2d Circuit Case Commentaries

Interlocutory Appellate Jurisdiction Limits: A “Motion to Modify” Cannot Re-Litigate a Preliminary Injunction Under 28 U.S.C. § 1292(a)(1)

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Interlocutory Appellate Jurisdiction Limits: A “Motion to Modify” Cannot Re-Litigate a Preliminary Injunction Under 28 U.S.C. § 1292(a)(1) 1. Introduction In CFPB v. Blust Family 2019 Irrevocable Tr....

COGSA “Package” by Agreement in Non-Container Shipments: A Pallet-Definition Clause Can Override the Face of the Sea Waybill

Date: Mar 3, 2026

COGSA “Package” by Agreement in Non-Container Shipments: A Pallet-Definition Clause Can Override the Face of the Sea Waybill 1. Introduction HDI Glob. Ins. Co. v. Kuehne + Nagel, Inc. is a Second...

Nexus to Political Opinion in Domestic-Violence Asylum Claims Requires Evidence of Persecutor’s Imputation; Police Reporting Alone Is Insufficient (Second Circuit Summary Order)

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Nexus to Political Opinion in Domestic-Violence Asylum Claims Requires Evidence of Persecutor’s Imputation; Police Reporting Alone Is Insufficient (Second Circuit Summary Order) 1. Introduction In...

Extortion-Driven Harm Lacks “One Central Reason” Nexus to Gender-Based Social Groups; CAT Review Is Forfeited Without Specific Error

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Extortion-Driven Harm Lacks “One Central Reason” Nexus to Gender-Based Social Groups; CAT Review Is Forfeited Without Specific Error 1. Introduction In Mejia-Padilla v. Bondi (2d Cir. Feb. 27, 2026)...

Milone v. Bryant Park Corp.: Licensee/Event Operator Not Liable for Sidewalk Mat Absent Special Use (Distinct Benefit + Causation) or Statutory Duty; NYC Admin. Code § 7-210 Duty Is Nondelegable

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Milone v. Bryant Park Corp.: Licensee/Event Operator Not Liable for Sidewalk Mat Absent Special Use (Distinct Benefit + Causation) or Statutory Duty; NYC Admin. Code § 7-210 Duty Is Nondelegable...

§ 6038(b) Foreign-Reporting Penalties Are Administratively Assessable (No District-Court Suit Required)

Date: Mar 3, 2026

§ 6038(b) Foreign-Reporting Penalties Are Administratively Assessable (No District-Court Suit Required) I. Introduction Safdieh v. Comm'r (2d Cir. Feb. 27, 2026) addresses a high-stakes but technical...

IDEA Claims Not Pursued Before the IHO Are Forfeited as Unexhausted; District Courts Must Adjudicate Parents’ Attorneys’ Fee Requests

Date: Mar 3, 2026

IDEA Claims Not Pursued Before the IHO Are Forfeited as Unexhausted; District Courts Must Adjudicate Parents’ Attorneys’ Fee Requests Nonprecedential posture: This decision is a Second Circuit...

IDEA Tuition Reimbursement May Be Denied for Failure to Provide the Statutory “Ten-Day Notice,” Even Where Parents Later Proffer a Notice Letter

Date: Mar 3, 2026

IDEA Tuition Reimbursement May Be Denied for Failure to Provide the Statutory “Ten-Day Notice,” Even Where Parents Later Proffer a Notice Letter Introduction Mejia v. Samuels (2d Cir. Feb. 27, 2026)...

Generalized “Safety” Assurances in Securities Offering Materials Are Inactionable Puffery Absent Specific, Pleaded Falsity or a Disclosure Duty

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Generalized “Safety” Assurances in Securities Offering Materials Are Inactionable Puffery Absent Specific, Pleaded Falsity or a Disclosure Duty Introduction Ohio Carpenters' Pension Fund v. Norfolk...

Post–VanDerStok Remand: Product-Specific “Firearm” Analysis Required Before Interlocutory Review in Ghost-Gun Litigation

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Post–VanDerStok Remand: Product-Specific “Firearm” Analysis Required Before Interlocutory Review in Ghost-Gun Litigation 1. Introduction The People of the State of New York, by Letitia James,...

