state Case Commentaries

State v. Maas (Mont. 2026): Ongoing-Emergency Confrontation Rule for Post-Shooting Hospital Statements; Remoteness Limits on Juvenile Character Rebuttal

Date: Sep 18, 2026

State v. Maas (Mont. 2026): Ongoing-Emergency Confrontation Rule for Post-Shooting Hospital Statements; Remoteness Limits on Juvenile Character Rebuttal 1. Introduction In State v. Maas, the Supreme...

Certified Conflict Accepted on Whether the Pre‑Amendment Home Construction Service Suppliers Act Covers Repairs and Renovations

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Certified Conflict Accepted on Whether the Pre‑Amendment Home Construction Service Suppliers Act Covers Repairs and Renovations Introduction 09/16/2026 Case Announcements, 2026-Ohio-3595 is the...

Ohio Sales-Tax Refund Appeals: BTA Must Make Clear ADP/True-Object Findings and Separately Evaluate Invoiced Ancillary Services

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Ohio Sales-Tax Refund Appeals: BTA Must Make Clear ADP/True-Object Findings and Separately Evaluate Invoiced Ancillary Services Case: CheckFree Servs. Corp. v. Harris, Slip Opinion No. 2026-Ohio-3555...

Unavailability Under Minn. R. Evid. 804(a)(5) Requires Use of Compulsory Process Before Admitting a Co-Defendant’s Statement Against Interest

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Unavailability Under Minn. R. Evid. 804(a)(5) Requires Use of Compulsory Process Before Admitting a Co-Defendant’s Statement Against Interest I. Introduction In State of Minnesota v. Derrick Lamon...

“Good Cause” in Montana Protective-Order Hearings Requires Proof by a Preponderance of Substantial, Credible Evidence

Date: Sep 18, 2026

“Good Cause” in Montana Protective-Order Hearings Requires Proof by a Preponderance of Substantial, Credible Evidence 1. Introduction In A. Nelson v. S. Frisk, 2026 MT 220, the Supreme Court of...

Removal by Participation: Dissolution Courts May Assume and Permanently Resolve Protection-Order Proceedings Under § 40-15-301(3), MCA

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Removal by Participation: Dissolution Courts May Assume and Permanently Resolve Protection-Order Proceedings Under § 40-15-301(3), MCA Case: Marriage of Cordeiro (Mont. 2026 MT 219) Court: Supreme...

Fraud-Based Rescission for Misrepresented Lease Term & Waiver of Affirmative Defenses Not Raised at Bench Trial (Shepard v. Bickham)

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Fraud-Based Rescission for Misrepresented Lease Term & Waiver of Affirmative Defenses Not Raised at Bench Trial (Shepard v. Bickham, 2026 MT 221N) Nonprecedential status. The Court designated this...

Jury Determinations Required for Unjust Enrichment “Rent,” Pritchard Setoff, and Reasonable Rental Value on Remand (Taylor v. Taylor)

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Jury Determinations Required for Unjust Enrichment “Rent,” Pritchard Setoff, and Reasonable Rental Value on Remand (Taylor v. Taylor) Introduction Case: Taylor v. Taylor, 2026 MT 223N (Mont. Sept....

Withdrawal of Deemed Admissions Required When Merits Are Subserved and No Prejudice Exists—Especially Where New Counsel Lacked Notice

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Withdrawal of Deemed Admissions Required When Merits Are Subserved and No Prejudice Exists—Especially Where New Counsel Lacked Notice Introduction In THOMAS & GOZA v. LIBERTY MUTUAL INSURANCE...

Municipal Authority to Choose Paper or Electronic Polling Place Rosters for Any Election Under Minn. Stat. § 201.225

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Municipal Authority to Choose Paper or Electronic Polling Place Rosters for Any Election Under Minn. Stat. § 201.225 1. Introduction In City of Oak Grove v. Steve Simon, in his official capacity as...

