state Case Commentaries

Recorded All-Landowner Assessment Covenant Defeats Preliminary Relief Based on Association Withdrawal

Date: Sep 25, 2026

Recorded All-Landowner Assessment Covenant Defeats Preliminary Relief Based on Association Withdrawal Case: Naylor v. Roundup Mesa Landowners Court: Supreme Court of Montana Date: September 22, 2026...

Generative AI Does Not Excuse False Appellate Citations, and an Actual-Malice Verdict Renders Public-Figure Error Harmless

Date: Sep 25, 2026

Generative AI Does Not Excuse False Appellate Citations, and an Actual-Malice Verdict Renders Public-Figure Error Harmless Case: Posey v. Bushnell Court: Supreme Court of Idaho Date: September 22,...

Expungement Does Not Automatically End a Lawyer’s Serious-Crime Interim Suspension

Date: Sep 25, 2026

Expungement Does Not Automatically End a Lawyer’s Serious-Crime Interim Suspension Case: In Re Eva Vekos, Esq. (Office of Disciplinary Counsel), 2026 VT 45 Court: Supreme Court of Vermont Date:...

State v. D. Crawford: Suspect-Initiated Dialogue After a Miranda Request for Counsel

Date: Sep 24, 2026

Suspect-Initiated Dialogue After a Miranda Request for Counsel: State v. D. Crawford Supreme Court of Montana · September 22, 2026 · 2026 MT 225 Introduction After a confrontation outside a Montana...

Express Probation Waivers Eliminate Fourth Amendment Standing to Challenge Covered Searches

Date: Sep 24, 2026

Express Probation Waivers Eliminate Fourth Amendment Standing to Challenge Covered Searches State v. Al-Mafrachi — Supreme Court of Idaho, September 22, 2026 Introduction Salwan Yousif Al-Mafrachi...

“Charging” an Unreasonable Fee Under SCR 20:1.5(a) Requires Proof of a Client-Facing Demand Beyond a Flat-Fee Agreement

Date: Sep 23, 2026

“Charging” an Unreasonable Fee Under SCR 20:1.5(a) Requires Proof of a Client-Facing Demand Beyond a Flat-Fee Agreement 1. Introduction Office of Lawyer Regulation v. Patrick J. Rupich (2026 WI 32)...

Accountings to OLR Are Not “Charging” an Unreasonable Fee Without Proof of Client Billing Under a Flat-Fee Agreement

Date: Sep 23, 2026

Accountings to OLR Are Not “Charging” an Unreasonable Fee Without Proof of Client Billing Under a Flat-Fee Agreement Case: Office of Lawyer Regulation v. Patrick J. Rupich, 2026 WI 32 (Wis. Sept. 18,...

Ohio Municipal Initiative Limits: Ordinances Creating New Private Rights of Action May Be Kept Off the Ballot

Date: Sep 23, 2026

Ohio Municipal Initiative Limits: Ordinances Creating New Private Rights of Action May Be Kept Off the Ballot I. Introduction In State ex rel. Kidd v. Clinton Cty. Bd. of Elections, Slip Opinion No....

Specificity Requirement for Resignation Pending Disciplinary Proceedings Under RGDP Rule 8

Date: Sep 23, 2026

Specificity Requirement for Resignation Pending Disciplinary Proceedings Under RGDP Rule 8 1. Introduction In STATE OF OKLAHOMA ex rel., OKLAHOMA BAR ASSOCIATION v. W.E. PAT PATE (2026 OK 65), the...

State Must Make a Clear Record of the Scope of a Plea-Bargained “Waiver of Appeal” or the Waiver Will Not Be Enforced

Date: Sep 23, 2026

State Must Make a Clear Record of the Scope of a Plea-Bargained “Waiver of Appeal” or the Waiver Will Not Be Enforced I. Introduction In State v. Delgado, 322 Neb. 364 (2026), the Nebraska Supreme...

