Puerto Rico Case Commentaries

Fourth Circuit Leaves Intact Constitutional Protection for Specified Intelligence-Agency Termination Procedures

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Fourth Circuit Leaves Intact Constitutional Protection for Specified Intelligence-Agency Termination Procedures Case: John Doe 1 v. Office of the Director of National Intelligence Court: United...

Anders Review After Resentencing: The Mandate Rule Limits Which Issues May Be Reopened

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Anders Review After Resentencing: The Mandate Rule Limits Which Issues May Be Reopened United States v. Marquis Mack, No. 25-4622, United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, November 3,...

Removal Unanimity Extends to Diverse Defendants, and Improper-Joinder Review Must Not Become a Merits Trial

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Removal Unanimity Extends to Diverse Defendants, and Improper-Joinder Review Must Not Become a Merits Trial Case: Guerdan v. State Automobile Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth...

Union-Election Challenges: Credibility, Agency, and Dissemination Under Substantial-Evidence Review

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Union-Election Challenges: Credibility, Agency, and Dissemination Under Substantial-Evidence Review Case: NLRB v. Hotel Equities Group Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit...

Olivas v. City of Midland: No Plain Error in Finding an Accommodation-Based Retaliation Claim Unexhausted

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Olivas v. City of Midland: No Plain Error in Finding an Accommodation-Based Retaliation Claim Unexhausted Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit Date: November 3, 2026 Case: No....

Failed Sobriety Tests and Probable Cause: Municipal Liability Requires an Underlying Constitutional Violation

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Failed Sobriety Tests and Probable Cause: Municipal Liability Requires an Underlying Constitutional Violation Case: Qashou v. City of San Antonio, No. 25-51051 Court: United States Court of Appeals...

Orally Adopted Supervised-Release Conditions: Record-Based Affirmance Despite Unverified Counsel Review

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Orally Adopted Supervised-Release Conditions: Record-Based Affirmance Despite Unverified Counsel Review United States v. Bell, No. 25-20208, United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit,...

Unauthorized Successive Habeas Petitions: Transfer Is the Rule, Dismissal the Exception

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Unauthorized Successive Habeas Petitions: Transfer Is the Rule, Dismissal the Exception Madden v. Herbert, No. 26-485, United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, decided November 4, 2026....

Pro Se Claims Must Satisfy Jurisdiction, Plausible Pleading, and Appellate Preservation Requirements

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Pro Se Claims Must Satisfy Jurisdiction, Plausible Pleading, and Appellate Preservation Requirements Case: Aaebo-Akhan v. Akhan, No. 26-3009 Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth...

Court Access Requires an Arguable Claim; Prison Transfers Cannot Punish Protected Grievances

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Court Access Requires an Arguable Claim; Prison Transfers Cannot Punish Protected Grievances Jones v. Brown United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit No. 24-1442 — November 4, 2026...

Advocacy for the Agreed Sentencing Recommendation Does Not, Without More, Breach a Plea Agreement

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Advocacy for the Agreed Sentencing Recommendation Does Not, Without More, Breach a Plea Agreement Case: United States v. Tuell, No. 26-5086 Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit...

Child-Contact Restrictions May Stand When the Sentencing Record Supplies the Rationale

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Child-Contact Restrictions May Stand When the Sentencing Record Supplies the Rationale Case: United States v. Dovid Akiva Shenkman Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit Date:...

Tailored Filing Restrictions Upheld for Repetitive Rule 60 Litigation; Suing the Judge Alone Does Not Require Recusal

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Tailored Filing Restrictions Upheld for Repetitive Rule 60 Litigation; Suing the Judge Alone Does Not Require Recusal Case: William Kaetz v. Educational Credit Management Corp., No. 26-1877 Court:...

Federal Civil-Rights Claims Arising from Family-Court Disputes Require Specific Constitutional Allegations

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Federal Civil-Rights Claims Arising from Family-Court Disputes Require Specific Constitutional Allegations Case: Courtney Innocenti v. Eric Miller Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Third...

Assumed Guidelines Error Is Harmless When the Record Establishes That the Same Sentence Would Be Imposed

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Assumed Guidelines Error Is Harmless When the Record Establishes That the Same Sentence Would Be Imposed Case: United States v. John Pollard, No. 26-1860 Court: United States Court of Appeals for the...

Federal Drug-Trafficking Conspiracy as an Aggravated Felony and the Evidentiary Requirements for CAT Protection

Date: Nov 7, 2026

Federal Drug-Trafficking Conspiracy as an Aggravated Felony and the Evidentiary Requirements for CAT Protection Case: Edwin Reyes v. Attorney General United States of America Court: United States...

Distinctive Drug Packaging May Permit Warrantless Opening After a Consensual Intruder Sweep

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Distinctive Drug Packaging May Permit Warrantless Opening After a Consensual Intruder Sweep Case: United States v. Jamill McDonald, No. 25-3344 Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth...

A Below-Guidelines Sentence Does Not Defeat Prejudice from an Invalid Drug-Prior Enhancement

Date: Nov 6, 2026

A Below-Guidelines Sentence Does Not Defeat Prejudice from an Invalid Drug-Prior Enhancement Case: Deandre Cherry v. United States Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit...

United States v. Morgan: Dost Jury Instructions and the Production of Lascivious Images from Innocent Conduct

Date: Nov 6, 2026

United States v. Morgan: Dost Jury Instructions and the Production of Lascivious Images from Innocent Conduct Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit Decision date: November 5,...

Abandoning Acceleration Restores the Original Maturity Date for Colorado Foreclosure Limitations

Date: Nov 6, 2026

Abandoning Acceleration Restores the Original Maturity Date for Colorado Foreclosure Limitations Case: Jensen v. Bank of New York Mellon Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit...