state Case Commentaries

Hoskin v. Wall: Rule 52(c) Bench-Trial Judgment on Partial Findings Requires Admissible Proof, Preserved Evidentiary Error, and Cohesive Appellate Briefing

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Hoskin v. Wall: Rule 52(c) Bench-Trial Judgment on Partial Findings Requires Admissible Proof, Preserved Evidentiary Error, and Cohesive Appellate Briefing Nonprecedential posture. The Court...

Reaffirmation of Little/Johnston: Appellate Courts Must Review Contested Evidence In Camera Before Assessing Exculpatory Value in Post-Conviction Litigation

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Reaffirmation of Little/Johnston: Appellate Courts Must Review Contested Evidence In Camera Before Assessing Exculpatory Value in Post-Conviction Litigation Case: Mathis v. State, 2026 MT 211 (Mont....

Therapy-Based Visitation Pauses and Late-Stage Compliance Do Not Defeat Termination After Prolonged Out-of-Home Placement (Mont. YINC)

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Therapy-Based Visitation Pauses and Late-Stage Compliance Do Not Defeat Termination After Prolonged Out-of-Home Placement (Mont. YINC) Case: Matter of H.T., S.T., & D.L., YINCC, 2026 MT 213N (Mont....

Defendant’s Motion to Reset Trial “at the Court’s Earliest Convenience” Constitutes a Postponement that Defeats § 46-13-401(2) Six-Month Dismissal

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Defendant’s Motion to Reset Trial “at the Court’s Earliest Convenience” Constitutes a Postponement that Defeats § 46-13-401(2) Six-Month Dismissal Introduction State v. J. Kelly (Mont. Sup. Ct. 2026...

Anti-SLAPP Prong One in Nevada: Contradictory Evidence Requires a Factual Good-Faith Showing—Mere Denial Is Not Enough

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Anti-SLAPP Prong One in Nevada: Contradictory Evidence Requires a Factual Good-Faith Showing—Mere Denial Is Not Enough I. Introduction In JET COMMERCIAL CONSTR., LLC v. N. AM. INS. AGENCY OF LAWTON,...

Souza v. Nago: Tie-Breaker-by-Lot Procedures Are HAPA “Rules,” and a Tie Plus Unresolvable Overage Requires a New Primary Election

Date: Sep 11, 2026

Souza v. Nago: Tie-Breaker-by-Lot Procedures Are HAPA “Rules,” and a Tie Plus Unresolvable Overage Requires a New Primary Election Introduction Souza v. Nago (Supreme Court of Hawaiʻi, Sept. 4, 2026)...

“Pending” Includes the Rule 59(e) Post‑Judgment Window: CNMI Courts Must Apply PL 23‑17 Survivorship Retroactively to Nonfinal Cases

Date: Sep 10, 2026

“Pending” Includes the Rule 59(e) Post‑Judgment Window: CNMI Courts Must Apply PL 23‑17 Survivorship Retroactively to Nonfinal Cases 1. Introduction Deleon Guerrero v. St. Jude Renal Care Facility,...

State Need Not Prove Provocation Exception Once It Disproves Any Element of Self-Defense

Date: Sep 9, 2026

State Need Not Prove Provocation Exception Once It Disproves Any Element of Self-Defense Introduction In State v. Guerrero (Conn. Sept. 8, 2026), the Connecticut Supreme Court affirmed a murder...

“Place of Employment Address” Means the Physical Worksite Under R.C. 2950.05(F)(2): No Vagueness As Applied to Multi-Week Offsite Assignments

Date: Sep 9, 2026

“Place of Employment Address” Means the Physical Worksite Under R.C. 2950.05(F)(2): No Vagueness As Applied to Multi-Week Offsite Assignments 1. Introduction In State v. Smith, Slip Opinion No....

Missouri Referendum Power Extends to Congressional Redistricting Acts: “Any Act of the General Assembly” Means Any Act

Date: Sep 9, 2026

Missouri Referendum Power Extends to Congressional Redistricting Acts: “Any Act of the General Assembly” Means Any Act 1. Introduction In von Glahn vs. Hoskins (Mo. banc Sept. 3, 2026), the Supreme...

