federal Case Commentaries

MDLEA Jurisdiction: No “Magic Words” Needed for a Nationality Request; Use of a Foreign Vessel Does Not Defeat U.S. Jurisdiction

Date: Sep 17, 2026

MDLEA Jurisdiction: No “Magic Words” Needed for a Nationality Request; Use of a Foreign Vessel Does Not Defeat U.S. Jurisdiction I. Introduction This consolidated Eleventh Circuit decision concerns...

MDLEA “Request” for Nationality Requires No Magic Words; Joint/Foreign-Platform Interdictions Do Not Defeat Jurisdiction

Date: Sep 17, 2026

MDLEA “Request” for Nationality Requires No Magic Words; Joint/Foreign-Platform Interdictions Do Not Defeat Jurisdiction Case: United States v. Manuel Melo (consolidated with codefendants Yesid...

MDLEA in a Foreign EEZ Treated as “High Seas”; Rule 5 Delay Remedies Limited to Suppression (Not Dismissal)

Date: Sep 17, 2026

MDLEA in a Foreign EEZ Treated as “High Seas”; Rule 5 Delay Remedies Limited to Suppression (Not Dismissal) Case: United States v. Silverio Henriquez (with codefendant Victor Manuel Pena-Abreu)...

Blanket Bans on Contacting Congress During Supervised Release Must Be Narrowly Tailored, But Overbreadth Is Not “Plain” Without On-Point Precedent

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Blanket Bans on Contacting Congress During Supervised Release Must Be Narrowly Tailored, But Overbreadth Is Not “Plain” Without On-Point Precedent I. Introduction In United States v. Garry Lebron...

Physician Not a Party/Beneficiary to Hospital–Clinic PSA; Loss of Call-Rotation Eligibility Is Material Breach Justifying For-Cause Termination

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Physician Not a Party/Beneficiary to Hospital–Clinic PSA; Loss of Call-Rotation Eligibility Is Material Breach Justifying For-Cause Termination Case: Garvey v. Ogden Clinic Professional Corp. Court:...

Tenth Circuit: “Overall Project Purposes” Under CWA § 404 May Include Multiple Interrelated Applicant Goals

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Tenth Circuit: “Overall Project Purposes” Under CWA § 404 May Include Multiple Interrelated Applicant Goals Case: Save The Colorado v. Graham (Nos. 25-1137, 25-1231 & 25-1299) Court: United States...

Vacatur-and-Amended-Judgment Rule: A First § 2255 Challenge to the Intervening Judgment Is Not “Second or Successive,” Even After a Mere Sentence Correction

Date: Sep 17, 2026

Vacatur-and-Amended-Judgment Rule: A First § 2255 Challenge to the Intervening Judgment Is Not “Second or Successive,” Even After a Mere Sentence Correction I. Introduction In In re: Abraham A....

Unpleaded Burnside and Independent Subrogation Claims Cannot Be Revived by a Pretrial Order in a Maritime Limitation Case

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Unpleaded Burnside and Independent Subrogation Claims Cannot Be Revived by a Pretrial Order in a Maritime Limitation Case 1. Introduction Aries Marine v. American Longshore (5th Cir. Sept. 14, 2026)...

Appellate Forfeiture of New Policy-Ambiguity Arguments After Contrary District-Court Positions

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Appellate Forfeiture of New Policy-Ambiguity Arguments After Contrary District-Court Positions Case: Megalomedia v. Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Company (5th Cir. Sept. 14, 2026) Panel: Ho,...

Pro Se Status and Grief Are Not “Good Cause” Under Rule 4(m): Fifth Circuit Affirms Service-Based Dismissal Even When Limitations Likely Bars Refiling

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Pro Se Status and Grief Are Not “Good Cause” Under Rule 4(m): Fifth Circuit Affirms Service-Based Dismissal Even When Limitations Likely Bars Refiling Case: Murphy v. Miller (5th Cir. Sept. 14, 2026)...

