balancing-first-amendment-rights- Case Commentaries

Seniority-Plan Changes Are Discrete Title VII Acts Triggering the 180-Day EEOC Clock; Speculative Race Inferences and a Single Non-Racial Text Cannot Plead Discrimination or Hostile Environment

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Seniority-Plan Changes Are Discrete Title VII Acts Triggering the 180-Day EEOC Clock; Speculative Race Inferences and a Single Non-Racial Text Cannot Plead Discrimination or Hostile Environment 1....

People v. Harrell (3d Dept 2026): Constructive Possession and Statutory Intent Presumption Sustain Weapon Convictions; Belated Discovery Does Not Invalidate a COC Absent Lack of Due Diligence

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Constructive Possession Plus Penal Law § 265.15(4) Presumption Can Prove CPW 2°; a Single Belated Disclosure Does Not Invalidate a COC Without a Due-Diligence Failure 1. Introduction People v Harrell...

Faxed DME Orders and OMIG Recoupment: DME Policy Guidelines as Non‑SAPA Interpretive Directives and the Enforceable “Wet Signature” Requirement (Audit-Period Compliance Controls)

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Faxed DME Orders and OMIG Recoupment: DME Policy Guidelines as Non‑SAPA Interpretive Directives and the Enforceable “Wet Signature” Requirement (Audit-Period Compliance Controls) 1. Introduction...

Billed Hourly Rates Presumptively Set the Lodestar in Nevada Civil-Contempt Fee Awards Under NRS 22.100(3)

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Billed Hourly Rates Presumptively Set the Lodestar in Nevada Civil-Contempt Fee Awards Under NRS 22.100(3) 1. Introduction Lytle Trust v. Gerry R. Zobrist and Jolin G. Zobrist Family Trust (142 Nev.,...

Custodial-Parent Kidnapping in New York: Evasive Out-of-State Secreting Supports “Abduction,” Defeats Penal Law § 135.30, and Establishes Territorial Jurisdiction When Intent Manifests In-State

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Custodial-Parent Kidnapping in New York: Evasive Out-of-State Secreting Supports “Abduction,” Defeats Penal Law § 135.30, and Establishes Territorial Jurisdiction When Intent Manifests In-State 1....

No “Diligent Efforts” Duty in Social Services Law § 384-b Abandonment Proceedings; Valid Pro Se Waiver Requires a Searching Inquiry

Date: Jul 3, 2026

No “Diligent Efforts” Duty in Social Services Law § 384-b Abandonment Proceedings; Valid Pro Se Waiver Requires a Searching Inquiry Case: Matter of Wanye D. (Quincy D.), 2026 NY Slip Op 04244 (App....

“Crime Victim” Under Executive Law § 632-a Is Not Limited to Physically Injured Victims: Psychological Harm and “Subject of the Felonious Conduct” Suffice

Date: Jul 3, 2026

“Crime Victim” Under Executive Law § 632-a Is Not Limited to Physically Injured Victims: Psychological Harm and “Subject of the Felonious Conduct” Suffice 1. Introduction Matter of New York State...

HRS § 291C-12(a) “Involved in a Collision” Includes Non-Contact Pursuit; Vagueness Challenges Are As-Applied Only; Bill of Particulars Can Supply Constitutionally Adequate Notice

Date: Jul 3, 2026

HRS § 291C-12(a) “Involved in a Collision” Includes Non-Contact Pursuit; Vagueness Challenges Are As-Applied Only; Bill of Particulars Can Supply Constitutionally Adequate Notice Case: State v....

ICWA Termination Requires Culturally Grounded Expert Testimony Tethered to Case-Specific Parental Conduct

Date: Jul 3, 2026

ICWA Termination Requires Culturally Grounded Expert Testimony Tethered to Case-Specific Parental Conduct 1. Introduction Viva G. v. State of Alaska, Department of Family and Community Services,...

Pandemic Remote Work Does Not Establish “Employer Necessity” Under New York’s Convenience-of-the-Employer Rule

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Pandemic Remote Work Does Not Establish “Employer Necessity” Under New York’s Convenience-of-the-Employer Rule 1. Introduction Matter of Zelinsky v Commissioner of Taxation & Fin. of the State of...