State v. McCree (322 Neb. 326): § 28-105.02 Mitigation—The Juvenile Defendant Must Submit a Mental-Health Evaluation; the Sentencing Court Need Not Obtain One Sua Sponte

Date: Sep 23, 2026

State v. McCree (322 Neb. 326): § 28-105.02 Mitigation—The Juvenile Defendant Must Submit a Mental-Health Evaluation; the Sentencing Court Need Not Obtain One Sua Sponte 1. Introduction In State v....

Hawaiʻi Adopts Restatement (Third) Toxic-Tort Causation Framework: Exposure, General Causation, and Specific Causation

Date: Sep 22, 2026

Hawaiʻi Adopts Restatement (Third) Toxic-Tort Causation Framework: Exposure, General Causation, and Specific Causation I. Introduction Patrickson v. DOW Chemical Company and Del Monte Fresh Produce...

No “Newly Discovered Evidence” from Post-Trial Guilty Pleas; No Purnell Conflict Colloquy Absent an Actual Conflict (Del. Supr. Sept. 21, 2026)

Date: Sep 22, 2026

No “Newly Discovered Evidence” from Post-Trial Guilty Pleas; No Purnell Conflict Colloquy Absent an Actual Conflict (Del. Supr. Sept. 21, 2026) 1. Introduction In Brian Wilson aka Fudayl Wakim v....

Permanent Absentee Voting Upheld: Automatic Ballot Mailing Does Not Expand Article V, § 4A Categories in a Facial Challenge

Date: Sep 22, 2026

Permanent Absentee Voting Upheld: Automatic Ballot Mailing Does Not Expand Article V, § 4A Categories in a Facial Challenge I. Introduction In Gerald W. Hocker and Steven Washington v. The Honorable...

BELLOMO v. ROYBAL: NRCP 68 Fee Awards Must Exclude Pre-Offer Contingency Work Under Clark v. Marin

Date: Sep 22, 2026

NRCP 68 Fee Awards Must Exclude Pre-Offer Contingency Work Under Clark v. Marin 1. Introduction Parties: Louis Bellomo and his employer, SHAC, LLC (a/k/a Sapphire LV Gentleman’s Club) (collectively,...

Half-Truths as Actionable Fraud in the Inducement: Nevada Recognizes a Duty to Disclose Once a Solicitation Creates a Misleading Impression

Date: Sep 22, 2026

Half-Truths as Actionable Fraud in the Inducement: Nevada Recognizes a Duty to Disclose Once a Solicitation Creates a Misleading Impression 1. Introduction In ROYAL UNION TR. v. JOHNSON (Nev. Sept....

Nevada: Fee-Splitting Alone Does Not Create a Joint Venture for Malpractice Vicarious Liability Without Shared Control and Loss-Sharing

Date: Sep 22, 2026

Nevada: Fee-Splitting Alone Does Not Create a Joint Venture for Malpractice Vicarious Liability Without Shared Control and Loss-Sharing 1. Introduction In HARPER v. BRUCE G. FAGEL, A LAW CORP. (Nev....

NRS 176.09183 Requires a Showing that New DNA Testing Could Have Prevented Prosecution Despite Other Circumstantial Evidence

Date: Sep 22, 2026

NRS 176.09183 Requires a Showing that New DNA Testing Could Have Prevented Prosecution Despite Other Circumstantial Evidence 1. Introduction In PINEDA-LAURENCIO (YIORKIS) v. STATE (CRIMINAL) (Nev....

Reconsidering Youngblood Under Michigan’s Due Process Clause for Destroyed Police Interview Recordings

Date: Sep 22, 2026

Reconsidering Youngblood Under Michigan’s Due Process Clause for Destroyed Police Interview Recordings 1. Introduction People of Michigan v. Dangelo Ladonn McWilliams (Mich Sup Ct, Sept 17, 2026)...

Abraham v. Arizona Board of Regents: De Novo Review, Post-Request Destruction as Denial, and “Substantially Prevailed” Measured Across the Entire Public-Records Dispute

Date: Sep 22, 2026

Abraham v. Arizona Board of Regents: De Novo Review, Post-Request Destruction as Denial, and “Substantially Prevailed” Measured Across the Entire Public-Records Dispute I. Introduction Parties: Dr....