Airport Site Selection Is an Expert Policy Decision: Landowners Cannot Compel Adoption of an Alternative Site

Case: PANDIT SHIVAJI KUMBHARKAR AND ORS v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA THRU. SECRETARY AND ORS

Court: Bombay High Court, Civil Appellate Jurisdiction

Coram: Suman Shyam and Advait M. Sethna, JJ.

Date: 22 September 2026

Citation: 2026:BHC-AS:38753-DB

1. Introduction

This decision concerns the proposed Greenfield International Airport at Purandar, Pune, and the acquisition of agricultural land for its construction. The petitioners were agriculturists owning land in villages including Munjewadi, Ekatpur, Pargaon, Kumbharvalan, Vanpuri, Udachiwadi and Khanawadi. They challenged the authorities’ decision to locate the airport at “Site 1A” and sought to restrain the acquisition of their lands.

The petitioners argued that an alternative location, “Site 5A”, was technically superior, less disruptive, cheaper to develop and involved less fertile land. They contended that reverting to Site 1A after Site 5A had been examined was arbitrary and inadequately explained.

The respondents—the State of Maharashtra, the Union of India, the Maharashtra Airport Development Company Limited, the Airports Authority of India and the Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation—maintained that airport siting was an expert and policy determination. They also relied on the advanced stage of acquisition proceedings under the Maharashtra Industrial Development Act, 1961.

Principal issues

  • Whether the High Court could compare Site 1A with Site 5A and decide which was more suitable for the airport.
  • Whether reversion to Site 1A was arbitrary, unsafe or technically irrational.
  • Whether the land acquisition proceedings under the Maharashtra Industrial Development Act, 1961 were liable to be stopped.
  • Whether the availability of an allegedly less disruptive alternative site justified judicial interference.

2. Factual and Procedural Background

  • In 2016, the Airports Authority of India examined six sites and recommended Site 1A, subject to defence and other clearances.
  • The Ministry of Defence granted a conditional no-objection certificate for Site 1A in January 2018.
  • Site clearance followed from the competent civil aviation authorities, and the State approved acquisition of approximately 2,367 hectares in May 2018.
  • During 2020–2021, Site 5A was explored as an alternative. The Ministry of Defence granted it a conditional NOC, which was later cancelled.
  • Site 1A was restored or reaffirmed in May 2024.
  • In March 2025, Chapter VI of the Maharashtra Industrial Development Act, 1961 was applied to the relevant lands. Objections were invited and hearings were conducted under Section 32.
  • A final notification under Section 32(1) was issued on 9 February 2026 for approximately 1,216.7522 hectares.

3. Summary of the Judgment

The Bombay High Court dismissed the writ petition. It held that the choice of location for a major public infrastructure project such as an international airport is principally a technical and policy matter entrusted to expert and governmental authorities.

The Court found no material establishing that Site 5A had ever been finally selected. Its NOC had been cancelled, while Site 1A was subsequently restored and cleared. The petitioners had not demonstrated bad faith, colourable exercise of power, manifest arbitrariness, breach of mandatory statutory provisions, environmental non-compliance or any other recognised ground for judicial review.

A landowner’s assertion that another parcel would be cheaper, safer or less disruptive was held insufficient to permit the Court to substitute its assessment for that of technical agencies.

The Court also declined to interfere with the acquisition proceedings because statutory notifications had been issued, objections had been considered and the acquisition had reached an advanced stage. It nevertheless preserved the petitioners’ right to invoke statutory remedies concerning compensation, disbursement and individual instances of non-compliance.

4. Analysis

4.1 The governing principle

The central rule emerging from the decision is that airport site selection—including questions of alignment, safety, operational feasibility, connectivity, future expansion and the extent of land required—is an expert policy determination. Judicial review does not permit the High Court to conduct a comparative technical appraisal merely because affected landowners prefer another site.

Intervention remains possible where the decision is shown to be:

  • mala fide or taken in bad faith;
  • a colourable exercise of executive power;
  • manifestly arbitrary;
  • contrary to mandatory statutory provisions;
  • in breach of environmental requirements; or
  • otherwise demonstrably illegal.

The judgment therefore establishes deference, not immunity. Technical and policy decisions remain reviewable, but only on public-law grounds rather than on the Court’s view of which option is better.

4.2 Why Site 5A did not invalidate Site 1A

The petitioners’ case rested heavily on documents identifying advantages of Site 5A. The Court, however, distinguished between the exploration of an alternative and its final governmental adoption. Nothing on record showed that Site 5A had been conclusively selected. Its clearance was later cancelled, and Site 1A was restored.

The fact that an authority studies or temporarily clears an alternative does not create an enforceable right in landowners to insist upon that alternative. Nor does it, without more, establish that the ultimate decision is irrational.

4.3 Evidentiary burden on challengers

The Court considered the petitioners’ safety and feasibility concerns insufficiently supported. Multiple specialised agencies, including the Ministry of Defence and civil aviation authorities, had participated in the approval process. Mere disagreement with their assessment, speculative apprehensions or reliance on unauthenticated reports could not establish illegality.

The judgment signals that a successful challenge to a technical infrastructure decision must contain precise pleadings and cogent evidence linking the decision to a recognised ground of judicial review.

4.4 Public interest and individual property interests

The Court accepted that the petitioners were directly affected landowners. It did not deny their standing. Nevertheless, standing to challenge a decision does not confer a right to dictate the location of a public project.

Construction of a civil airport was regarded as serving a larger public purpose. The executive, having access to technical, financial, safety and planning information, was considered best placed to determine the land required. The Court therefore refused to balance competing sites afresh.

