Bombay High Court Case Commentaries

Arrest Requires Demonstrable Necessity: A Subsequent Notice or Mechanical Remand Cannot Validate Unlawful Detention

Date: Oct 29, 2026

Arrest Requires Demonstrable Necessity: A Subsequent Notice or Mechanical Remand Cannot Validate Unlawful Detention Case: BIPIN SATISH CHANDRA AGRWAL v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANR Citation:...

A Scheduled Ingredient Alone Does Not Create a Drug Ceiling Price

Date: Sep 29, 2026

A Scheduled Ingredient Alone Does Not Create a Drug Ceiling Price: Formulation-Specific Price Fixation Under DPCO 1995 Is Mandatory Case: M/S PHARMED LIMITED AND ANR v. UNION OF INDIA AND 3 ANR...

Airport Site Selection Is an Expert Policy Decision: Landowners Cannot Compel Adoption of an Alternative Site

Date: Sep 23, 2026

Airport Site Selection Is an Expert Policy Decision: Landowners Cannot Compel Adoption of an Alternative Site Case: PANDIT SHIVAJI KUMBHARKAR AND ORS v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA THRU. SECRETARY AND...

A Magistrate Cannot Revert to Section 156(3) After Entering the Post-Cognizance Procedure

Date: Sep 12, 2026

A Magistrate Cannot Revert to Section 156(3) After Entering the Post-Cognizance Procedure Case: TANSUKHLAL PANNALAL JAIN v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANR Court: Bombay High Court, Criminal...

POSH Act: ICC’s “No Sexual Element” Closure Is an Appealable Section 13(2) Recommendation Under Section 18

Date: Aug 26, 2026

POSH Act: ICC’s “No Sexual Element” Closure Is an Appealable Section 13(2) Recommendation Under Section 18 Case: ANUP VIKAL v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA THR THE INDUSTRIES AND ORS (connected with WP...

RTI Act: No Obligation on a Public Authority to Procure Information from a Private Body Merely Because It Can Access It Under Another Law

Date: Aug 19, 2026

RTI Act: No Obligation on a Public Authority to Procure Information from a Private Body Merely Because It Can Access It Under Another Law 1) Introduction This group of nine writ petitions before the...

Re-reservation Bar After Section 127 Lapse: Land De-reserved by Operation of Law Cannot Be Reserved Again in a Subsequent Development Plan

Date: Aug 18, 2026

Re-reservation Bar After Section 127 Lapse: Land De-reserved by Operation of Law Cannot Be Reserved Again in a Subsequent Development Plan 1. Introduction The Bombay High Court (M.S. Karnik and...

Society NOC Cannot Be Imposed Without Statutory Authority for Registration of a Final Consent Decree

Date: Aug 18, 2026

Society NOC Cannot Be Imposed Without Statutory Authority for Registration of a Final Consent Decree Case: SANJAY NARANG v. JOINT SUB-REGISTRAR CITY NO. 1 OF ASSURANCE MUMBAI Court: Bombay High Court...

Mandamus Cannot Protect Admission Founded on a Non-Authentic CET Scorecard; Writ Court Confines Itself to Authenticity, Not Criminal Attribution

Date: Aug 15, 2026

Mandamus Cannot Protect Admission Founded on a Non-Authentic CET Scorecard; Writ Court Confines Itself to Authenticity, Not Criminal Attribution 1) Introduction In SHUBHAM VIJAY MANGIRE v. THE STATE...

POSH Act Appeals Must Lie Only to Statutory Court/Tribunal or Notified Standing Orders Appellate Authority—Employer-Created “Appellate Authorities” Are Without Jurisdiction

Date: Aug 13, 2026

POSH Act Appeals Must Lie Only to Statutory Court/Tribunal or Notified Standing Orders Appellate Authority—Employer-Created “Appellate Authorities” Are Without Jurisdiction Case: ASHOK UPADHYAY,...

