state Case Commentaries

Waiver by Conduct of a Parent’s Statutory and Due-Process Right to Appointed Counsel in South Dakota Termination Proceedings

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Waiver by Conduct of a Parent’s Statutory and Due-Process Right to Appointed Counsel in South Dakota Termination Proceedings Introduction Interest of P.R.M., 2026 S.D. 47, is a South Dakota Supreme...

Spoliation of Surveillance Video: Adverse Inference (Not Liability Preclusion) When Negligent Loss Causes Limited Prejudice

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Spoliation of Surveillance Video: Adverse Inference (Not Liability Preclusion) When Negligent Loss Causes Limited Prejudice 1. Introduction Alvarez v 100-10 67th Rd. Condominium (2026 NY Slip Op...

Preconception Co‑Parenting Agreements Extend to Later‑Conceived Siblings Absent Proof of Termination; Best-Interests Inquiry Follows Standing

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Preconception Co‑Parenting Agreements Extend to Later‑Conceived Siblings Absent Proof of Termination; Best-Interests Inquiry Follows Standing 1. Introduction Matter of Kelly C. v Chaya E. (2026 NY...

Dissenting Rule: Trial Courts Retain Postjudgment Jurisdiction to Redact Sexual-Assault Victim Identifiers Under § 54-86e, Even After Acquittal

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Dissenting Rule: Trial Courts Retain Postjudgment Jurisdiction to Redact Sexual-Assault Victim Identifiers Under § 54-86e, Even After Acquittal 1. Introduction In State v. Khan (Dissent), the Supreme...

Wyoming Must Fund True-Cost Teacher Salaries and Make Cumulative Annual Inflation Adjustments (ECAs) in the Legislative Model

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Wyoming Must Fund True-Cost Teacher Salaries and Make Cumulative Annual Inflation Adjustments (ECAs) in the Legislative Model Case: The State of Wyoming v. Wyoming Education Association, a Wyoming...

Beauchamp v. New York City Tr. Auth.: Future Medical Expenses Must Track Reasonably Certain Proof; Speculative Procedures Cannot Inflate Damages; Remittitur Benchmarks for Extraordinary Injuries

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Beauchamp v. New York City Tr. Auth.: Future Medical Expenses Must Track Reasonably Certain Proof; Speculative Procedures Cannot Inflate Damages; Remittitur Benchmarks for Extraordinary Injuries...

Telecommunications Wi‑Fi Cabling Is Not a Labor Law § 240(1) “Alteration,” and Public Service Law § 228 Does Not Shield Owners Outside Cable-TV Installations

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Telecommunications Wi‑Fi Cabling Is Not a Labor Law § 240(1) “Alteration,” and Public Service Law § 228 Does Not Shield Owners Outside Cable-TV Installations 1. Introduction In Hearns v Blended...

Penal Law § 450.10 Turnover Is Not a Substitute for Civil Title Adjudication: Prohibition Lies to Vacate Turnover Orders Resolving Disputed Ownership Without a Criminal Case

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Penal Law § 450.10 Turnover Is Not a Substitute for Civil Title Adjudication: Prohibition Lies to Vacate Turnover Orders Resolving Disputed Ownership Without a Criminal Case I. Introduction Matter of...

Separation-Agreement “Release Consideration” as Dismissal Pay: Allocation Bars UI Benefits and False Certifications Support Overpayment and Willful-Misrepresentation Penalties

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Separation-Agreement “Release Consideration” as Dismissal Pay: Allocation Bars UI Benefits and False Certifications Support Overpayment and Willful-Misrepresentation Penalties 1. Introduction Matter...

Speculation Is Insufficient: Newly Discovered Evidence About a Defense Expert’s Later Misconduct Does Not Satisfy Jones Absent a Probable Lesser Sentence

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Speculation Is Insufficient: Newly Discovered Evidence About a Defense Expert’s Later Misconduct Does Not Satisfy Jones Absent a Probable Lesser Sentence I. Introduction In Benjamin Davis Smiley, Jr....