Harris v. Hoskins: Certificates of Insufficiency Must State Specific Reasons; Secretary of State Cannot Vacate and Re-Certify an Initiative Ballot Title

Date: Sep 9, 2026

Harris v. Hoskins: Certificates of Insufficiency Must State Specific Reasons; Secretary of State Cannot Vacate and Re-Certify an Initiative Ballot Title 1. Introduction In Harris v. Hoskins (Mo. banc...

Knighten v. VitalCore: McArn Wrongful-Discharge Claims Require Reported Conduct Warranting Criminal Penalties; Swindol Does Not Broaden McArn

Date: Sep 9, 2026

Knighten v. VitalCore: McArn Wrongful-Discharge Claims Require Reported Conduct Warranting Criminal Penalties; Swindol Does Not Broaden McArn 1. Introduction In Knighten v. VitalCore Health...

De Novo Review of Ambiguously Marked “Logo Ballots” in Alabama Election Contests

Date: Sep 9, 2026

De Novo Review of Ambiguously Marked “Logo Ballots” in Alabama Election Contests 1. Introduction Maxwell “Mike” Blackmon v. Randy Brock (Appeal from Conecuh Circuit Court: CV-22-6) is an Alabama...

Ecclesiastical-Abstention Is Not Jurisdictional Where Neutral Principles Can Decide Church-Property Deed Validity (and § 10A-17-1.06’s Statement-of-Authority Requirements)

Date: Sep 9, 2026

Ecclesiastical-Abstention Is Not Jurisdictional Where Neutral Principles Can Decide Church-Property Deed Validity (and § 10A-17-1.06’s Statement-of-Authority Requirements) 1. Introduction Cassandra...

Judicially Enforceable “Clear and Concise” Yes/No Effect Statements: Substantial-Compliance Review Under Idaho Code § 34-1810(1)(b)

Date: Sep 8, 2026

Judicially Enforceable “Clear and Concise” Yes/No Effect Statements: Substantial-Compliance Review Under Idaho Code § 34-1810(1)(b) I. Introduction Idahoans United v. McGrane/Labrador [SUBSTITUTE] is...

Souza v. Nago: Tie Elections Require Accounted Ballots and Promulgated “Lot” Procedures; Courts May Order a Completion Election Under HRS § 11-175

Date: Sep 7, 2026

Tie Elections Require Accounted Ballots and Promulgated “Lot” Procedures; Courts May Order a Completion Election Under HRS § 11-175 I. Introduction Souza v. Nago (Haw. Sept. 4, 2026) is a...

State v. Cook: CPS-Fear Statements as Inextricably Intertwined Evidence and Strict Specificity for Ineffective-Assistance Claims on Direct Appeal

Date: Sep 6, 2026

State v. Cook: CPS-Fear Statements as Inextricably Intertwined Evidence and Strict Specificity for Ineffective-Assistance Claims on Direct Appeal Case: State v. Cook, 322 Neb. 114 (Neb. Sept. 4,...

Setoff in Probate Requires an Enforceable Debt Owed to the Estate; “Shall Not Collect” Eliminates Setoff

Date: Sep 6, 2026

Setoff in Probate Requires an Enforceable Debt Owed to the Estate; “Shall Not Collect” Eliminates Setoff Case: In re Estate of Mueller (Kan. 2026-09-04) Court: Supreme Court of Kansas Core holding...

Byrd v. Coffey: Preponderance Standard Governs Declaratory Judgments Interpreting Ambiguous Deeds Before Applying Quiet-Title Burdens

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Byrd v. Coffey: Preponderance Standard Governs Declaratory Judgments Interpreting Ambiguous Deeds Before Applying Quiet-Title Burdens Supreme Court of Idaho (Sept. 4, 2026) 1. Introduction Byrd v....

Unscheduled Lease-Option Rights Remain Bankruptcy Estate Property, Defeating Debtor Standing in Idaho

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Unscheduled Lease-Option Rights Remain Bankruptcy Estate Property, Defeating Debtor Standing in Idaho Case: Conger v. Clark (Idaho Sup. Ct. Sept. 4, 2026) | Court: Supreme Court of Idaho 1....