Insufficient Implementation Time Can Render a Postal Election-Mail Rule Arbitrary and Capricious Under the APA (Stay Denied)

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Insufficient Implementation Time Can Render a Postal Election-Mail Rule Arbitrary and Capricious Under the APA (Stay Denied) 1. Introduction United States Postal Service, et al. v. California, et al....

Procedural Due Process for Municipal Trespass Warnings Requires a Meaningful, Standards-Guided Post-Deprivation Appeal—Even When Substantive Due Process Fails

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Procedural Due Process for Municipal Trespass Warnings Requires a Meaningful, Standards-Guided Post-Deprivation Appeal—Even When Substantive Due Process Fails I. Introduction Case: Jesse Lee v. City...

Mootness Remand Under FRAP 12.1(b): Vacatur of a Preliminary Injunction to Eliminate Appellate Jurisdiction

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Mootness Remand Under FRAP 12.1(b): Vacatur of a Preliminary Injunction to Eliminate Appellate Jurisdiction Introduction American Academy of Pediatrics v. James Uthmeier (7th Cir. Sept. 14, 2026) is...

United States v. Burton: § 1591(c) as an Alternative Mens Rea Means (No Unanimity Required) and “Purpose” to Produce Under § 2251(a)

Date: Sep 16, 2026

United States v. Burton: § 1591(c) as an Alternative Mens Rea Means (No Unanimity Required) and “Purpose” to Produce Under § 2251(a) 1. Introduction In United States v. Dontae D. Burton (11th Cir....

Bergin v. N.Y. State Unified Court System: The Second Circuit Aligns Title VII Religious-Accommodation Prima Facie Proof with Abercrombie’s Motivating-Factor Standard

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Bergin v. N.Y. State Unified Court System: The Second Circuit Aligns Title VII Religious-Accommodation Prima Facie Proof with Abercrombie’s Motivating-Factor Standard 1. Introduction In Bergin v....

Second Circuit Adopts Hunt Test for Associational Standing Under § 1983 and Overrules Aguayo

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Second Circuit Adopts Hunt Test for Associational Standing Under § 1983 and Overrules Aguayo Case: Defending Education v. Croton-Harmon Union Free School District Court: U.S. Court of Appeals for the...

General Relevance/Prejudice Evidentiary Rulings Do Not “Subsume” a Confrontation Clause Claim Under AEDPA; Precluding the Prior Brady-Misconduct Narrative Can Still Permit Meaningful Cross-Examination and a Complete Defense

Date: Sep 16, 2026

General Relevance/Prejudice Evidentiary Rulings Do Not “Subsume” a Confrontation Clause Claim Under AEDPA; Precluding the Prior Brady-Misconduct Narrative Can Still Permit Meaningful...

Florida Building Code “Permit-Vesting” Rule: The Code in Effect on the Permit Application Date Governs for the Life of the Permit (and Later Code Editions Do Not Create Contract or § 553.84 Liability)

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Florida Building Code “Permit-Vesting” Rule: The Code in Effect on the Permit Application Date Governs for the Life of the Permit (and Later Code Editions Do Not Create Contract or § 553.84...

Late-Disclosed Key Witness May Be Excluded Under Rule 37 and Fees Awarded; Performance-Based Termination Defeats ADEA/FRCA and “Leaving” Announcement Is Not Defamatory

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Late-Disclosed Key Witness May Be Excluded Under Rule 37 and Fees Awarded; Performance-Based Termination Defeats ADEA/FRCA and “Leaving” Announcement Is Not Defamatory I. Introduction In John Lapikas...

Qualified Immunity Bars § 1983 Claims for Brief Detention of a Shooting Witness Absent Clearly Established Law; Pro Se Dismissals Under Rule 12(b)(6) Generally Require at Least One Opportunity to Amend

Date: Sep 16, 2026

Qualified Immunity Bars § 1983 Claims for Brief Detention of a Shooting Witness Absent Clearly Established Law; Pro Se Dismissals Under Rule 12(b)(6) Generally Require at Least One Opportunity to...