state Case Commentaries

Idaho Supreme Court Requires Accurate, Clear, and Concise “Yes/No Effect” Ballot Statements Under I.C. § 34-1810(1)(b) and Confirms Extraordinary-Writ Review

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Idaho Supreme Court Requires Accurate, Clear, and Concise “Yes/No Effect” Ballot Statements Under I.C. § 34-1810(1)(b) and Confirms Extraordinary-Writ Review 1. Introduction Case: Idahoans United v....

Kuehn v. Evnen: No Imputation of Notarial Defects Across Petition Pages; Discretionary Refusal to Draw Fifth Amendment Adverse Inferences in Initiative Litigation

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Kuehn v. Evnen: No Imputation of Notarial Defects Across Petition Pages; Discretionary Refusal to Draw Fifth Amendment Adverse Inferences in Initiative Litigation I. Introduction Kuehn v. Evnen (322...

Rogers v. Moll: Kansas Affirms “Instructions as a Whole” Can Satisfy Causation Without a Standalone Definition—and Flags PIK’s “Fault” Framing in Single-Defendant Negligence Trials

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Rogers v. Moll: Kansas Affirms “Instructions as a Whole” Can Satisfy Causation Without a Standalone Definition—and Flags PIK’s “Fault” Framing in Single-Defendant Negligence Trials 1. Introduction...

State v. Barnes: Plain-View “Immediately Apparent” Probable Cause for a Smoked-Down Blunt and General Consent to Search a Person Encompasses Pocket Searches

Date: Sep 5, 2026

State v. Barnes: Plain-View “Immediately Apparent” Probable Cause for a Smoked-Down Blunt and General Consent to Search a Person Encompasses Pocket Searches I. Introduction In State v. Barnes (Kan....

No Double Presentence Credit Across Separate Dockets When Confinement Is Attributable to Probation Revocation

Date: Sep 5, 2026

No Double Presentence Credit Across Separate Dockets When Confinement Is Attributable to Probation Revocation Case: Yzail Ashton Gauna v. The State of Wyoming, 2026 WY 97 (Wyo. Sept. 3, 2026) Court:...

Sedillo v. State: Idaho Constitutional Double Jeopardy Applies the Pleading Theory and Requires Merger of Theft into Robbery When the Same Taking Is Charged

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Sedillo v. State: Idaho Constitutional Double Jeopardy Applies the Pleading Theory and Requires Merger of Theft into Robbery When the Same Taking Is Charged I. Introduction In Sedillo v. State (Idaho...

No Double Credit for Jail Time Across Separate Dockets Unless Confinement Was Solely for Unposted Bond

Date: Sep 5, 2026

No Double Credit for Jail Time Across Separate Dockets Unless Confinement Was Solely for Unposted Bond Case: Yzail Ashton Gauna v. The State of Wyoming, 2026 WY 97 (Wyo. Sept. 3, 2026) 1....

Nonrecourse Clauses in Confidentiality Agreements Bar Tortious-Interference Claims Against Nonparty Affiliates Absent Bad-Faith Conduct Unrelated to Legitimate Economic Self-Interest

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Nonrecourse Clauses in Confidentiality Agreements Bar Tortious-Interference Claims Against Nonparty Affiliates Absent Bad-Faith Conduct Unrelated to Legitimate Economic Self-Interest 1. Introduction...

Memoranda of Payment Do Not Satisfy RSA 281-A:55-a, II Notice of a “Possible Claim” Against the Special Fund

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Memoranda of Payment Do Not Satisfy RSA 281-A:55-a, II Notice of a “Possible Claim” Against the Special Fund Case: Appeal of Comm'r of N.H. Dep't of Labor, Cite: 2026 N.H. 34 Court: Supreme Court of...

State v. Sarria (375 Or 516) — ORS 133.076 Requires a Peace-Officer-Issued (Not Court-Issued) Criminal Citation; Outdoor Media Limits New Procedural Affirmances in Conditional-Plea Appeals

Date: Sep 5, 2026

State v. Sarria (375 Or 516) — ORS 133.076 Requires a Peace-Officer-Issued (Not Court-Issued) Criminal Citation; Outdoor Media Limits New Procedural Affirmances in Conditional-Plea Appeals I....

