state Case Commentaries

Referee “Hear-and-Determine” Decisions as Court Mandates Enforceable by Civil Contempt in Matrimonial Equitable Distribution

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Referee “Hear-and-Determine” Decisions as Court Mandates Enforceable by Civil Contempt in Matrimonial Equitable Distribution Case: Brandford v Brandford, 2026 NY Slip Op 05270 (App Div, 2d Dept Sept....

Contractors Cannot Sue for Damages Under General Municipal Law § 101(5); Conclusory Third-Party Beneficiary and Unjust Enrichment Pleadings Fail at CPLR 3211(a)(7)

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Contractors Cannot Sue for Damages Under General Municipal Law § 101(5); Conclusory Third-Party Beneficiary and Unjust Enrichment Pleadings Fail at CPLR 3211(a)(7) 1. Introduction In Civetta Mech.,...

Leave-to-Amend Orders Have No Preclusive Effect on RGB Rent-Increase Entitlement; Minimum-Dollar RGB Increases Must Be Preserved in the Renewal Lease

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Leave-to-Amend Orders Have No Preclusive Effect on RGB Rent-Increase Entitlement; Minimum-Dollar RGB Increases Must Be Preserved in the Renewal Lease Introduction Case: Matter of Hillside Place, LLC...

Conclusive Security Claims Do Not Justify Blanket FOIL Withholding: Mandatory In Camera Review for Cybersecurity Contracts and Executive Calendars

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Conclusive Security Claims Do Not Justify Blanket FOIL Withholding: Mandatory In Camera Review for Cybersecurity Contracts and Executive Calendars 1. Introduction Case: Matter of Newsday, LLC v....

Legislative Cutbacks to Earned-Time Credits Are Not Subject to Procedural Due Process; Victim-Expectation Carveouts Survive Common Benefits Review

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Legislative Cutbacks to Earned-Time Credits Are Not Subject to Procedural Due Process; Victim-Expectation Carveouts Survive Common Benefits Review I. Introduction In Chavis Murphy v. Nicholas Deml...

FAPA Renewal Rule: Voluntary Discontinuance Does Not De-Accelerate or Reset the Mortgage Foreclosure Limitations Period

Date: Sep 18, 2026

FAPA Renewal Rule: Voluntary Discontinuance Does Not De-Accelerate or Reset the Mortgage Foreclosure Limitations Period 1. Introduction Bank of N.Y. Mellon v Conforti (2026 NY Slip Op 05262 [2d Dept...

Bellavia v. Hoppenstein: Nonconforming CPLR 2106 Party Affirmations Cannot Supply Facts on CPLR 3211 Motions (but Legal Argument May Still Be Considered)

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Bellavia v. Hoppenstein: Nonconforming CPLR 2106 Party Affirmations Cannot Supply Facts on CPLR 3211 Motions (but Legal Argument May Still Be Considered) Case: Bellavia v Hoppenstein, 2026 NY Slip Op...

Clarke v. Spino — Documentary-Evidence Dismissal and Down-Payment Forfeiture in a Short-Sale, Time-of-the-Essence Closing

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Documentary Evidence Can Defeat Short-Sale “Condition Precedent” Theories at the Pleading Stage, Enforcing Time-of-the-Essence Default and Down-Payment Forfeiture 1. Introduction Clarke v Spino (2026...

Foley v. Foley: Civil Contempt May Enforce an Unpaid Matrimonial Distributive Award Where Execution Is Not Legally Available; Issues Are Forfeited After an Abandoned Cross-Appeal

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Foley v. Foley: Civil Contempt May Enforce an Unpaid Matrimonial Distributive Award Where Execution Is Not Legally Available; Issues Are Forfeited After an Abandoned Cross-Appeal 1. Introduction In...

Policyholder Entitlement to MLMIC Demutualization Proceeds Absent Assignment or Contractual Transfer

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Policyholder Entitlement to MLMIC Demutualization Proceeds Absent Assignment or Contractual Transfer 1. Introduction Joseph Onorato, M.D., P.C. v Bruck (Appellate Division, Second Department, Sept....