4.5 Land acquisition proceedings

The acquisition was undertaken under the Maharashtra Industrial Development Act, 1961. Chapter VI had been applied, notices were issued, objections were invited and considered, and a final notification under Section 32(1) had been published.

The petitioners had not pleaded sufficient facts establishing a specific statutory defect in that process. The proceedings had also reached an advanced stage. These considerations weighed against reopening the acquisition.

Importantly, the Court did not decide every possible individual acquisition grievance. Questions concerning compensation, its disbursement and particular failures of statutory compliance were expressly left open for appropriate proceedings under the statutory framework, including remedies relating to compensation under Section 33.

5. Precedents Cited

Alok Kotahwala & Ors. v. Jaipur Metro Rail Corporation Ltd. & Ors.

This was the most directly applied authority. It held that the availability of alternative government or private land does not permit courts to substitute their opinion for that of project-planning authorities. Matters such as alignment, connectivity, operational requirements, maintenance and future expansion require expert evaluation.

The Bombay High Court applied this reasoning to hold that Site 1A could not be displaced merely because Site 5A appeared more convenient to the petitioners.

State of Punjab v. Gurdial Singh

This decision recognises that the power to select land for a public purpose lies within the responsible discretion of the Government. Courts cannot invalidate a choice merely because they regard it as unwise. Intervention is justified where power is polluted by improper purposes or is otherwise legally void.

It supplied the doctrinal basis for distinguishing an allegedly “foolish” choice from an unlawful choice.

Sooraram Pratap Reddy v. Collector

This precedent states that the Government is ordinarily the best judge of whether an acquisition serves a public purpose. A writ court should not substitute its judgment for that of the Government in the absence of legal infirmity.

It reinforced the Court’s deference to governmental assessment of the land required for the Purandar project.

Balco Employees' Union (Regd.) v. Union Of India & Ors.

This case limits judicial review of policy choices. Courts do not examine whether a different policy would have been wiser, fairer, more scientific or more logical. Their function is to test legality, not policy wisdom.

The High Court relied on it to reject the invitation to decide whether Site 5A represented a better policy choice.

Narmada Bachao Andolan v. Union of India

This authority holds that decisions on whether to undertake an infrastructure project, what type of project to adopt and how it should be executed belong to the policy-making sphere. Courts may nevertheless ensure that laws are obeyed and fundamental rights are not unlawfully infringed.

Its ratio was directly applied to characterise airport siting as a policy matter while retaining review for illegality.

Union Of India v. Kushala Shetty & Ors.

The respondents cited this decision in support of judicial restraint concerning technical infrastructure and land-selection decisions. Although the High Court did not separately analyse it, it supported the broader proposition that courts should not redesign public projects in the absence of illegality or mala fides.

K.T. Plantation Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. State of Karnataka

The petitioners invoked this case to argue that deprivation of property under Article 300A must have lawful authority and a genuine public purpose. The High Court did not reject that proposition. It instead found that the acquisition was supported by statutory proceedings and that no specific illegality had been established.

Kolkata Municipal Corporation & Anr. v. Bimal Kumar Shah & Ors.

This authority was relied upon to emphasise constitutional protection against unlawful deprivation of property. The Court did not undertake a separate analysis of it because the petitioners’ principal case concerned comparative site suitability rather than a demonstrated absence of legal authority for acquisition.

6. Complex Concepts Simplified

Judicial review
The Court examines whether a decision was lawful, rational and procedurally proper. It does not decide whether it was the best possible decision.
Policy decision
A governmental choice involving technical, economic, administrative and public-interest considerations. Courts ordinarily defer to the executive in such matters.
Manifest arbitrariness
A decision so unreasonable, unexplained or capricious that it lacks a rational basis.
Mala fides
Bad faith, such as acting for an improper or dishonest purpose.
Colourable exercise of power
Using a lawful power as a disguise to achieve an unauthorised objective.
Eminent domain
The State’s power to compulsorily acquire private property for a public purpose, subject to constitutional and statutory safeguards.
Article 300A
The constitutional rule that no person may be deprived of property except by authority of law.
Vesting free from encumbrances
Upon the prescribed acquisition notification, title passes to the State without prior private claims or burdens continuing against the land, subject to statutory rights such as compensation.
Certiorari and mandamus
Certiorari is used to quash an unlawful decision; mandamus commands a public authority to perform a legal duty.

7. Potential Impact

  • Landowners challenging airports, highways, metro systems or similar projects cannot succeed merely by identifying another apparently preferable site.
  • Challenges must plead and prove a specific public-law defect, such as mala fides, statutory breach, environmental non-compliance or manifest arbitrariness.
  • Courts are likely to attach substantial weight to clearances issued by specialised technical agencies.
  • Exploration or provisional clearance of an alternative site does not amount to its final selection.
  • The advanced stage of an acquisition may weigh against discretionary relief, particularly where third-party, financial and administrative consequences have arisen.
  • The judgment does not prevent landowners from pursuing compensation or case-specific statutory objections.

8. Conclusion

The Bombay High Court reaffirmed the boundary between judicial review and executive policy-making. Courts may test the legality of an infrastructure decision, but they cannot act as appellate technical authorities and choose between competing project sites.

Because Site 5A had not been finally selected, Site 1A had received approvals, and no mala fides, manifest arbitrariness or statutory violation was established, the Court declined to interfere. The acquisition challenge was consequently dismissed, while individual remedies concerning statutory compliance and compensation were preserved.