No Due Process Error from Reasonable Trial Time Limits Absent Objection or Prejudice; Unsworn Post-Trial Submissions Properly Excluded

Date: Sep 5, 2026

No Due Process Error from Reasonable Trial Time Limits Absent Objection or Prejudice; Unsworn Post-Trial Submissions Properly Excluded 1. Introduction Bryan Hutcheson v. Haley Frano and Kenneth Frano...

Option-to-Purchase Contracts: No Implied Right to Delay Closing to Challenge a Contractually-Required MAI Appraisal; Appraisal-Critique Experts Must Satisfy V.R.E. 702

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Option-to-Purchase Contracts: No Implied Right to Delay Closing to Challenge a Contractually-Required MAI Appraisal; Appraisal-Critique Experts Must Satisfy V.R.E. 702 Introduction Jamaica Cottage...

Relief-from-Abuse Orders May Rest on Circumstantial Proof of Nonaccidental Injury and a Parent’s Acts or Omissions Failing to Protect a Child

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Relief-from-Abuse Orders May Rest on Circumstantial Proof of Nonaccidental Injury and a Parent’s Acts or Omissions Failing to Protect a Child Note on authority: This decision is an Entry Order issued...

Financial and Logistical Realities May Be Weighed in Out-of-State Parent-Child Contact—§ 650 “Maximum Contact” Does Not Eliminate Trial-Court Discretion

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Financial and Logistical Realities May Be Weighed in Out-of-State Parent-Child Contact—§ 650 “Maximum Contact” Does Not Eliminate Trial-Court Discretion 1. Introduction Karissa Lashley v. Jacob...

Termination of Parental Rights: A Loving Bond Does Not Override the Child’s Need for Permanency When Other Best-Interest Factors Favor Termination

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Termination of Parental Rights: A Loving Bond Does Not Override the Child’s Need for Permanency When Other Best-Interest Factors Favor Termination Introduction Case: In re R.W., Juvenile (C.H.,...

Intervenor Standing Limits: Neighbors Cannot Appeal PUC Exclusion of Municipal Recommendations in § 248a CPG Proceedings

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Intervenor Standing Limits: Neighbors Cannot Appeal PUC Exclusion of Municipal Recommendations in § 248a CPG Proceedings I. Introduction Case: In re Petition of Industrial Tower and Wireless LLC...

Post-Judgment Business Setbacks Are Not “Newly Discovered Evidence” Under VR.C.P. 60(b)(2) in Divorce; Attorney’s Fees May Be Awarded for Meritless Relitigation

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Post-Judgment Business Setbacks Are Not “Newly Discovered Evidence” Under VR.C.P. 60(b)(2) in Divorce; Attorney’s Fees May Be Awarded for Meritless Relitigation 1. Introduction Case: Alison Beckwith...

De Novo Supreme Court Review of Attorney Sanctions Under Rule 9 § 33.1(d) to Ensure Statewide Uniformity

Date: Sep 5, 2026

De Novo Supreme Court Review of Attorney Sanctions Under Rule 9 § 33.1(d) to Ensure Statewide Uniformity Case: Fred C. Dance v. Board of Professional Responsibility of the Supreme Court of Tennessee...

Tumultuous Conduct Under 13 V.S.A. § 1026a: Loud, Confrontational Door-and-Window Banging Supports Aggravated Disorderly Conduct

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Tumultuous Conduct Under 13 V.S.A. § 1026a: Loud, Confrontational Door-and-Window Banging Supports Aggravated Disorderly Conduct Introduction In State v. Carl Holcomb, Jr. (Vt. Sept. 4, 2026) (entry...

Impaired Breathing as “Serious Bodily Injury” Under Vermont’s Aggravated Domestic Assault Statute; No Plain Error in MPC-Style Recklessness Instruction

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Impaired Breathing as “Serious Bodily Injury” Under Vermont’s Aggravated Domestic Assault Statute; No Plain Error in MPC-Style Recklessness Instruction Case: State v. Kisha Parson (Vt. Sup. Ct.,...