King v. Kohn (2d Dep’t 2026): No Notice of Pendency Where Pleading Seeks Only Damages; Former DCL § 276 Unavailable for Post–April 4, 2020 Conduct

Date: Sep 18, 2026

King v. Kohn (2d Dep’t 2026): No Notice of Pendency Where Pleading Seeks Only Damages; Former DCL § 276 Unavailable for Post–April 4, 2020 Conduct 1. Introduction In King v Kohn (2026 NY Slip Op...

Levine v Stellar 341, LLC — Pleading Adverse Possession and Practical Location Pre-2008; Limits of “Documentary Evidence” on CPLR 3211(a)(1)

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Levine v Stellar 341, LLC — Pleading Adverse Possession and Practical Location Under Pre-2008 RPAPL; What Counts (and Doesn’t) as “Documentary Evidence” on CPLR 3211(a)(1) 1. Introduction Levine v...

Co-Signatory Not Liable Where Contract Unambiguously Assigns Payment to Another; Indefinite Construction-Management Agreements Unenforceable; Quantum Meruit Requires Proof of Reasonable Value

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Co-Signatory Not Liable Where Contract Unambiguously Assigns Payment to Another; Indefinite Construction-Management Agreements Unenforceable; Quantum Meruit Requires Proof of Reasonable Value...

Visually Indistinct “Two-Surface” Floor Installations and Slip-Resistance Failures Create Triable Negligence Issues for Both Contractors and Premises Operators

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Visually Indistinct “Two-Surface” Floor Installations and Slip-Resistance Failures Create Triable Negligence Issues for Both Contractors and Premises Operators 1. Introduction Macri v Fluor Enters.,...

Subsequently Discovered Evidence Defeats Res Judicata After an Article 78 Proceeding, but Fraud and Prospective Business-Interference Claims Still Demand Particularized Pleading

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Subsequently Discovered Evidence Defeats Res Judicata After an Article 78 Proceeding, but Fraud and Prospective Business-Interference Claims Still Demand Particularized Pleading 1. Introduction In...

Zeltser v. Kukolev: Statute of Frauds Bars Oral Real-Property Ownership Claims, but Unjust Enrichment Restitution May Proceed

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Statute of Frauds Bars Oral Real-Property Ownership Claims, but Unjust Enrichment Restitution May Proceed (Zeltser v. Kukolev) 1. Introduction In Zeltser v Kukolev (2026 NY Slip Op 05353), the...

Declaratory Judgment Available for Untimely LUCT Assessments Raising Pure Questions of Statutory Authority (Despite Missed RSA 79-A:10 Appeal Deadline)

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Declaratory Judgment Available for Untimely LUCT Assessments Raising Pure Questions of Statutory Authority (Despite Missed RSA 79-A:10 Appeal Deadline) Case: McMaster Development, LLC v. Town of...

Rule 60 Is Not a Second Appeal; Parenting-Plan Amendments Require Statutory Threshold Showings and a Proper Record (In re Marriage of Scobee and White)

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Rule 60 Is Not a Second Appeal; Parenting-Plan Amendments Require Statutory Threshold Showings and a Proper Record Case: In re the Marriage of: Scobee and White, 2026 MT 222N (Mont. Sept. 15, 2026)...

Shelstad v. Pacific Life Insurance Company — Economic Loss Rule Bars Negligence Claims Against Insurers for Third‑Party Investment Losses Absent a Recognized “Special Relationship”; Apparent Authority Cannot Extend Beyond the Principal’s Manifestations and Express Disclaimers

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Economic Loss Rule Bars Negligence Claims Against Insurers for Third‑Party Investment Losses Absent a Recognized “Special Relationship”; Apparent Authority Cannot Extend Beyond the Principal’s...

Engellant v. Crowley Fleck (Mont. 2026): Validity of a Later Will as a “Negative Defense” Defeating Causation/Damages in Estate-Planning Malpractice

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Engellant v. Crowley Fleck (Mont. 2026): Validity of a Later Will as a “Negative Defense” Defeating Causation/Damages in Estate-Planning Malpractice 1. Introduction Case: Engellant v. Crowley Fleck,...