federal Case Commentaries

No Plain-Error Relief for § 1028A Mandatory Minimum Home-Detention Requests Absent Controlling Authority

Date: Aug 21, 2026

No Plain-Error Relief for § 1028A Mandatory Minimum Home-Detention Requests Absent Controlling Authority Case: United States v. Allen Pendergrass (11th Cir. Aug. 19, 2026) (per curiam, not for...

Certification on Indiana’s “One Action” Statute: Applicability to Mortgage Guaranties and Enforceability of Waiver

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Certification on Indiana’s “One Action” Statute: Applicability to Mortgage Guaranties and Enforceability of Waiver 1. Introduction Merchants Bank of Indiana v. David Craik (7th Cir. Aug. 19, 2026)...

FIRREA Succession Clause Does Not Transfer Investors’ Rule 10b-5 Purchase-and-Sale Claims to the FDIC; No FIRREA Exhaustion for Third-Party Securities Claims

Date: Aug 21, 2026

FIRREA Succession Clause Does Not Transfer Investors’ Rule 10b-5 Purchase-and-Sale Claims to the FDIC; No FIRREA Exhaustion for Third-Party Securities Claims Introduction Sjunde AP-Fonden v. FDIC (2d...

Twenty-Sixth Amendment Requires Age-Neutral Access to State-Provided Voting Methods (No-Excuse Absentee-by-Mail)

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Twenty-Sixth Amendment Requires Age-Neutral Access to State-Provided Voting Methods (No-Excuse Absentee-by-Mail) Case: Trudy Grant v. Conway Belangia (No. 25-1413) — United States Court of Appeals...

Qualified Immunity for Threat-Based Arrests Supported by a Disinterested Witness Report and the Suspect’s Admission; Narrow Use of Pendent Appellate Jurisdiction

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Qualified Immunity for Threat-Based Arrests Supported by a Disinterested Witness Report and the Suspect’s Admission; Narrow Use of Pendent Appellate Jurisdiction Case: Bonds v. Woodall (No. 25-60462)...

Proffer-Waiver Expansion: Opening Statements That Advance Contradictory Factual Theories Trigger Rebuttal Use of Proffer Admissions

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Proffer-Waiver Expansion: Opening Statements That Advance Contradictory Factual Theories Trigger Rebuttal Use of Proffer Admissions Case: United States v. Jose Tavares (No. 25-1489) (3d Cir. Aug. 17,...

Mann Act § 2422(a) Covers “Johns” Who Financially Induce Interstate Travel for Prostitution; Self-Representation May Be Revoked for Waiver by Conduct

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Mann Act § 2422(a) Covers “Johns” Who Financially Induce Interstate Travel for Prostitution; Self-Representation May Be Revoked for Waiver by Conduct Case: United States v. Jose Torres (3d Cir. Aug....

Bad-Faith Requirement for § 1983 Evidence-Fabrication Claims Arising from State Ethics Investigations

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Bad-Faith Requirement for § 1983 Evidence-Fabrication Claims Arising from State Ethics Investigations 1. Introduction In Ernest N. Finley, Jr. v. Thomas Albritton (11th Cir. Aug. 17, 2026), Chief...

Residual-Exception Admission of Unsworn Recantation Letters to Defeat Grand-Jury Probable Cause at Summary Judgment

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Residual-Exception Admission of Unsworn Recantation Letters to Defeat Grand-Jury Probable Cause at Summary Judgment I. Introduction Batista-Reyes v. Paul (2d Cir. Aug. 17, 2026) arises from a 1993...

Broad Catchall Authority Under 18 U.S.C. § 3583(d): “Pay-if-able” Treatment-Cost Contributions as Valid Special Conditions of Supervised Release

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Broad Catchall Authority Under 18 U.S.C. § 3583(d): “Pay-if-able” Treatment-Cost Contributions as Valid Special Conditions of Supervised Release I. Introduction In United States v. Williams (10th...

