Society NOC Cannot Be Imposed Without Statutory Authority for Registration of a Final Consent Decree
Case: SANJAY NARANG v. JOINT SUB-REGISTRAR CITY NO. 1 OF ASSURANCE MUMBAI
Court: Bombay High Court
Coram: Suman Shyam and Advait M. Sethna, JJ.
Date: 17 August 2026
1. Introduction
The Bombay High Court considered whether the Collector could insist upon a no-objection certificate from a co-operative housing society before permitting registration of a consent decree that operated as a conveyance of immovable property.
Sanjay Narang and Rachna Narang sought registration of a consent decree dated 16 December 2022 concerning commercial premises in Soona Mahal Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. The decree arose from consent terms between the petitioners and the former owners, Khorshed Tehemton Udwadia and Dr. Adi Nazir. It expressly declared that the consent terms would operate as a conveyance in favour of the petitioners.
Although the petitioners paid stamp duty of Rs.91,58,300 and the applicable registration charges, the registration authorities required them to obtain the Collector’s approval. The Collector, in turn, demanded a no-objection certificate from the Society. The Society declined to issue one. The petitioners therefore invoked Article 226 of the Constitution.
2. Factual and Procedural Background
- The dispute concerned a 186 sq. ft. shop known as “Pushp Milan” and adjoining restaurant premises measuring approximately 2,530 sq. ft.
- The former owners were members of the Society and held the relevant shares under Share Certificate No.101.
- An agreement to sell the shop was executed on 9 January 2018 in favour of Mars Enterprises & Hospitality Private Limited, a company promoted by the petitioners.
- Disputes resulted in Suit No.621 of 2019 before the Bombay High Court. The Society was joined only as a formal party, and no substantive relief was sought against it.
- The principal parties executed consent terms dated 13 December 2022. The suit was decreed in those terms on 16 December 2022.
- The consent decree was adjudicated for stamp duty, sealed on 12 June 2024 and forwarded for registration on 3 July 2024.
- The Sub-Registrar required the Collector’s no-objection because the building stood on land associated with the Collector.
- The Collector then required, among other documents, an NOC from the Society. The Society objected to the proposed transfer.
- During the writ proceedings, the petitioners obtained an order declaring them deemed members under Sections 22 and 23 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960. The Society’s challenge to that order remained pending.
3. Issues Before the Court
- Whether the Collector possessed statutory authority to require an NOC from the Society as a precondition to registration of the consent decree.
- Whether Section 37A of the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, 1966 justified that requirement.
- Whether the decree had been presented within the period prescribed by Section 23 of the Registration Act, 1908.
- Whether the final consent decree, expressly operating as a conveyance, was required to be implemented despite the Society’s objections.
4. Summary of the Judgment
The Court allowed the writ petition. It directed the Collector to decide the petitioners’ application dated 22 August 2024 without insisting upon an NOC from the Society. The Collector could require payment of the prescribed transfer fee and applicable premium so that the Sub-Registrar could register the consent decree.
The principal findings were:
- The consent terms unequivocally operated as a conveyance of the premises to the petitioners.
- The decree and the order recording the consent terms had attained finality because none of the respondents had challenged them.
- No statute, rule, regulation or notification authorising the Collector to insist upon the Society’s NOC was demonstrated.
- Section 37A of the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code did not, by itself, create such an NOC requirement.
- The authorities could collect lawful transfer fees and premium but could not create an additional administrative obstacle unsupported by law.
- The registration was sought within the applicable period under Section 23 of the Registration Act.
- The Society would not be held responsible by the Collector for non-issuance of an NOC.
- Questions concerning alleged encroachment were left open for determination in appropriate proceedings.
5. Analysis
5.1 Finality and effect of the consent decree
Clauses 3, 11 and 12 of the consent terms were decisive. They declared that the petitioners were in lawful possession, that the consent terms would operate as a conveyance, and that the petitioners would bear stamp duty, registration fees, transfer charges and other governmental levies.
Once the High Court decreed the suit in those terms, the settlement acquired both contractual and judicial force. It was no longer merely a private arrangement. The revenue authorities were consequently required to act in furtherance of the decree rather than impose an extraneous condition that prevented its implementation.
The Court described the authorities’ position as an “obstructionist approach” because it hindered execution of a legally binding decree without identifiable statutory support.
5.2 Administrative authorities cannot invent preconditions
The central principle is that a public authority must identify a legal source for every compulsory precondition it imposes. The fact that the property stood on land subject to governmental control did not automatically empower the Collector to demand the Society’s consent.
The Collector retained authority to examine the application, calculate transfer fees and premium, and enforce valid restrictions. What the Collector could not do was make the Society’s NOC a jurisdictional prerequisite when no enactment or notification prescribed it.
5.3 Section 37A of the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code
Section 37A regulates transactions involving Government and nazul land and recognises restrictions relating to sale, transfer, redevelopment and change of use. The State relied upon these restrictions to defend the Collector’s demand.
The Court rejected that argument. Neither Section 37A nor its legislative purpose established that a co-operative society’s NOC was mandatory before the decree could be registered. The judgment does not eliminate lawful governmental controls over such land; it holds only that those controls cannot be expanded into an NOC requirement without legal authority.
