federal Case Commentaries

Gore v. State Farm: Evidence and Documentation Requirements for Resisting Insurance Summary Judgment

Date: Nov 16, 2026

Gore v. State Farm: Evidence and Documentation Requirements for Resisting Insurance Summary Judgment Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit Case: No. 25-60625 Decision date:...

PFA Status Alone Does Not Establish a Constitutional Arrest-Notification Duty; Police-Targeting Claims Require Supporting Facts

Date: Nov 16, 2026

PFA Status Alone Does Not Establish a Constitutional Arrest-Notification Duty; Police-Targeting Claims Require Supporting Facts Case: John Gomez v. City of Pittsburgh, No. 26-1735 Court: United...

Unreasonable Reservation-System Delays Can Constitute a Material Breach of a Hotel Franchise Agreement

Date: Nov 16, 2026

Unreasonable Reservation-System Delays Can Constitute a Material Breach of a Hotel Franchise Agreement Case: Travelodge Hotels, Inc. v. Huber Hotels, LLC, Robert Huber, and Janette Huber Court:...

Acceptance of Responsibility After Remand: A Renewed Guilty Plea Does Not Erase Earlier Obstruction

Date: Nov 13, 2026

Acceptance of Responsibility After Remand: A Renewed Guilty Plea Does Not Erase Earlier Obstruction Case: United States v. Alexander Leszczynski Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh...

Visible Suspected Narcotics May Justify Vehicle Entry During a Lawful Traffic Stop

Date: Nov 13, 2026

Visible Suspected Narcotics May Justify Vehicle Entry During a Lawful Traffic Stop Case: United States v. DaQuan Lane, No. 24-4312 Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit...

Delayed HCV Treatment Claims Require Medical Evidence Linking the Delay to Injury

Date: Nov 13, 2026

Delayed HCV Treatment Claims Require Medical Evidence Linking the Delay to Injury Case: Wallace Collier v. Woodrow Myers Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit Date: November...

Prisoner Retaliation Screening Must Address Informal Complaints and Alleged Coordinated Punishment

Date: Nov 13, 2026

Prisoner Retaliation Screening Must Address Informal Complaints and Alleged Coordinated Punishment Case: Calvin Mayfield v. Ryan Woods, No. 26-1401 Court: United States Court of Appeals for the...

Supervised-Release Sentencing After Esteras: Retributive Factors Can Require Resentencing on Plain-Error Review

Date: Nov 13, 2026

Supervised-Release Sentencing After Esteras: Retributive Factors Can Require Resentencing on Plain-Error Review Case: United States v. Bayron-Ramos, No. 25-1366 Court: United States Court of Appeals...

Federal-Sector Title VII: Flexible Proof Does Not Eliminate Personnel-Action, Timeliness, or Appellate-Preservation Requirements

Date: Nov 13, 2026

Federal-Sector Title VII: Flexible Proof Does Not Eliminate Personnel-Action, Timeliness, or Appellate-Preservation Requirements Case: Cecile Jackson v. Secretary of the Air Force Court: United...

AEDPA Double Deference: Strategic Trial Choices and Uncalled Witnesses Require a Showing of Prejudice

Date: Nov 13, 2026

AEDPA Double Deference: Strategic Trial Choices and Uncalled Witnesses Require a Showing of Prejudice Case: Everett Smith v. Warden, Dooly SP Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh...

Negotiated Nondisparagement Settlements and Foreseeable Reputational Damages Under Florida Law

Date: Nov 13, 2026

Negotiated Nondisparagement Settlements and Foreseeable Reputational Damages Under Florida Law Case: Michael Fitzgerald v. Ronda McNae Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit...

Brill v. Ulster County: An Unconditional ACOD Can Satisfy Favorable Termination Under Section 1983

Date: Nov 13, 2026

An Unconditional ACOD Can Satisfy Favorable Termination for a Section 1983 Malicious Prosecution Claim Case: Brill v. Ulster County, No. 25-2432, United States Court of Appeals for the Second...

Failure to Investigate a Known Exculpatory Eyewitness Can Warrant Habeas Relief Despite AEDPA Deference

Date: Nov 13, 2026

Failure to Investigate a Known Exculpatory Eyewitness Can Warrant Habeas Relief Despite AEDPA Deference Case: Maleek Jones v. Sharonda Carlos, et al., No. 23-7097 Court: United States Court of...

Numerical Handgun Limits and a 90-Day Acquisition Cap Require Second Amendment Historical Review

Date: Nov 13, 2026

Numerical Handgun Limits and a 90-Day Acquisition Cap Require Second Amendment Historical Review Case: Mills v. New York City, No. 24-3308-cv Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Second...

United States v. Robinson: Prior Digital Coordination Supports Narrow Communication Searches, Not Blanket Storage or Employer-Device Searches

Date: Nov 13, 2026

United States v. Robinson: Prior Digital Coordination Supports Narrow Communication Searches, Not Blanket Storage or Employer-Device Searches Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Second...

CGIA Immunity: Conscious Disregard of Nonphysical Harm Can Be Willful and Wanton

Date: Nov 13, 2026

CGIA Immunity: Conscious Disregard of Nonphysical Harm Can Be Willful and Wanton Case: Gasser v. Coffey Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit Date: November 10, 2026 Case...

Immigration Reopening: The BIA Must Address Equitable Tolling and Distinguish Waivers from U Visas

Date: Nov 13, 2026

Immigration Reopening: The BIA Must Address Equitable Tolling and Distinguish Waivers from U Visas Case: Robert Panton v. Todd W. Blanche Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit...

Excessive-Force Trials: Local Policy Does Not Define the Constitutional Standard, and Evidentiary Objections Must Be Specifically Preserved

Date: Nov 13, 2026

Excessive-Force Trials: Local Policy Does Not Define the Constitutional Standard, and Evidentiary Objections Must Be Specifically Preserved Case: Trevor Young, Jr. v. Rodgina Jones, No. 25-1074...

Later Scientific Evidence Alone Does Not Establish Fraud Justifying Reopening a Class Settlement

Date: Nov 13, 2026

Later Scientific Evidence Alone Does Not Establish Fraud Justifying Reopening a Class Settlement Case: In re: E. Palestine Train Derailment, No. 26-3499 Court: United States Court of Appeals for the...

Threatened Civil Litigation Can Plausibly Restrain Parental Criticism of Public Schools

Date: Nov 13, 2026

Threatened Civil Litigation Can Plausibly Restrain Parental Criticism of Public Schools Case: Stefanie Boone v. Lowell Area Schools Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit...