state Case Commentaries

Montana Sentencing Courts Cannot Require Freestanding Compliance Audit Hearings Without Statutory Authority

Date: Nov 11, 2026

Montana Sentencing Courts Cannot Require Freestanding Compliance Audit Hearings Without Statutory Authority Case: State v. D. Rogers, 2026 MT 260, DA 24-0560 Court: Supreme Court of Montana Decided:...

Distinct 911-Texting Episodes Support Separate Convictions, and Communications-Privacy Protections Extend to Dispatchers

Date: Nov 11, 2026

Distinct 911-Texting Episodes Support Separate Convictions, and Communications-Privacy Protections Extend to Dispatchers Case: State v. D. Savage Jr., 2026 MT 264 Court: Supreme Court of Montana...

Prior Representation in the Same Case Requires Recusal and Establishes Good Cause to Withdraw a Guilty Plea

Date: Nov 11, 2026

Prior Representation in the Same Case Requires Recusal and Establishes Good Cause to Withdraw a Guilty Plea Case: State v. Notafraid Jr., 2026 MT 263 Court: Supreme Court of Montana Decided: November...

Replacement-Cost Restitution for Damaged Equipment: A Nonprecedential Application of Montana Law

Date: Nov 11, 2026

Replacement-Cost Restitution for Damaged Equipment: A Nonprecedential Application of Montana Law Case: State v. R. Taylor, 2026 MT 265N, No. DA 24-0715 Court: Supreme Court of Montana Decided:...

Before Final Decree, Unauthorized Water Use Does Not Automatically Establish Abandonment

Date: Nov 11, 2026

Before Final Decree, Unauthorized Water Use Does Not Automatically Establish Abandonment Case: YC Properties v. Connolly, 2026 MT 261 Court: Supreme Court of Montana Decided: November 4, 2026...

Hospital Admission and Room Numbers Are Health Records Under Minnesota Law

Date: Nov 11, 2026

Hospital Admission and Room Numbers Are Health Records Under Minnesota Law Case: Justin Holtzbauer v. Allina Health System Court: Supreme Court of Minnesota Decided: November 4, 2026 Opinion by:...

Minnesota Felony Tax Evasion Requires a Purpose to Deceive, Not a Separate Affirmative Act

Date: Nov 11, 2026

Minnesota Felony Tax Evasion Requires a Purpose to Deceive, Not a Separate Affirmative Act Case: State of Minnesota v. Daniel Roy O'Day Court: Supreme Court of Minnesota Decided: November 4, 2026...

Judicial Disqualification Requires More Than Former Defense-Firm Affiliation or Delayed Discovery

Date: Nov 11, 2026

Judicial Disqualification Requires More Than Former Defense-Firm Affiliation or Delayed Discovery Case: James Guzman v. State of Florida Court: Supreme Court of Florida Case number: SC2024-1191...

Informant Reliability and Lost Bodycam Evidence: Totality of Circumstances and Prejudice Govern

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Informant Reliability and Lost Bodycam Evidence: Totality of Circumstances and Prejudice Govern Case: State of West Virginia v. Curtis Lynn Morgan Court: Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia...

West Virginia Medical Malpractice Verdicts Must Be Reduced by Settlements Even When Settling Parties Are Assigned No Fault

Date: Nov 6, 2026

West Virginia Medical Malpractice Verdicts Must Be Reduced by Settlements Even When Settling Parties Are Assigned No Fault Case: Thomas A. Cummings v. Ward J. Paine, MD, and Benjamin Klennert, P.A....

Unsafe-Building Demolition and Summary Judgment: Factual Disputes Must Be Material and Properly Developed

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Unsafe-Building Demolition and Summary Judgment: Factual Disputes Must Be Material and Properly Developed Case: New China Restaurant, Inc. and Philip Dy Chin v. City of Charleston Court: Supreme...

Wrongful Disqualification of an Elected Prosecutor Can Justify Prohibition Even When a Special Prosecutor Could Proceed

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Wrongful Disqualification of an Elected Prosecutor Can Justify Prohibition Even When a Special Prosecutor Could Proceed Case: State of West Virginia ex rel. State of West Virginia v. The Honorable C....

West Virginia Protective Orders: Courts Must Hear and Explain Decisions on Requested Economic Relief

Date: Nov 6, 2026

West Virginia Protective Orders: Courts Must Hear and Explain Decisions on Requested Economic Relief Case: Carmen Ann Riley v. Terry Allen Riley, No. 25-44 Court: Supreme Court of Appeals of West...

Nevada Arbitration: Statutory Delegation of Contract Enforceability and Direct-Benefit Estoppel for Nonsignatories

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Nevada Arbitration: Statutory Delegation of Contract Enforceability and Direct-Benefit Estoppel for Nonsignatories Case: LEGACY FUNERAL HOLDINGS OF NEV., LLC v. OUZENIAN (CIVIL) Citation: 142 Nev.,...

Sexual-Offense Convictions Without Physical Evidence: Victim Testimony and the Jury’s Role in Assessing Credibility

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Sexual-Offense Convictions Without Physical Evidence: Victim Testimony and the Jury’s Role in Assessing Credibility Case: State of West Virginia v. John L., No. 23-749 Court: Supreme Court of Appeals...

Knowing Refusal of a Continuance Bars Plain-Error Review: Waiver, Autopsy Evidence, and Inconsistent Verdicts

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Knowing Refusal of a Continuance Bars Plain-Error Review: Waiver, Autopsy Evidence, and Inconsistent Verdicts Case: State of West Virginia v. Jeffrey Todd Hoskins, No. 23-154 Court: Supreme Court of...

Prompt Notice and Cessation of Practice Guide Retroactive Reciprocal Attorney Suspensions

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Prompt Notice and Cessation of Practice Guide Retroactive Reciprocal Attorney Suspensions Case: IN RE: DISCIPLINE OF DAVID EDWARD WALTERS (BAR MATTER) Citation: 142 Nev., Advance Opinion 69 Court:...

Continuing Pain Does Not Bar Termination of Temporary Total Disability Benefits After Maximum Medical Improvement

Date: Nov 5, 2026

Continuing Pain Does Not Bar Termination of Temporary Total Disability Benefits After Maximum Medical Improvement Case: David Martinez v. State of Wyoming, Ex Rel. Department of Workforce Services,...

Specific Jurisdiction Reaches Out-of-State Harm Connected to an Oklahoma-Centered Ownership Agreement

Date: Nov 5, 2026

Specific Jurisdiction Reaches Out-of-State Harm Connected to an Oklahoma-Centered Ownership Agreement SCHRAMMEL & WARD v. COLYER HEREFORDS AND ANGUS, INC., 2026 OK 78 — Supreme Court of Oklahoma...

Probable Cause Determinations Are Not Immediately Appealable: State v. Miller

Date: Nov 5, 2026

Probable Cause Determinations Are Not Immediately Appealable: Postconviction Review Remains the Proper Route Case: State v. Miller (Order on Motion), 355 Conn. 936 (SC 21286) Court: Supreme Court of...