Matter of Borochov: Reciprocal Public Censure When Foreign Misconduct Constitutes New York Misconduct (22 NYCRR 1240.13[b][3])

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Matter of Borochov: Reciprocal Public Censure When Foreign Misconduct Constitutes New York Misconduct (22 NYCRR 1240.13[b][3]) 1. Introduction Matter of Borochov (2026 NY Slip Op 05305) is a...

People v. Sukram Commentary

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Nonviolent Drug Felony Sentencing: Defendant Must Be Adjudicated a Second Felony Drug Offender (Not a Second Violent Felony Offender) 1. Introduction In People v Sukram (2026 NY Slip Op 05328), the...

State v. Khan (Conn. 2026): Post-Acquittal Jurisdiction Bar to Reopening Criminal Cases to Redact Trial Transcripts; Review Lies by Writ of Error

Date: Sep 18, 2026

State v. Khan (Conn. 2026): Post-Acquittal Jurisdiction Bar to Reopening Criminal Cases to Redact Trial Transcripts; Review Lies by Writ of Error 1. Introduction State v. Khan (SC 21188, officially...

Course of Performance Controls: HAMP Deferred-Principal Repayments Treated as “Subsequent Recoveries” Under RMBS PSAs

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Course of Performance Controls: HAMP Deferred-Principal Repayments Treated as “Subsequent Recoveries” Under RMBS PSAs 1. Introduction Matter of Wells Fargo Bank v. HBK Master Fund L.P. (2026 NY Slip...

Matter of Gellene: Reciprocal Discipline Requires Independent New York “Rule-Equivalency” Review Despite Default

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Matter of Gellene: Reciprocal Discipline Requires Independent New York “Rule-Equivalency” Review Despite Default 1. Introduction Matter of Gellene (2026 NY Slip Op 05361 [3d Dept Sept. 17, 2026])...

State v. Nelson (2026 UT 33) Commentary

Date: Sep 18, 2026

State v. Nelson (2026 UT 33): “Double Deference” Governs Ineffective-Assistance Claims Premised on an Unmade Directed-Verdict Motion, and Evidence Must Be Viewed in Favor of the Jury’s Verdict 1....

Climate Sols. v. State: Washington Clarifies “Horizontal” and “Vertical” Rational Unity Under Article II, Section 19 and Rejects an Omnibus Exception

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Climate Sols. v. State: Washington Clarifies “Horizontal” and “Vertical” Rational Unity Under Article II, Section 19 and Rejects an Omnibus Exception I. Introduction In Climate Solutions, et al. v....

Retirement Does Not Defeat Lawyer Discipline: Default-Based Proof and a One-Year Suspension for Probate Mismanagement, Unreasonable Fees, and Criminal Misconduct

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Retirement Does Not Defeat Lawyer Discipline: Default-Based Proof and a One-Year Suspension for Probate Mismanagement, Unreasonable Fees, and Criminal Misconduct 1. Introduction Office of Lawyer...

Retirement Does Not Defeat Disciplinary Jurisdiction: One-Year Suspension for Knowing Estate/Trust Misconduct and Egregious Misdemeanor Conduct in Default

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Retirement Does Not Defeat Disciplinary Jurisdiction: One-Year Suspension for Knowing Estate/Trust Misconduct and Egregious Misdemeanor Conduct in Default 1. Introduction Office of Lawyer Regulation...

Mandamus Is Unavailable to Upset a Primary Election Tie-Breaker When a Statutory Election Contest Remedy Existed; Court Flags Need for Timely Public Access to Overage/Underage Data

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Mandamus Is Unavailable to Upset a Primary Election Tie-Breaker When a Statutory Election Contest Remedy Existed; Court Flags Need for Timely Public Access to Overage/Underage Data 1. Introduction...