5.4 Registration Act, 1908
The Court accepted that Section 17 applied because the decree was intended to operate as a deed of conveyance transferring rights in immovable property. The respondents did not establish any applicable exclusion from the registration requirement.
The State’s objection under Section 23 was also rejected. The final decree was drawn and sealed on 12 June 2024 and forwarded for registration on 3 July 2024. On that chronology, the Court held that the prescribed four-month period had been complied with.
5.5 Government Resolution dated 7 July 2017
The Government Resolution enabled the District Collector to grant ex-post facto approval to specified transfers upon payment of prescribed charges. Since the petitioners were willing to pay the applicable transfer fee and premium, the Court found no justification for refusing to process their application.
The ruling therefore balances private rights and governmental revenue interests: the petitioners must discharge lawful financial liabilities, but the administration cannot impose an unauthorised consent requirement.
5.6 Separation of title, registration and society disputes
The judgment keeps distinct three matters that are often conflated:
- the effect of the consent decree as a conveyance;
- registration and payment of governmental charges; and
- membership, encroachment and internal society disputes.
The Society’s allegations of encroachment did not justify preventing registration. At the same time, the Court did not decide those allegations and expressly permitted them to be raised in appropriate proceedings. Registration therefore does not extinguish independent claims that were not adjudicated.
6. Precedents Cited
6.1 Aspi Chinoy line of authority
In Aspi Chinoy & Anr Vs. State of Maharashtra & Ors., the Bombay High Court rejected the Collector’s attempt to require persons transferring flats in buildings at Nariman Point and Cuffe Parade to obtain a prior certificate from the Collector. The decision established that governmental ownership or control of the underlying land does not, without more, authorise a prior-approval requirement for every subsequent flat transaction.
The ruling was affirmed when the Supreme Court dismissed the State’s appeal in State of Maharashtra & Ors. Vs. Aspi Chinoy & Anr.. The Supreme Court distinguished cases where land had been allotted directly to a co-operative society from cases where land was leased to a builder, flats were conveyed to private purchasers, and a society was later formed.
These were the principal precedents applied in the present case. They supported the conclusion that the Collector could not demand a prior NOC merely because of the governmental character of the underlying land.
6.2 Other authorities relied upon
The petitioners also relied upon the following decisions:
The judgment did not separately reproduce or analyse the facts and holdings of these authorities. It stated that their reasoning was reflected in its analysis to the extent necessary. Their collective role was therefore confirmatory: they supported the binding character and enforceability of court-approved settlements, the legal effect of decrees affecting property, and the principle that public authorities must respect rather than frustrate judicial orders.
In particular, Salkia Businessmen'S Association v. Howrah Municipal Corporation reinforces the obligation to honour and implement undertakings and settlements incorporated into judicial orders. The older property decisions formed part of the broader jurisprudence concerning the effect and registration of decrees dealing with immovable property. However, the present judgment rests primarily upon the consent decree’s express language, the absence of statutory authority for the NOC, and the Aspi Chinoy decisions.
7. Complex Concepts Simplified
- Consent decree
- A court decree based on terms agreed between the parties. It is both a settlement and an enforceable judicial order.
- Conveyance
- A legal instrument transferring ownership or an interest in immovable property from one person to another.
- No-objection certificate
- A statement that an authority or society does not object to a proposed transaction. Such a certificate can be made compulsory only where law authorises it.
- Nazul land
- Land held or administered by the Government, often subject to special conditions governing transfer or use.
- Ex-post facto approval
- Approval granted after a transaction has taken place, usually upon satisfaction of prescribed conditions and payment of fees.
- Premium and transfer fee
- Amounts lawfully payable to the Government or competent authority for approving or recording a transfer. They are distinct from an NOC.
- Finality of a decree
- A decree becomes final when it is not successfully appealed, reviewed or set aside. Administrative authorities cannot disregard it merely because they disagree with its consequences.
8. Impact of the Judgment
- Limits administrative discretion: Collectors and registration authorities must identify an express legal basis before demanding an NOC.
- Strengthens enforcement of consent decrees: Revenue procedures cannot be used to obstruct a final decree that expressly operates as a conveyance.
- Protects lawful governmental dues: Authorities may still recover prescribed transfer fees and premium and apply valid land restrictions.
- Separates registration from society membership: A pending membership or internal society dispute does not automatically prevent registration of an otherwise valid conveyance.
- Preserves independent disputes: Registration does not prevent later adjudication of encroachment or other claims in appropriate proceedings.
The ruling is not a blanket declaration that society consent is irrelevant in every property transaction. Its ratio is narrower: where a final consent decree operates as a conveyance, the Collector cannot insist on a society NOC unless a statute, rule or binding governmental instrument expressly authorises that requirement.
9. Conclusion
The Bombay High Court affirmed that administrative convenience cannot substitute for statutory authority. Once the consent decree had attained finality and expressly conveyed the premises to the petitioners, the revenue authorities were required to facilitate its lawful registration after collecting the prescribed charges.
The precedent establishes that a co-operative society’s NOC cannot be invented as an additional precondition to registration. The Collector must administer the law, recover legitimate dues and respect binding judicial decrees—not create obstacles unsupported by legislation.