 29, 2026

Legislative Repeal Moots Mandamus Appeal and Warrants Vacatur Where Mootness Is Not Appellant-Caused Case: Aldin Associates Ltd. Partnership v. State (Order on Motion) Court: Supreme Court of...

Law-of-the-Case Precludes Renewed “Letter of No Objection” Demands; Purchaser Default at a Time-of-the-Essence Closing Defeats Specific Performance and CPLR 5107 Relief

Date: Aug 29, 2026

Law-of-the-Case Precludes Renewed “Letter of No Objection” Demands; Purchaser Default at a Time-of-the-Essence Closing Defeats Specific Performance and CPLR 5107 Relief 1. Introduction Chao-Yu C....

Amendments Cure Alleged One-Subject Defects: Later Reenactments Supersede Earlier Budget-Bill Enactments

Date: Aug 29, 2026

Amendments Cure Alleged One-Subject Defects: Later Reenactments Supersede Earlier Budget-Bill Enactments Case: Allied Health & Chiropractic, L.L.C. v. State | Citation: 2026-Ohio-3308 | Court:...

Unobjected-to Magistrate Decisions in Inmate Writ Cases: Waiver to Plain-Error Review and Mandatory Dismissal for R.C. 2969.25(A) Noncompliance

Date: Aug 29, 2026

Unobjected-to Magistrate Decisions in Inmate Writ Cases: Waiver to Plain-Error Review and Mandatory Dismissal for R.C. 2969.25(A) Noncompliance 1. Introduction In State ex rel. Wright v. Franklin...

Reinstatement Recommendations Must Contain Actual Findings and Reasoned Analysis Under I.B.C.R. 518(b)(4)(C): In the Matter of Webb

Date: Aug 29, 2026

Reinstatement Recommendations Must Contain Actual Findings and Reasoned Analysis Under I.B.C.R. 518(b)(4)(C): In the Matter of Webb 1. Introduction In In the Matter of Brian L. Webb (Idaho Sup. Ct....

State v. Amasiu: Statute of Limitations “Commencement” for Information Charging Occurs Upon a Probable-Cause Finding

Date: Aug 29, 2026

State v. Amasiu: Statute of Limitations “Commencement” for Information Charging Occurs Upon a Probable-Cause Finding Supreme Court of Hawaiʻi (Aug. 26, 2026) — SCWC-21-0000556 I. Introduction State...

Act 250 Jurisdiction Persists After Sustained Unpermitted Expansion Despite Later “Decoupling”; Stop-Work Orders Upheld When Economic Effects Are Considered

Date: Aug 29, 2026

Act 250 Jurisdiction Persists After Sustained Unpermitted Expansion Despite Later “Decoupling”; Stop-Work Orders Upheld When Economic Effects Are Considered 1. Introduction In Land Use Review Board...

Probation-Violation Detention in Vermont: Presumption of Incarceration and No Right to “Try” a Release Plan Under 28 V.S.A. § 301(4)

Date: Aug 29, 2026

Probation-Violation Detention in Vermont: Presumption of Incarceration and No Right to “Try” a Release Plan Under 28 V.S.A. § 301(4) 1. Introduction State v. Tyrin Smith (Vt. Sup. Ct. Aug. 28, 2026)...

Threatened Foreclosure and Substantial Asset Diversion Establish “Irreparable Injury” and “Gross Mismanagement” for NRS 78.650 Receivership; Interested Shareholder May Serve as Receiver Under NRS 78.650(4)

Date: Aug 29, 2026

Threatened Foreclosure and Substantial Asset Diversion Establish “Irreparable Injury” and “Gross Mismanagement” for NRS 78.650 Receivership; Interested Shareholder May Serve as Receiver Under NRS...

Bankruptcy Standing Determination Issue-Precludes Later Nevada Quiet-Title Challenges to Foreclosure Authority

Date: Aug 29, 2026

Bankruptcy Standing Determination Issue-Precludes Later Nevada Quiet-Title Challenges to Foreclosure Authority 1. Introduction Lee v. The Bank of New York Mellon (Nev. Aug. 28, 2026) arises from a...