NRCP 68 Attorney-Fee Awards in Contingency Cases Must Reflect Only Post-Offer Work (Overruling Capriati’s “Incurred Post-Offer” Rule)

Date: Jul 3, 2026

NRCP 68 Attorney-Fee Awards in Contingency Cases Must Reflect Only Post-Offer Work (Overruling Capriati’s “Incurred Post-Offer” Rule) 1. Introduction In Clark v. Marin (Nev. July 2, 2026), the...

Harmless Initial-Appearance Right-to-Counsel Error and Use of “Tie-Breaker” Authority in High-Conflict Joint Custody

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Harmless Initial-Appearance Right-to-Counsel Error and Use of “Tie-Breaker” Authority in High-Conflict Joint Custody Case: Matter of Jimmy PP. v Jennifer QQ. | Court: Appellate Division, Third...

Custody Modification Requires a Post-Order Change Beyond Conditions Contemplated by a Consent Order; Single, Purpose-Linked Social Media Post Insufficient for Harassment/Stalking

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Custody Modification Requires a Post-Order Change Beyond Conditions Contemplated by a Consent Order; Single, Purpose-Linked Social Media Post Insufficient for Harassment/Stalking 1. Introduction...

Collateral Consequences Preserve Article 10 Appeals Despite Post-Order Criminal Plea; Prima Facie Abuse May Be Found Against Multiple Caretakers Without Pinpointing the Perpetrator

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Collateral Consequences Preserve Article 10 Appeals Despite Post-Order Criminal Plea; Prima Facie Abuse May Be Found Against Multiple Caretakers Without Pinpointing the Perpetrator 1. Introduction...

Post-Remand Judicial Review May Raise Prior Remand-Order Jurisdiction, but Only if the New Petition Strictly Complies with NRS 233B.130(2)(a)

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Post-Remand Judicial Review May Raise Prior Remand-Order Jurisdiction, but Only if the New Petition Strictly Complies with NRS 233B.130(2)(a) Case: ROCHA v. STATE, DEP'T OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERV.,...

Voluntariness of Statements After Miranda Where Initial Handcuffing Was by Another Agency and Police Promised the Suspect Would Go Home

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Voluntariness of Statements After Miranda Where Initial Handcuffing Was by Another Agency and Police Promised the Suspect Would Go Home 1. Introduction People v Brown (2026 NY Slip Op 04233 [App Div...

Rule 25 Substitution After Death Requires an Estate-Based “Proper Party”; “Distributee” Is Not an Open-Ended Category

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Rule 25 Substitution After Death Requires an Estate-Based “Proper Party”; “Distributee” Is Not an Open-Ended Category 1. Introduction In Human Rights Commission v. Homer Durkee (2026 VT 27), the...

Matter of Ethan H. — Dismissal in Furtherance of Justice When Juvenile Delinquency Is Used to Solve Placement Problems

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Matter of Ethan H. — Dismissal in Furtherance of Justice When Juvenile Delinquency Is Used to Solve Placement Problems 1. Introduction Matter of Ethan H. (2026 NY Slip Op 04252 [3d Dept July 2,...

Matter of El Shamar B.: Record-Based Proof (Not Self-Serving Accounts) Controls “Dangerous Mental Disorder” Track-One Findings Under CPL 330.20

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Matter of El Shamar B.: Record-Based Proof (Not Self-Serving Accounts) Controls “Dangerous Mental Disorder” Track-One Findings Under CPL 330.20 1. Introduction Matter of El Shamar B. (Appellate...

People v. Hollman: Out-of-State Child Concealment Can Support Second-Degree Kidnapping Despite a Custodial Parent’s Participation; “Sole Purpose” Relative Defense Narrowly Construed and New York Territorial Jurisdiction Sustained

Date: Jul 3, 2026

People v. Hollman: Out-of-State Child Concealment Can Support Second-Degree Kidnapping Despite a Custodial Parent’s Participation; “Sole Purpose” Relative Defense Narrowly Construed and New York...