Vehicle Under Repair is “In Use” and a Repair Garage is a “Public Place”: Insurer Liability for Welding-Blast Death Under the Motor Vehicles Act

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Vehicle Under Repair is “In Use” and a Repair Garage is a “Public Place”: Insurer Liability for Welding-Blast Death Under the Motor Vehicles Act 1. Introduction In THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD....

Mandatory Pre‑Cognizance Hearing under BNSS Section 223 Applies to SEBI Special Courts

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Mandatory Pre‑Cognizance Hearing under BNSS Section 223 Applies to SEBI Special Courts (Non‑Compliance Vitiates Cognizance) 1) Introduction In Neville Tuli v. Securities and Exchange Board of Indi...

Section 33(2)(b) “One Month’s Wages” Must Be an Additional Statutory Payment, Not the Earned Salary of the Dismissal Month

Date: Jul 8, 2026

Section 33(2)(b) “One Month’s Wages” Must Be an Additional Statutory Payment, Not the Earned Salary of the Dismissal Month 1) Introduction In DR. SATISH BHIDE v. SHRI. RAVINDRA M. PANDE (Bombay High...

Executive Government Resolutions Cannot Retrospectively Defeat Statutory Leasehold-to-Occupancy Conversion; Sub-lessee Lacks Locus; Section 257 MLRC Is Supervisory

Date: Jul 8, 2026

Executive Government Resolutions Cannot Retrospectively Defeat Statutory Leasehold-to-Occupancy Conversion; Sub-lessee Lacks Locus; Section 257 MLRC Is Supervisory 1. Introduction In DHARAMPAL SHARMA...

No Presumption of Private Practice Income for Government Doctors; No Compensation for “Loss of Salary” When Salary Was Drawn

Date: Jul 8, 2026

No Presumption of Private Practice Income for Government Doctors; No Compensation for “Loss of Salary” When Salary Was Drawn Case: BAJAJ ALLIANCE INSURANCE CO. LTD. v. SHRI ROHIDAS AMBADAS CHAVAN AND...

Interim Gag Orders in Defamation: Truthful, Bona Fide Public-Interest Clarifications (Especially by Banks) Are Not Restrained

Date: Jun 16, 2026

Interim Gag Orders in Defamation: Truthful, Bona Fide Public-Interest Clarifications (Especially by Banks) Are Not Restrained Case: LILAVATI KIRTILAL MEHTA TRUST THROUGH PRASHANT MEHTA v. HDFC BANK...

Nexus-to-Syndicate as the Decisive Threshold for MCOCA: Delay, A‑Summary History, and 65B Defects Not Grounds for Quashment; Proceedings Quashed Only Where Nexus is Absent

Date: Jun 10, 2026

Nexus-to-Syndicate as the Decisive Threshold for MCOCA: Delay, A‑Summary History, and 65B Defects Not Grounds for Quashment; Proceedings Quashed Only Where Nexus is Absent Case: RAJAN BHAGWANDAS...

Article 21 Public Law Compensation for Death in State Mental Hospital: Adoption of Motor Accident Multiplier Method and Need-Based Top-Up

Date: Jun 9, 2026

Article 21 Public Law Compensation for Death in State Mental Hospital: Adoption of Motor Accident Multiplier Method and Need-Based Top-Up Case: SMT. NOORJAN SAMSHUDDIN BHANVADIYA AND ORS. v. THE...

Religious References, Dua/Amen, and “Dead Voters” Allegations: Strict Pleading Threshold for Corrupt Practice and Void-Vote Grounds in Election Petitions

Date: Jun 9, 2026

Religious References, Dua/Amen, and “Dead Voters” Allegations: Strict Pleading Threshold for Corrupt Practice and Void-Vote Grounds in Election Petitions 1) Introduction The decision in MUFTI...

Tenure “D” (Rule 43) Lands Are Class-I and Freely Transferable: No 75% Transfer Premium; Only NA Change-of-User Charge Sustainably Recoverable

Date: Jun 9, 2026

Tenure “D” (Rule 43) Lands Are Class-I and Freely Transferable: No 75% Transfer Premium; Only NA Change-of-User Charge Sustainably Recoverable 1) Introduction The Bombay High Court (Milind N. Jadhav,...