United States v. Jimenez: Appeal Waivers Foreclose Post-Remand Guideline Recalculation and Courts Must Justify Device-Search Conditions with Defendant-Specific Facts

Date: Mar 3, 2026

United States v. Jimenez: Appeal Waivers Foreclose Post-Remand Guideline Recalculation and Courts Must Justify Device-Search Conditions with Defendant-Specific Facts Court: U.S. Court of Appeals for...

IDEA Administrative Waiver: Timeliness Arguments Not Raised to the SRO Are Forfeited; Exhaustion Is Nonjurisdictional

Date: Mar 3, 2026

IDEA Administrative Waiver: Timeliness Arguments Not Raised to the SRO Are Forfeited; Exhaustion Is Nonjurisdictional 1. Introduction In M.G. v. Rye City School District (2d Cir. Feb. 25, 2026)...

Law-of-the-Case Bars New and Recycled Claims on a Third Appeal After a Limited Resentencing Remand; Bruen Challenges to 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1) Remain Foreclosed by Zherka

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Law-of-the-Case Bars New and Recycled Claims on a Third Appeal After a Limited Resentencing Remand; Bruen Challenges to 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1) Remain Foreclosed by Zherka I. Introduction United States...

Upward Variance “Double Counting” Rule: When a Guideline-Accounted Factor Drives a Major Variance, the Court Must Explain Why This Case Is Atypical

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Upward Variance “Double Counting” Rule: When a Guideline-Accounted Factor Drives a Major Variance, the Court Must Explain Why This Case Is Atypical 1. Introduction Case: United States v. Ramos, No....

BMI Rate-Court Proceedings: “Compelling-Reason” Constraint on Novel Revenue Bases and Heightened Scrutiny of Benchmark Weighting

Date: Feb 27, 2026

BMI Rate-Court Proceedings: “Compelling-Reason” Constraint on Novel Revenue Bases and Heightened Scrutiny of Benchmark Weighting Introduction Broadcast Music, Inc. (“BMI”) licenses public-performance...

Post–Loper Bright: No Deference to SEC Interpretations When Defining “Investment Adviser” Under the Advisers Act

Date: Feb 27, 2026

Post–Loper Bright: No Deference to SEC Interpretations When Defining “Investment Adviser” Under the Advisers Act Case: U.S. Sec. & Exch. Comm'n v. Amah (2d Cir. Feb. 24, 2026) (summary order) Court:...

Rule 9(b) in FCA Product-Defect/Shipping Theories Requires a Concrete, Identifiable Compromised Item or Claim

Date: Feb 27, 2026

Rule 9(b) in FCA Product-Defect/Shipping Theories Requires a Concrete, Identifiable Compromised Item or Claim Introduction In Wood v. Siemens (2d Cir. Feb. 24, 2026) (summary order), relator Mary...

Waiver-by-Tactical Non-Objection to Attorney-Witness Testimony and Reliance on Curative Instructions in Securities-Fraud Trials (United States v. Larmore)

Date: Feb 22, 2026

Waiver-by-Tactical Non-Objection to Attorney-Witness Testimony and Reliance on Curative Instructions in Securities-Fraud Trials (United States v. Larmore) Introduction United States v. Larmore (2d...

Plain-Error Review Governs Unpreserved Procedural Challenges to Above-Policy Supervised-Release Revocation Sentences

Date: Feb 22, 2026

Plain-Error Review Governs Unpreserved Procedural Challenges to Above-Policy Supervised-Release Revocation Sentences Introduction United States v. Morales-Plumei is a nonprecedential Second Circuit...

Organizational “Diversion of Resources” Standing Narrowed After Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine; Tenant-Screening Vendors Not Liable Under FHA Absent Proximate Cause

Date: Feb 22, 2026

Organizational “Diversion of Resources” Standing Narrowed After FDA v. All. for Hippocratic Med.; Tenant-Screening Vendors Not Liable Under FHA Absent Proximate Cause Case: CFHC v. CoreLogic Rental...