state Case Commentaries

Non-Signatory Biological Fathers May Bring an Independent § 25-803 Paternity Action Despite an Existing AOP; Courts Must Apply § 25-814(C) to Competing Presumptions

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Non-Signatory Biological Fathers May Bring an Independent § 25-803 Paternity Action Despite an Existing AOP; Courts Must Apply § 25-814(C) to Competing Presumptions I. Introduction Case: TYLER STRANG...

OCPA Deadlines Enforced: A Motion Is Denied by Operation of Law 30 Days After a Hearing Unless the Court Expressly Extends the Hearing Date

Date: Sep 16, 2026

OCPA Deadlines Enforced: A Motion Is Denied by Operation of Law 30 Days After a Hearing Unless the Court Expressly Extends the Hearing Date I. Introduction Rivero v. Stahlheber, 2026 OK 63 (Okla....

Post-Conviction Summary Dismissal Reversed: A Petitioner’s Admissible Affidavit Can Create a Material Fact Dispute Over Counsel’s Failure to Convey Plea Acceptance

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Post-Conviction Summary Dismissal Reversed: A Petitioner’s Admissible Affidavit Can Create a Material Fact Dispute Over Counsel’s Failure to Convey Plea Acceptance Case: Ennis Jr. v. State of Idaho...

Untimely Postprimary Candidate-Qualification Protests Cannot Use R.C. 3501.39(A)(2) to Evade R.C. 3513.05; Boards Lack Late Sua Sponte Power Under R.C. 3501.39(A)(4)

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Untimely Postprimary Candidate-Qualification Protests Cannot Use R.C. 3501.39(A)(2) to Evade R.C. 3513.05; Boards Lack Late Sua Sponte Power Under R.C. 3501.39(A)(4) I. Introduction Case: State ex...

Homogenous Per-Share Merger-Damages Settlements May Proceed Under Rule 23(b)(1)/(b)(2) Without Mandatory Opt-Out; Celera Opt-Out Remains an Exceptional, Discretionary Remedy

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Homogenous Per-Share Merger-Damages Settlements May Proceed Under Rule 23(b)(1)/(b)(2) Without Mandatory Opt-Out; Celera Opt-Out Remains an Exceptional, Discretionary Remedy Case: IsZo Capital LP v....

Unobjected-to Instructional Errors on Uncontested Issues Do Not Constitute Plain Error (and “Eluding” Need Not End When Police Call Off a Chase)

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Unobjected-to Instructional Errors on Uncontested Issues Do Not Constitute Plain Error (and “Eluding” Need Not End When Police Call Off a Chase) Case: People v. Jeffery Sloan, 2026 CO 63 (Colo. Sept....

Amended Pleadings Revive a Waived Civil Jury Demand Only When They Add New Triable Issues (Not New Theories or Clarifications)

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Amended Pleadings Revive a Waived Civil Jury Demand Only When They Add New Triable Issues (Not New Theories or Clarifications) 1. Introduction In SCP 3330 Brighton v. Mountain Cement, 2026 CO 62...

Terran Sanchez v. People (2026 CO 60): COLJI-Crim. E:03 (2022) “Firmly Convinced / Real Possibility” Reasonable-Doubt Instruction Upheld as Constitutional

Date: Sep 16, 2026

COLJI-Crim. E:03 (2022) “Firmly Convinced / Real Possibility” Reasonable-Doubt Instruction Is Constitutional and Does Not Shift or Lower the Burden of Proof Case: Terran Sanchez v. People, 2026 CO 60...

Rule 56(f) Requires Discovery Before Summary Judgment on Fact-Intensive Equitable Defenses to Condominium Covenant Enforcement

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Rule 56(f) Requires Discovery Before Summary Judgment on Fact-Intensive Equitable Defenses to Condominium Covenant Enforcement Case: Sea Breeze Condominiums & Resort Owners' Association, Inc. v....

Wyoming Presentence Credit Rule for Out-of-State Confinement on Independent Charges & Notice-of-Appeal Jurisdiction for Post-Notice Orders

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Out-of-State Jail Time Is Not Credited When Independent Charges Would Have Kept the Defendant Confined; Post-Notice Orders Require a Separate/Amended Notice of Appeal Brian Joseph Melber v. The State...