Brown v. Wallace: Qualified-Immunity Denial at the Pleading Stage When Key Fourth Amendment Justification Facts Are Unknown; Reasonable Suspicion Minimum for Visual Body-Cavity Searches Outside Jail Intake

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Brown v. Wallace: Qualified-Immunity Denial at the Pleading Stage When Key Fourth Amendment Justification Facts Are Unknown; Reasonable Suspicion Minimum for Visual Body-Cavity Searches Outside Jail...

Strickland Prejudice in Late-Stage Plea Advice Claims: No § 2255 Hearing When the Record Forecloses Acceptance and a Lower Outcome

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Strickland Prejudice in Late-Stage Plea Advice Claims: No § 2255 Hearing When the Record Forecloses Acceptance and a Lower Outcome I. Introduction In Derek Fields v. United States (7th Cir. Aug. 17,...

Removal Stays Are Provisional: Petitioners Must Continuously Prove All Nken Factors, Including Jurisdiction and Procedural Viability

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Removal Stays Are Provisional: Petitioners Must Continuously Prove All Nken Factors, Including Jurisdiction and Procedural Viability Case: Jose Aristy-Rosa v. Attorney General United States of...

Nonpayment of Arbitral Filing Fees After AAA Warnings Constitutes FAA § 3 Default/Waiver Decidable by Courts

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Nonpayment of Arbitral Filing Fees After AAA Warnings Constitutes FAA § 3 Default/Waiver Decidable by Courts Introduction In 5-Star General Store v. American Express Company (1st Cir. Aug. 19, 2026),...

Public Trial Protocol Disclosures Negate “Half-Truth” Liability for Safety-Event Statements in Securities Fraud Claims

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Public Trial Protocol Disclosures Negate “Half-Truth” Liability for Safety-Event Statements in Securities Fraud Claims 1. Introduction In Re: Apellis Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Securities Litigation is a...

Defining “Construction and Design of Improvements” Under the Springfield Water Special Act: Fact-Specific PWA Coverage and No Metcalf Incompatibility

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Defining “Construction and Design of Improvements” Under the Springfield Water Special Act: Fact-Specific PWA Coverage and No Metcalf Incompatibility Case: Nicholls v. Veolia Water Contract...

Rule 37 Sanctions and Forfeiture After Remand: Jurisdictional Discovery Over a Relief Defendant Proceeds Absent Timely Objection

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Rule 37 Sanctions and Forfeiture After Remand: Jurisdictional Discovery Over a Relief Defendant Proceeds Absent Timely Objection I. Introduction SEC v. Gastauer (1st Cir. Aug. 19, 2026) arises from...

Equitable Tolling for Motions to Reopen Requires Explained, Continuous Diligence—FOIA Timing and “I Didn’t Know” Are Not Enough

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Equitable Tolling for Motions to Reopen Requires Explained, Continuous Diligence—FOIA Timing and “I Didn’t Know” Are Not Enough 1. Introduction In Jhonny Castiblanco-Manrique v. U.S. Attorney General...

K-9 Deployment During In-Home Warrant Arrest Is Objectively Reasonable When Officers Give Repeated Warnings, Face Prolonged Noncompliance, and Release the Dog Promptly After Handcuffing

Date: Aug 21, 2026

K-9 Deployment During In-Home Warrant Arrest Is Objectively Reasonable When Officers Give Repeated Warnings, Face Prolonged Noncompliance, and Release the Dog Promptly After Handcuffing Case:...

Florida Implied Covenant Claims Require an Identified Breach of an Express Contract Term (and Account-Closure Discretion Defeats “Arbitrary” Closure Theories)

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Florida Implied Covenant Claims Require an Identified Breach of an Express Contract Term (and Account-Closure Discretion Defeats “Arbitrary” Closure Theories) I. Introduction In Sam Lewis v. JPMorgan...