Reciprocal Discipline in Oklahoma: Suspension Timing Tied to RGDP Rule 9.1 Affidavit and Denial of Hearing Absent Disputed Facts

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Reciprocal Discipline in Oklahoma: Suspension Timing Tied to RGDP Rule 9.1 Affidavit and Denial of Hearing Absent Disputed Facts Case: STATE OF OKLAHOMA, ex rel. OKLAHOMA BAR ASSOCIATION v. COBB,...

Post-Zarella: Essential-Need and Procedural Protections as Preconditions to Appellate Review of Privately Held Privileged Records

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Post-Zarella: Essential-Need and Procedural Protections as Preconditions to Appellate Review of Privately Held Privileged Records I. Introduction In State of New Hampshire v. Tailor Lemieux (N.H....

State v. Fomo: Abstract “Grooming” Definitions by Police Experts—Harmless Error Without Case-Specific Application; No Plain-Error Reversal Absent Manifest Injustice

Date: Sep 17, 2026

State v. Fomo: Abstract “Grooming” Definitions by Police Experts—Harmless Error Without Case-Specific Application; No Plain-Error Reversal Absent Manifest Injustice Court: Supreme Court of...

Late-Disclosed “Grooming” Expert Testimony and Hybrid Police Witnesses: Abuse of Discretion Absent Good Cause and Safeguards (State v. Fomo)

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Late-Disclosed “Grooming” Expert Testimony and Hybrid Police Witnesses: Abuse of Discretion Absent Good Cause and Safeguards (State v. Fomo) Case: State v. Fomo (Concurrence) Court: Supreme Court of...

Ohio Supreme Court Case Announcements (2026-Ohio-3554): Procedural Gatekeeping Through Sua Sponte Dismissals, Delayed-Appeal Screening, and “Held for Decision” Orders

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Ohio Supreme Court Case Announcements (2026-Ohio-3554): Procedural Gatekeeping Through Sua Sponte Dismissals, Delayed-Appeal Screening, and “Held for Decision” Orders Citation: 09/15/2026 Case...

R.C. Chapter 2506 Appeals Do Not Trigger Claim-Preclusion of Later Damages/Declaratory Actions When Those Remedies Were Procedurally Unavailable

Date: Sep 17, 2026

R.C. Chapter 2506 Appeals Do Not Trigger Claim-Preclusion of Later Damages/Declaratory Actions When Those Remedies Were Procedurally Unavailable I. Introduction In Sheetz, Inc. v. Centerville, Slip...

Sanchez v. People: Colorado Upholds COLJI-Crim. E:03 (2022) “Firmly Convinced/Real Possibility” Reasonable-Doubt Instruction

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Sanchez v. People: Colorado Upholds COLJI-Crim. E:03 (2022) “Firmly Convinced/Real Possibility” Reasonable-Doubt Instruction 1. Introduction In Sanchez v. People, 2026 CO 60, the Colorado Supreme...

Amended Pleadings Do Not Revive a Waived Civil Jury Right Absent New Triable Issues (C.R.C.P. 38)

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Amended Pleadings Do Not Revive a Waived Civil Jury Right Absent New Triable Issues (C.R.C.P. 38) Introduction In In re SCP 3330 Brighton OPCO, LLC, the Colorado Supreme Court (original proceeding...

Dependency-and-Neglect Dismissal Is Appealable When It Locks In an Adverse Temporary Placement

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Dependency-and-Neglect Dismissal Is Appealable When It Locks In an Adverse Temporary Placement I. Introduction In T.L.P. v. People, 2026 CO 61, the Colorado Supreme Court addressed a recurring...

People v. Sloan (2026 CO 63): Instructional Errors on Uncontested Issues Do Not Satisfy Plain-Error “Substantial Rights” Review

Date: Sep 16, 2026

People v. Sloan (2026 CO 63): Instructional Errors on Uncontested Issues Do Not Satisfy Plain-Error “Substantial Rights” Review I. Introduction In People v. Sloan, 2026 CO 63, the Colorado Supreme...