Tie Elections in Hawaiʻi: Zero-Margin Overages, Burden on Election Officials, and Invalid “By Lot” Procedures Adopted Without Rulemaking

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Tie Elections in Hawaiʻi: Zero-Margin Overages, Burden on Election Officials, and Invalid “By Lot” Procedures Adopted Without Rulemaking Context: The provided text is an amended separate opinion by...

Amended Judgments Do Not Reset Post‑Judgment Interest: Interest Runs from the Entry Date of the Unreversed Money Award

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Amended Judgments Do Not Reset Post‑Judgment Interest: Interest Runs from the Entry Date of the Unreversed Money Award 1. Introduction In SNAP! MOBILE v. VERTICAL RAISE (Idaho Supreme Court, Sept....

Statutory Extraterritorial Arrest Violations Do Not Trigger Idaho’s Exclusionary Rule Absent a Constitutional Breach (State v. Satterfield)

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Statutory Extraterritorial Arrest Violations Do Not Trigger Idaho’s Exclusionary Rule Absent a Constitutional Breach (State v. Satterfield) 1. Introduction In State v. Satterfield (Idaho Sept. 11,...

Probate Rule 2(f) Preservation in Alaska Commitment & Medication Appeals: Mandatory Objections to Master’s Reports; Voluntary-Treatment Advisement Errors Require Prejudice for Reversal

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Probate Rule 2(f) Preservation in Alaska Commitment & Medication Appeals: Mandatory Objections to Master’s Reports; Voluntary-Treatment Advisement Errors Require Prejudice for Reversal 1....

Kuehn v. Pillen: Taxpayer Standing Requires an Expenditure-Centered Dispute; Incidental Implementation Costs Cannot Manufacture Standing

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Taxpayer Standing Requires an Expenditure-Centered Dispute; Incidental Implementation Costs Cannot Manufacture Standing (and Chambers v. Lautenbaugh Disapproved to the Extent Inconsistent) 1....

Kansas “Marketable Gas” After Cooper-Clark: Express Royalty Clauses Control; Marketability Is a Fact Question and the Marketable Condition Rule Is a Gap-Filler

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Kansas “Marketable Gas” After Cooper-Clark: Express Royalty Clauses Control; Marketability Is a Fact Question and the Marketable Condition Rule Is a Gap-Filler 1. Introduction Case: Cooper-Clark...

Martin v. City of Topeka: Street-Maintenance Duty as a Specific Duty; Public-Duty Doctrine Survives the KTCA; No Discretion to Ignore Known Street Hazards

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Martin v. City of Topeka: Street-Maintenance Duty as a Specific Duty; Public-Duty Doctrine Survives the KTCA; No Discretion to Ignore Known Street Hazards 1. Introduction In Martin v. City of Topeka...

State v. Contreras: No “Itemized” Jury-Waiver Requirement for Apprendi Age Facts When the Defendant Pleads and Admits the Charging Document

Date: Sep 12, 2026

State v. Contreras: No “Itemized” Jury-Waiver Requirement for Apprendi Age Facts When the Defendant Pleads and Admits the Charging Document 1. Introduction In State v. Contreras (Kan. Sept. 11,...

State v. Hunter (Kan. 2026): K.S.A. 22-3430 Commitment Is In Lieu of Sentencing and Cannot Be Paired with a KSGA Prison Sentence

Date: Sep 12, 2026

K.S.A. 22-3430 Commitment Is In Lieu of Sentencing and Cannot Be Imposed Simultaneously with a KSGA Prison Sentence Case: State v. Hunter, No. 128,056 (Kan. Sept. 11, 2026) Court: Supreme Court of...

State v. Trickle: Admissibility of Suicide “Relative Risk” Expert Testimony, Strict Objection Specificity, and Limits on “Liar” Rhetoric in Closing

Date: Sep 12, 2026

State v. Trickle: Admissibility of Suicide “Relative Risk” Expert Testimony, Strict Objection Specificity, and Limits on “Liar” Rhetoric in Closing Court: Supreme Court of Kansas Date: September 11,...